Essay about The Case Of Marbury V. Madison

Essay about The Case Of Marbury V. Madison

Length: 728 words (2.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The case of Marbury v. Madison was a monumental United States Supreme Court case. It is the case to which judicial review came to be. The case was brought to the Supreme Court by William Marbury against James Madison. It was a critical ruling based on interpretation, and still impacts modern law.
William Marbury was appointed to be Justice of the Peace in the District of Columbia, by President John Adams. However, President Adams failed to finalize his commission before leaving office. James Madison then refused to issue the documents. This is when William Marbury petitioned the Supreme Court to order James Madison, the new Secretary of State to produce the documents. The supreme court ruled that while the withholding of the documents was illegal, they did not have the authority to order Madison to produce the documents. The Supreme Court, headed by Chief Justice John Marshall would not order James Madison to produce the commission for Marbury, but instead stated that it was unconstitutional for Marbury to bring his case to the Supreme Court. This was because the Judiciary Act of 1798 was found to be unconstitutional because it exceeded the powers of the court that was stated in the Constitution. Marshall stated in his decision that, "In denying his request, the Court held that it lacked jurisdiction because Section 13 of the Judiciary Act passed by Congress in 1789, which authorized the Court to issue such a writ, was unconstitutional and thus invalid.” (Duignan,2009)
Marbury vs. Madison was so monumental because it was the first time that it was found that the Constitution and Judiciary Act conflict. Marshall then concluded that Judiciary Acts do not trump the Constitution. This means that if an act of congress contradicts the...


... middle of paper ...


...was to have the power to legislate. Allowing the Supreme Court to overturn passed laws, that were the will of the people and make them null and void, leave some to feel this has upset the balance of powers between the three legislative branches. (Coffey, 2012) President Jefferson disagreed with the ruling of Marbury vs. Madison, and even tried to have it overturned, though it was unsuccessful due to the lack of congressional support to make a constitutional amendment allowing it to be overturned.
Today it is accepted by most, that the Supreme Court has final authority over the United States law. Even though Marbury v. Madison happened many years ago, it still plays a pivotal role in our current government. The ruling of Marbury v. Madison set the precedent allowing the people of the United States, our legislation, and government to all be subject to judicial review.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about The Case Of Marbury V. Madison

- The case of Marbury v. Madison was a monumental United States Supreme Court case. It is the case to which judicial review came to be. The case was brought to the Supreme Court by William Marbury against James Madison. It was a critical ruling based on interpretation, and still impacts modern law. William Marbury was appointed to be Justice of the Peace in the District of Columbia, by President John Adams. However, President Adams failed to finalize his commission before leaving office. James Madison then refused to issue the documents....   [tags: Supreme Court of the United States]

Better Essays
728 words (2.1 pages)

The Case of Marbury v. Madison Essay

- ... Adams signed the appointment and Marshall sealed it thereby giving Marbury legal right to the office he was appointed to. Therefore, denying delivery of the appointment to him was a violation of his rights and the law provides him remedy. The third question was to determine whether the Supreme Court had the authority to review acts of Congress for their constitutionality. The Court decided that it did have such authority to determine whether laws were unconstitutional and void. The judiciary has the duty to interpret the law and determine if a law violates any part of the Constitution....   [tags: supreme court, jurisdiction , congress]

Better Essays
989 words (2.8 pages)

The Case Of Marbury Vs. Madison Essays

- What is most remarkable about the case of Marbury vs. Madison is the clever way in which Chief Justice John Marshall approached the Court’s final decision. He and his colleagues decided to use a three-pronged test to determine whether or not Mr. Marbury was entitled to the reprieve he was seeking. And it seemed as if he would. But then, two-thirds of the way into the Court’s opinion, Marshall decided to refer back to the Judiciary Act of 1789. After careful review, he announced that this writ of mandamus in particular was actually an expansion of original jurisdiction....   [tags: Supreme Court of the United States]

