Cost Benefit Analysis : The Cost Of Tragedy Essay

Cost Benefit Analysis : The Cost Of Tragedy Essay

Length: 1761 words (5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Cost-benefit analysis is an economic approach decision making that compares the strengths and weaknesses of each choice in order to determine which option will provide the most amount of benefits and the least amount of costs. This method is often applied to decisions that concern the environment as an attempt to determine the value of the environment before following through with decisions to preserve or utilize the environment for resources. Although many economists believe that cost-benefit analysis is an efficient way to make most decisions, some philosophers suggest that certain things, including the environment, have innumerable values, therefore, cost-benefit analysis may not be a reliable method to make decisions regarding these things. In “The Cost of Tragedy,” Martha Nussbaum differentiates between what she calls an “obvious question” and a “tragic question,” and argues that all decision makers must ask the “tragic question” in order to determine if any or all options violate some moral principle. Depending on whether the answer to this question is “yes” or “no” will determine how much one should rely on cost-benefit analysis to determine the best option and prevent tragedies from reoccurring the future. Another perspective of the reliability cost-benefit analysis is presented in Andrew Brennan’s “Ethics, ecology and economics,” where he argues that cost-benefit analysis and economism in general cannot determine the true value of the environment, and thus cannot provide adequate environmental philosophy. Along with this, in “A Place for Cost-Benefit Analysis,” David Schmidtz argues that although it is not perfect, if cost-benefit analysis is applied with consideration to externalities beyond just the economic costs of de...


... middle of paper ...


...arantee that we have considered everything. In the real world, we must acknowledge that for any actual calculation we perform, there could be some cost or benefit or risk we have overlooked” (162). Schmidtz acknowledges that human decision makers cannot possibility account for every single external cost, but he does claim that this limit can be accounted for if the decision is opened to the public for scrutiny. For Schmidtz, public deliberation of a decision is a practical way for a decision maker to account for the most externalities to avoid moral violation of many people (163). Although cost-benefit analysis is not a perfect formula that can always determine morally perfect decisions, choices will always have to be made, and Schmidtz argues that cost-benefit analysis—when it accounts for external costs—is the most practical method to determine the best option.



Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on The Public Benefit View Of Government Regulation

- In each of the three scenarios presented in the case, opponents and proponents have divergent views of government regulations. One view is on the public benefit, the other is on the cost to private industry. How can you decide which view to accept. Currently being a member of the public, I would side with the benefit viewpoint. I also must imagine that people in the private industry, albeit concerned with their company and its profits, also enjoy the world that they live in and don’t want to see it burned to the ground....   [tags: Cost-benefit analysis, Cost, Regulation]

Better Essays
711 words (2 pages)

Cost Benefits Of Cost Benefit Analysis Essay

- Cost benefit analysis, abbreviated as CBA, is a tool derived from utilitarianism to help businesses compare the costs of carrying out and the benefits that result from a decision. It lays down a set of guidelines that help businesses compare the costs and benefits of each available option and figure out which is the best option to choose. (Velsaquez, 63) A simple scenario utilizing cost benefit analysis is judging the production value of item “x”. If the “benefits” or the revenue made from selling “x” is high enough to cover the monetary costs, the costs of the time spent on the product, and produce profit, then cost benefit analysis would state that “x” is worth making because the benefit...   [tags: Cost, Cost-benefit analysis, Decision theory]

Better Essays
1074 words (3.1 pages)

Cost -benefit Analysis And Risk Assessment Essay

- Cost -Benefit Analysis and Risk Assessment Any pathological or medical institution should carry out any decision to implement Blood-bank System products and services on a thorough analysis of the costs and benefits associated with such action. Some of the reasons institutions offer Blood-bank services include: • Lower operating costs, • To improve or maintain their competitive position. • Increased customer demand for services, and • New revenue opportunities. • Availability of database to take strategic decisions • Reduce the labour cost • Automate the working for customer and staff ease....   [tags: Cost, Cost-benefit analysis, Costs, Optimism bias]

Better Essays
711 words (2 pages)

