Billy Joe Carter Case Study

878 Words2 Pages

Case 1
a. The ethical issues for this case would be whether or not Billy Joe Carter should claim business deductions in regards to his four-wheel drive truck relating to his “business trips.” Billy has indicated that the expenses associated with several trips to Las Vegas were also primarily of a business nature. There were also other large deductions without providing any substantial documentation or evidence.
b. Per the Internal Revenue Code (IRC) Section 162, the key words relating to the case would be that business expenses are allowed for “ordinary and necessary expenses…on any trade or business.” What constitutes as an ordinary and necessary business expense would be that ordinary means that it is a common expense and is accepted in …show more content…

One option that Helen may opt to take would be that Helen may trust Billy and assist in preparing his tax return that includes a plethora of business deductions for business expenses “associated with several trips to Las Vegas…’primarily of a business nature.’” Billy also claimed several other large deductions without providing substantial documentation or evidence to support his claim. With all of the information and facts that are gathered, however, Helen may analyze the situation and make a determination that per IRC Section 162, Billy cannot make a business deduction for his personal trips, expenses associated with several trips to Las Vegas, and other large deductions without any documentation or evidence. Therefore, Helen may decide to refuse to provide tax practitioner services for …show more content…

It is best for Helen to refuse to provide tax practitioner services to Billy as per IRC Section 162, it would be highly unethical and incorrect to claim business deductions for personal trips, expenses associated with several trips to Las Vegas, and other large deductions without substantial documentation. This is because Helen also becomes responsible for the tax returns of Honest Bill’s Used Car Lot’s as it indicates that she would “complete and file his return before the April 15 deadline…” The tax governmental agency, presumably the IRS, may randomly decide to conduct an audit to review Bill’s books and records. The tax auditor may inspect the documents that were filed and request for documentation to support his claim for business deductions. Without any substantial documentation or evidence, Billy cannot furnish any documents, and Helen would then become involved in the audit case as she was the CPA tax practitioner who completed and filed his tax return. The tax auditor may then issue an assessment per IRC Section 162, and there may also be additional penalties and

More about Billy Joe Carter Case Study

Open Document