Better Essays
1058 words (3 pages)

The Case Of Marbury Vs. Madison Essay example

- America’s foundation has been built upon the principles of democracy. All people of the nation are represented through selected individuals who work solely for the ideals of the governed. America’s specific government functions from three different branches; Legislative (House and Congress), Judicial (Court Systems), and Executive (President). Having three different branches of government enables each branch to constantly access one another, so one does not get more powerful than the other. This is a system of checks and balances....   [tags: Separation of powers, United States]

Better Essays
728 words (2.1 pages)

The Case Marbury V. Madison Essay examples

- Judicial Assignment The United States was founded on the principle that the law not man governed, the law being manifested in the Constitution which in 1787 was ratified as the supreme law of the land. Its success is due in large part to the vagueness and relative freedom it allows in interpreting its meaning, having very limited explicit passages. Such vagueness extends to the basic principle of enforcing the laws of the country which although agreed upon by the states, nevertheless provides no effective means by which they are to be enforced....   [tags: Supreme Court of the United States]

Better Essays
996 words (2.8 pages)

The Court Case of Marbury v. Madison and Judicial Review Essays

- ... Here is the contradiction to popular belief. Marshall was not a pioneer for the creation of fair and equal government, he was really trying to make a decision that would protect his position while pleasing both the Federalists and the Democratic-Republicans. This is most accurately described by Robert G. McCloskey: “ a mastery of indirection [is]…Marshall’s ability to sidestep danger while seeming to court it, to advance in one direction while his opponents are looking another”(Clinton 6). Marshall’s actions were fueled by political concerns, not legal....   [tags: supreme courts, federalists, justice]

Better Essays
866 words (2.5 pages)

Important Court Case in American History: Marbury v. Madison Essay

- Arguably the most important court case in American History, Marbury v. Madison was a revolutionary decision that set precedent unparalleled to any other court case. This case, which regarded the midnight appointment of Marbury, a justice, is more important for its effects than the actual ruling. It established the incredibly important judicial review; the Supreme Court’s power to declare acts of congress unconstitutional, and balanced the judicial branch with other branches. Marbury v. Madison, the most important American court case, began with the election of 1800....   [tags: judiciary, appointment, precident]

Better Essays
541 words (1.5 pages)

Marbury v. Madison: Judicial Review Essay

- In the case of Marbury v. Madison the power of judicial review was granted to the Supreme Court in 1801. The Constitution does not give power of judicial review. On Adams last day in office, several government officials upheld the case. Judicial review does not exist in countries that have a centralized or unitary form of government. The elected parliament declares it is the law of the land. Halsema Proposal to Netherlands has taken the initiative to start the process of judicial review. President John Adams and the Federalist lost the election to Thomas Jefferson....   [tags: Marbury v. Madison]

Better Essays
1021 words (2.9 pages)

Marbury V. Madison ( 1803 ) Essay

- Marbury v. Madison (1803) is one of the most important cases in the history of the Supreme Court. It began in 1800, with the beginning of the Democratic-Republican party of Thomas Jefferson (McBride). John Adams of the Federalist Party had just been defeated and creating political alarm for the group (McBride). John Adams in his final days of presidency decided to appoint a great number of justices of the peace (McBride). The new President Jefferson and his Republicans were infuriated with Adams act before he left office....   [tags: Thomas Jefferson, James Madison]

Better Essays
711 words (2 pages)

Essay about Marbury V. Madison ( 1803 )

- Derek Bloom Marbury v. Madison (1803) Introduction Marbury v. Madison (1803) refers to a landmark case in US law that laid the basis for the application of judicial review, particularly under Article three of the Constitution. The outcome of the case helped define the limits between the country’s distinct executive and judicial branches. Marbury v. Madison (1803) came about after William Marbury’s application to the (SC) Supreme Court. The application came after President John Adams appointed him as Justice of the Peace....   [tags: Supreme Court of the United States]

Better Essays
1743 words (5 pages)