Classroom Mixtures for the Gifted- Homogeneous or Heterogeneous?- Article Review

Classroom Mixtures for the Gifted- Homogeneous or Heterogeneous?- Article Review

Length: 1170 words (3.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Classroom Mixtures for the Gifted- Homogeneous or Heterogeneous?

John H. Holloway in his article, “Grouping Gifted Students”, looks at research to the question of whether or not gifted students can receive effective instruction in the regular classroom. He wants to know if researchers agree with Lisa Benson, a classroom teacher, who says no. Her reasoning is the gifted students become frustrated especially if they have a high degree of creativity and resources are not available in the regular classroom.
Holloway first looks at the question from the homogeneous versus heterogeneous grouping perspective. From this perspective two researchers, Renuzulli and Mesler, found that the regular (heterogeneous) classroom could serve the gifted students. Renuzulli suggested that teachers would need special training or access to specialists. The four other researches cited found homogenous grouping was better for gifted students. Burns and Mason found this was true because “the higher ability classes received better instruction or had higher ability teachers and benefited from high-ability classmates” (p.89). In another research, Rogers concluded that gifted students need some form of ability grouping to broaden and extend their curriculum. Shields found that homogeneous grouping had a positive effect on the attitudes of the gifted and how they felt about themselves as learners and the school experience. The study by Gentry, Rizza, and Owen expressed concern that there was little differentiation for the gifted students in the heterogeneous classroom.
The research of mixed-ability group options was next looked at by Holloway. Tomlinson’s research says the gifted can receive effective instruction in a differentiated classroom. However, s...

... middle of paper ...

...estion is not usually asked. Students at the high school level tend to want to take the easy way out.
I think if I had to make the decision at my school, based on research and on my experiences I would choose to have homogenous grouping for the gifted students. My biggest challenge would be as to what criteria to use. Would it be ability, areas of giftedness, or some other criteria?

Holloway, J. (2003, October). Grouping Gifted Students. Educational Leadership, 61, 89-91. Retrieved January 29, 2010, from

Holloway, J. (2003, October). Grouping Gifted Students. Educational Leadership, 61, 89-91. Retrieved January 29, 2010, from

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Gifted and Talented Education Research Paper

- Gifted and Talented Education Research Paper It is important to understand the many different methods of educating gifted and talented students. Most people, whether as teachers, students, or parents, will at some point be faced with the many options of educating the gifted and talented. In the United States today, 3-5 percent of students are considered gifted. Defining whether or not a student is gifted can be quite difficult, but many would agree that gifted students “are able to learn material rapidly and understand concepts deeply” (Lynch, 1999)....   [tags: essays papers]

Strong Essays
2674 words (7.6 pages)

A Working Definition Of Gifted And Talented Essay

- Before moving on in the research, a working definition of gifted and talented needs to be developed. This definition has evolved on both the federal and the state level. The first definition was given by the federal government in The Education Amendments of 1969 (Stephens & Karnes, 2000). It defines gifted and talented as “’children who have outstanding intellectual ability or creative talent, the development of which requires special activities or services not ordinarily provided by local education agencies ‘” (Stephens & Karnes, 2000, p....   [tags: Teacher, Education, Gifted education]

Strong Essays
799 words (2.3 pages)

Gifted Underachievers Essay

- Sylvia Rimm and Linda Emerick both discuss the reversal of underachieving gifted students. Both articles address the characteristics and/or behavioral patterns of gifted underachievers as well as how the process of underachieving may be reversed. Rimm states, that “being intellectually or creatively gifted does not assure educational or creative success or productivity. There are risks and pressures that…detour potentially high-achieving children (Colangelo & Davis, 2003, p. 424).” Both authors agree that the risks and pressures that may result in underachievement include the pressure to achieve and feelings of inadequacy when goals are not attained (Emerick, 1992, p....   [tags: Education, gifted students, ]

Strong Essays
943 words (2.7 pages)