Organizational Change : Tragedy Or Transformation Essay

- Leadership & Change Cornelius Cash Grand Canyon University LDR825-Organizational Change: Tragedy or Transformation July 6, 2016 Introduction The method used in articulating change management depends on the type of organization and leadership style of the leader. In an organization that has a transactional leader the tools of reward and punishment are utilized in the change management process (Bass, 2008). Miscommunication has a high impact on change within a low skilled, highly directive work environment....   [tags: Organization, Management, Leadership]

Better Essays
732 words (2.1 pages)

In the Heart of the Sea: The Tragedy of the Whaleship by Nathaniel Philbrick

- Introduction The book “In the Heart of the Sea: The Tragedy of the Whaleship Essex” by Nathaniel Philbrick is tragic, eyes widening and heart wrenching where all the morals and ethics are gravely subjected to situation and questioned when it comes to survival. What they must do for survival. How man love their lives and no matter what strikes upon them, holler from behind, ambush their morale, yet they want to keep going just for the sake of living. The book is epitome of such a situation that encounters survival over morality....   [tags: morals and ethics, captains, risk]

Free Essays
1232 words (3.5 pages)

Essay on Tragedy of the Commons: Overfishing the World’s Oceans

- Introduction Economic activity and our environment have been closely linked since man first discovered the concept of trade. In the language of economics, the environment has itself, become an increasingly “scarce resource1”. Since economics is about managing these scarce resources, it will be a useful tool when considering some of the environmental issues facing our planet. One of the major concerns confronting the environment today is the overfishing of the world’s oceans, depleting some species to near extinction....   [tags: Economy, Demand, Fishing]

Better Essays
1697 words (4.8 pages)

The Cost Of Purchasing 5000 Devices Essay

- Part A: 1) The cost of purchasing 5000 devices (DD11) per year = $14 × 5000 = $70,000 After discontinuing the manufacture of devices: The direct materials = 0 The direct labor = 0 The variable factory overhead costs = 20% × $30,000 = $6,000 The fixed factory overhead costs = $55,000 - $2,000 = $53,000 Manufacturing the devices ( DD11 ) Purchasing the devices ( DD11 ) from an outside supplier The incremental cost or benefit Total manufacturing costs ( $190,000 ) 0 $190,000 Costs of purchasing the devices 0 ($70,000) ( $70,000 ) Fixed factory overhead costs ($6,000)...   [tags: Costs, Cost, Variable cost, Cost-benefit analysis]

Better Essays
1668 words (4.8 pages)

Essay Improving The Cost Of Poct Technology

- I. Introduction When patients are in the hospital, they are often tested for many diseases and conditions. In fact, many hospitals have clinical testing areas and labs for testing saliva blood, and urine. However, these labs require a large amount of manpower and time to test samples, collect data, and analyze results. POCT (Point-of-Care Testing) is bedside testing for patients. Although POCT technologies provide many benefits such as, reduced testing time, decreased turnaround time, increased portability, and produced more accurate results, high costs have inhibited many facilities from purchasing and using POCT technologies....   [tags: Cost-benefit analysis, Cost, Costs, Optimism bias]

Better Essays
1239 words (3.5 pages)

The Formal Cost-benefit Analysis Essay examples

- The formal cost-benefit analysis compares the monetary benefits and costs of government actions that would be aimed at improving public well being. Analysts approximate legal benefits using various estimating techniques. Measurement problems can also lead to some important cost-benefit categories that being ignored, in which the results can be subject to wide perception in biased debates. It is reasonable to expect that these factors would result in some reduction and adjustment as well as administrative and lawful delay of eagerness for good....   [tags: American Government, economics, Finance]

Free Essays
500 words (1.4 pages)

Environmental Cost-Benefit Analysis Essay

- The overall goal of this cost-benefit analysis (CBA) is to determine if purchasing the manufacturing facility, cleaning up the spill, and the income generated from said building will be worth the expenditures. In other words, is the cost and effort going to payoff in the end. To conduct an effective cost-benefit analysis a thorough study of the grounds and building where the spill occurred would need to be completed. Since we have a hypothetical of the spill and associated damage done I, as the Environmental & Safety Manager, would put together an outline or type of plan of action to ensure I cover all necessary steps necessary to conduct a thorough cost benefit analysis....   [tags: expenditures, damage, spill]

Better Essays
625 words (1.8 pages)