Analysis Of The Article ' Civil Disobedience ' Essay

Analysis Of The Article ' Civil Disobedience ' Essay

Length: 1068 words (3.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

It is said that temptation leads to sin and that all humans are capable of sin. Without laws, chaos would reign and no man would be left unaffected. This is where the concept of government comes into affect. However, the question of how the government should function in humans ' life has been asked since the beginning of its creation. Henry Thoreau has asked this question and came up with the answer that government is essential in human life but the attempt to govern the people should not overstep the bounds of what its citizens needed. In 1849 his article Civil Disobedience was published providing the world with his understanding of the political government and why it should be different. A similar author who believed the government should be changed is Malcolm X. Malcolm X spoke to the black race on April 3, 1964. However, despite Thoreau and Malcolm X both arguing against the structure of the government, Malcolm X 's speech establishes a sense of urgency to take immediate action that Thoreau 's argument lacks, which, thereby, makes Thoreau 's argument weak.



Malcolm X and Thoreau both began their argument by addressing situations taking place in their time period while also creating a connection with their audience through the use of diction. In the beginning of his essay Thoreau casually undermines the government by declaring, " Witness the present Mexican war, the work of comparatively a few individuals using the standing government as their tool, for in the outset, the people would never have consented to this measure." While Thoreau 's audience was mostly well educated men and women who already did not support the Mexican war, Thoreau further turned them against the government system by addressing the govern...


... middle of paper ...


...ed. For example, Malcolm X provides the solution that the black community should stop voting and segregate themselves from the people trying to control them. He produces two important methods to leading the people against the government: emotion and a solution.



Malcolm X and Thoreau are both known for their resistance against the government. Their articles have been studied throughout history and it is certain that they will be studied in the future. Their courage to speck out against the government in an act of selflessness may one day accomplish their articles purpose. In todays society there are problems being brought up that no one spoke of in the past, there are new laws being made that give the government less power than they had. This was the purpose of both Malcolm X and Thoreau. It can be seen that they helped create the world that it is today.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Patriotism and People Who Commit Acts of Civil Disobedience Essay

- ... This is an interesting notion, because the term ‘responsibility’ is far stronger than ‘right’ or ‘freedom’ in this regard. Locke believed, of course, that citizens had the right to rebel against injustice and the freedom to disobey, but he more than that declared that they ethically should rebel if they know their government is unjust. Locke argued that citizens have a duty to follow the law only so far as they have accepted to enter the social contract with their government and that the government is fulfilling its part of the contract....   [tags: liberal democracy, justice, free nation]

Better Essays
2103 words (6 pages)

The Norton Mix : A New Understanding Of Conflict Essay

- The Norton Mix: A New Understanding of Conflict Conflict seems to be a term that has filled our current events, and is present in every flick of the channel. However, the word conflict is shrouded in ambiguity and depending on the source it meaning is hard to truly understand. Considering the fact that the current news media has given the word conflict an abstract presence, by relating events to current news trends instead of reality. By contrast, The Norton Mix has articles that are informative, descriptive, and easy to understand....   [tags: Civil disobedience, Nonviolence]

Better Essays
1273 words (3.6 pages)

The Norton Mix And A New College Student Essay

- After reading The Norton Mix, I found it easy to read and extract information from articles in order understand the authors main point. The Norton Mix, has great articles, which I will mention a few in this paper, and write an analysis concerning conflicts and wars and what binds them together. I would recommend The Norton Mix to a new college student who is not open to new ideas because of its readability attributes. For example each article provides great details and solid supporting evidence which a new college student will be able to seamlessly understand, without reading the article over....   [tags: Civil disobedience, Nonviolence]

Better Essays
1215 words (3.5 pages)

The Moratorium March Essay

- I. Introduction and Historical Context On November 15, 1969, the Moratorium March against the Vietnam War commenced in Washington D.C. Pacifists and peace administrators carried banners which stated, ”A Calvinist for peace, No more war, We want peace now,” and some carried placards bearing the name of soldiers that had died during the war (Leen). The placards that had names of fallen soldiers were first used on November 13, 1969 during the protest called “March against Death.” Two days after this protest, the “Moratorium March” began....   [tags: vietnam war, civil disobedience]