Critical Thinking Is A Good Strategy For Gifted Student Essay

- There are many strategies that are helping all students to meet their education needs, one of the strategy is Critical-Thinking. Critical-Thinking is a good strategy for gifted student. I believe that using the critical thinking will help students gain self-esteem and teaching to their thinking. Teacher should has the idea to use critical thinking and when he or she can use this strategy and improve students thinking. I found study that was talking about the Dixon-Hegelian method. That study used with 4th and 5th grade class of gifted in the spring semester of the 1998-99 school year....   [tags: Critical thinking, Education, Gifted education]

Strong Essays
804 words (2.3 pages)

Flipped Classrooms : The Flipped Classroom Essay

- Many teachers have begun using the flipped classroom model in their high schools. This new teaching approach has proven to be quite controversial among students, parents, teachers, and other school staff. Each individual’s values affect whether or not he or she believes high schools should utilize the flipped classroom model. This essay will first describe what a typical flipped classroom looks like; then, it will explain how certain values, such as individualized learning, responsibility and student ownership, equal opportunity, and face-to-face interactions, influence views about high schools employing the flipped classrooms model in their courses....   [tags: High school, Education, Learning, Classroom]

Strong Essays
1232 words (3.5 pages)

Gifted and Talented Case Study Essay

- After reading Eduardo’s situation I believe that his instruction that he has been given does not cater to his interest such as role playing such as he would do in the Hispanic drama club. I would need to incorporate Eduardo’s strengths in my 9th grade history lessons. If there is a gifted and talented program in the high school that I am teaching in, I would refer him to the gifted and talented program. Students who are labeled as gifted and talented in the classroom face challenges of acceptance from their peers....   [tags: Case Study]

Strong Essays
1541 words (4.4 pages)

Essay about Helping Gifted Learners Soar by VanTassel-Baska

- Question 1 Based on the information you have read in the text and any experiences you have had as a teacher, what do you think are the issues gifted students face as they go through school. Based from the information provided by VanTassel-Baska, et. Al. (2009), gifted and talented students face the same issues as their regular peers but they have different way of viewing these issues and it affects them differently as well. The book discussed different issues that gifted learners face and recommendations on how to address these issues were also available for teachers, administrators and other school personnel....   [tags: gifted and talented students]

Strong Essays
1069 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on Inclusion Of A Special Education Classroom

- Inclusion Model in Classrooms; Yes or No. Issue Inclusion of all students in classrooms has been an ongoing issue for the past twenty-five years (Noll, 2013). The controversy is should special education students be placed in an inclusion setting or should they be placed in a special education classroom. If the answer is yes to all special education students being placed in inclusion, then how should the inclusion model look. Every students is to receive a free an appropriate education. According to the Individual Education Act (IDEA), all students should be placed in the Least Restrictive Learning Environment (Noll, 2013)....   [tags: Special education, Education, Gifted education]

Strong Essays
1880 words (5.4 pages)

Essay on Homogeneous Tracking In Schools

- Homogeneous tracking has too many negative effects and not enough benefits to be used much longer. Homogeneous tracking has no positive long term effects. It negatively affects the students placed in low and average ability classes, whereas detracking has been proven to help those students. Detracking has been extremely promising, showing benefits both academically and socially. The bad far outweighs the good, so students should not be tracked homogeneously. Homogeneous tracking has not yet shown any positive long term effects....   [tags: essays research papers]

Strong Essays
512 words (1.5 pages)

Essay about Gifted Students and Social Stigma

- Gifted Students and Social Stigma Philosopher Benedict Spinoza said, "Man is a social animal" (Kaplan 278). The desire for social acceptance, whether recognized or denied, is part of human culture. People yearn for it, obsess over it, and alter themselves to obtain it. Humans can spend their entire lives unsuccessfully attempting to achieve a level of social status they believe will validate them. Acceptance is denied for superficial reasons varying from clothing to cliques. However, it is also denied due to innate elements of personality....   [tags: Sociology Psychology Research Papers]

Strong Essays
6007 words (17.2 pages)