Alex Mckinnon Should Sue The National Rugby League Essay

Alex Mckinnon Should Sue The National Rugby League Essay

Length: 1310 words (3.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The question today is whether Alex McKinnon should sue the National Rugby League for the injuries he sustained in a game last year. Well today learned colleagues, I will argue that he should not sue the NRL on the basis of negligence. First and foremost, on behalf of the National Rugby League and myself, we would like to extend our condolences for such a horrendous situation and we wish him all the best.
Representing the defence, the nature of this case regards clams that the NRL was negligent in relation to Alex’s three way tackle in a game between the Newcastle Knights and the Melbourne Storm. This tackle saw Alex come into contact with Jordan McLean, Jesse Bromwich, and Kenny Bromwich, in which he was lifted up and awkwardly landing on his neck, which consequently saw him become paralysed. To quote Alex’s then coach of the Knights, Wayne Bennett, “It’s sad and extremely disappointing for him. There is not much we can do about it” (Sydney Morning Herald 2014.)
Correspondingly, that is the unfortunate truth. Alex’s unforeseen paralysis is indeed ill-fated and an extreme circumstance. However, the NRL does not have the power to correct his injuries; it is beyond our ability. To claim that the NRL is at fault for Alex’s injuries is a far cry as our duty of care does not extend, nor directly fall with him. That duty of care falls to the club itself as we merely act as an organisational sporting body. As his duty of care directly falls to the Newcastle Knights and the injuries were sustained during a game, we implore the fact that we are not legally liable to be sued for alleged negligent actions because they execution of the tackle was not conducted on our ‘behalf.’
As Alex is arguing that the NRL did have a duty of care, we will ...

... middle of paper ...

...f ensuring to provide the players that we represent rules that are positive and fair for the future of the National Rugby League. Along with the NRL judiciary, it is also truthfully synthesised that we ensure that incidents that occur are regulated and have a fair, independent, and in-house trial. Summarily, the NRL and its judiciary effectively regulate and implement the best for the game. We recognise that the incident that Alex McKinnon was involved with was both an unfortunate and atrocious situation. However, we believe that on the grounds of not having a direct duty of care, the party who is at fault is not the National Rugby League as a whole. We have stated that vicarious liability does not apply in regards to this case and the concept of violenti non fit injuria sees the fact that Alex most certainly would have been aware of the dangers of playing the game.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Betting on Rugby Union Essays

- Betting on Rugby Union Rugby union is a popular betting sport for smart punters especially in its heartlands of Great Britain and mainland Europe. The sport is popular in both hemispheres and is the national sport of New Zealand where it is the most popular winter sport for spectating. This is an emerging betting sport for online bookmakers that serve the Asian markets. The game is played between sides of 15 players with regular exchanges allowed. The side in possession of the ball has an unlimited number of plays in which to score a try, force a drop out or lose possession....   [tags: sport, league, competition]

Strong Essays
523 words (1.5 pages)

Australian Rugby League Essay

- This report investigates the epic battle between the Australian Rugby League which has been around for 87 years and the Super League concept for the control of Rugby League in Australia. One man, Mr Rupert Murdoch, is trying to take over and run a rebel Super League to enhance his power and for financial gain. This Super League is proposed to run in 1996 with a 10 team competition as its prospectus. This report reviews the history of the Australian Rugby League, the battle between Mr.Murdoch and Mr.Packer, the battle of who controls pay television, the players future and junior development....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
2211 words (6.3 pages)

Is Professional Rugby Union Becoming too Dangerous? Essays

- Rugby players are monsters. They have become so big, can they be called human. In this modern day, rugby union is more about how hard you can tackle and how fast you can run, than the rugby. This essay will delve into and explore whether professional rugby union is becoming too dangerous and why this is the case. Was the professionalism of rugby a good idea. Sure, it’s great to watch and exciting to play but at what cost, Death. As a rugby player myself, I believe rugby is a fantastic sport and it is something I know a lot about....   [tags: rugby, rugby players, mouth guards]

Strong Essays
686 words (2 pages)