Better Essays
763 words (2.2 pages)

Analysis of Martin Luther King's Essay

- Convincing, Indefatigable and influential are the best adjectives to explain Letter from Birmingham Jail. Martin Luther King Jr's astuteness is enhanced by the astonishing capability to show the unkind and heartless attitude against black community. Throughout the whole writing to the eight clergymen Jr. never get too far from the clash for fairness in Birmingham. As head of the South Christians Leadership Conferences (SCLC), Martin L. King, Junior., in the year 1963 acknowledged Birmingham, Alabama, as "possibly the most carefully segregated city in the United States"....   [tags: Rhetorical Analysis, Civil Rights]

Better Essays
1217 words (3.5 pages)

Essay on Nonviolent Protests And Its Effect On Social Change

- Toulmin Model Claim: Maj: Violent protests destroy property, cost lives, and does little to bring social change. Min: Nonviolent protests have brought about more social change than violent protest. Conclusion: Nonviolent protest are more effective than violent protest in effort to bring about social change. Qualifier: In most cases Ground #1: Peaceful protest brings people together. Data, warrant, backing Peaceful protest brings people together. According to Currans (2014), a group of women gathered outside a library in Manhattan, New York to protest war, rape, ethnic cleansing, and human rights for everyone around the world....   [tags: Protest, Civil disobedience]

Better Essays
2103 words (6 pages)

Silent Justice in a Different Key: Suzy Clarkson Holstein´s Trifles Essay

- I. Article Summary: Suzy Clarkson Holstein's article, “Silent Justice in a Different Key: Glaspell's 'Trifles'” evaluates the play Trifles and how the difference between the men in the play mirror how a woman's perspective is very different from a man's. Trifles is about two women, Mrs. Peters and Mrs. Hale, who show up at a house with their husbands and the county attorney to investigate a murder. The entire time the men are looking for evidence to implicate the accused wife, Minnie Wright, of killing her husband....   [tags: article analysis, women]

Better Essays
615 words (1.8 pages)

The Pros and Cons of Civil Disobedience Essay

- Civil disobedience is the refusal to obey civil laws in an effort to induce change in governmental policy or legislation, characterized by the use of passive resistance or other nonviolent means. The use of nonviolence runs throughout history however the fusion of organized mass struggle and nonviolence is relatively new. The militant campaign for women’s suffrage in Britain included a variety of nonviolent tactics such as boycotts, noncooperation, limited property destruction, civil disobedience, mass marches and demonstrations....   [tags: Civil Disobedience Essays]

Free Essays
1017 words (2.9 pages)

Essay about The Need For Civil Disobedience

- To grasp the meaning of Civil Disobedience one would have to say that it means the refusal to obey the civil laws so that the government can change the policy or legislation, characterized by the use of. I have read Thoreau’s essay on civil disobedience and the obligation that your conscience mind follows and in reading this it states that people should not let the governments overrule or atrophy their consciences and that we as people are obligated to not allow the government to make them agents of any type of injustice....   [tags: Civil Disobedience Essays]

Better Essays
1281 words (3.7 pages)

Essay on Civil Disobedience

- Civil disobedience has been around for a long time. In Bible times Christians would disobey laws that would go against their beliefs, such as the law that they couldn’t preach. (Acts 4) Christians still disobey laws in many countries that do not let them practice their faith, some end up in jail or killed. In the past in this country, Thoreau wrote an essay on Civil disobedience saying that people make the law and have a right to disobey unjust laws, to try and get those laws changed. Under British rule in India, the British were harshly oppressive and only interested in exploiting products from India for their own use, causing many Indians to become extremely poor....   [tags: Civil Disobedience Essays]

Free Essays
577 words (1.6 pages)