Sports Culture in New Zealand: Rugby Essay example

- Sports Culture in New Zealand Perspective Sport Culture rugby, in particular plays a major role in the creation of New Zealand’s national identity over the past 140 years. New Zealand is identifiable with its strong ties to Rugby on an international scale. Introduced as contact sport by European men it grew, Rugby Union Clubs began to emerge in cities and towns all over the nation. Sport culture allowed pakeha and Maori to unite, as previously the solidarity of New Zealand culture dwindled beneath the Maori Land Wars of the 19th century....   [tags: Sports, Rugby, New Zealand]

Strong Essays
797 words (2.3 pages)

Drowning Anna by Sue Mayfield Essay

- I read the book Drowning Anna by Sue Mayfield. It is a book about a girl who is forced to deal with a ruthless bully, Hayley Parkin. She also goes through heartbreak, backstabbing, and much more. Anna Goldsmith, the main character of my book, moves from a classy city in London, England, to a small Yorkshire town. At first, she is treated like a queen, mostly because of her movie-star good looks. She has beautiful black hair, and perfect, glowing skin. She is also an A student. She plays the in the orchestra and succeeds in everything that she does....   [tags: Drowning Anna, Sue Mayfield]

Strong Essays
1211 words (3.5 pages)

Different Types of Development Structures and Nature Between Rugby League and Ice Hockey

- Sport development models designed by organisations are created to try and effectively identify the necessary frameworks and strategies implemented to achieve all round success at all levels. Athlete participation is the main focus of all sport development models and is concerned with activities experiences, pathways followed, obstacles overcome and how the sport can monitor its frameworks to achieve a sustainable future for the sport. In recent years there has been increased attention to establish and improve pathways and systems to maximize sport development....   [tags: sport development, athlete participation]

Strong Essays
1285 words (3.7 pages)

Essay about The Effect of Steriods in Major League Baseball

- Baseball is known as America’s pastime and is one of the most popular, respected sports on earth. Since the beginning of the sport, it seemingly advances with technology every year making faster and stronger players. The use of steroids became rampant and spread among players and has carried them away from the true history of the game they play. Controversy still today runs around the sport today about fines, punishments and record breaking. The past two decades of Major League Baseball have been tainted because of the use of performance enhancing drugs, also known as steroids, causing the loss of many fans and the true meaning of America’s favorite sport....   [tags: baseball, steroids, alex rodriguez, mlb]

Strong Essays
1333 words (3.8 pages)

Does Alex Have Learning Disabilities? Essay

- A learning disability is a condition in which a student has a dysfunction in processing information typically found in language-based activities, resulting in interference with learning (Friend, 2014, p.531). According to IDEA, a student must meet specific criteria in order to be identified as having specific learning disabilities. In this paper I will state which criteria according to IDEA specifically qualifies the student as having a learning disability, identify what assessments could be used to also determine whether the student has a learning disability, and lastly I will identify if the student has a learning disability....   [tags: Alex Case Study]

Strong Essays
959 words (2.7 pages)

Essay on The Development of Rugby

- The Development of Rugby In 2003 when England won the World cup all of a sudden thousands of kids wanted to pick up rugby balls and become the ‘next Jonny Wilkinson’ since then the RFU has taken various methods to try and encourage children to take up rugby. Nationally there is the Zurich Premier League, these are the twelve best teams in the country and compete for honours at home and abroad. Then there is division 1, division 2, division 3 north, and division 3 south....   [tags: Papers]

Strong Essays
743 words (2.1 pages)

Essay on Alex La Guma's The Lemon Orchard

- Stable Meaning, the Perversion of Nature, and Discursive Communities in Alex La Guma's "The Lemon Orchard" South African writer Alex La Guma was an active member of his country's non-white liberation movement. One of the 156 people accused in the Treason Trial of 1956, La Guma wrote his first book, A Walk in the Night and Other Stories, in 1962 (Wade 15). "The Lemon Orchard," a story which appeared in this debut work, is a gripping piece about the horror and cruelty of racism. In the story, La Guma describes in chilling detail how a black teacher (who had sought legal redress for being beaten up by his principal and church minister) is roused from his sleep and led to a lemon orchard b...   [tags: Alex La Guma Lemon Orchard]

Strong Essays
5282 words (15.1 pages)