United States v. Alvarez Essay

United States v. Alvarez Essay

Length: 1055 words (3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In United States v. Alvarez, Xavier Alvarez claimed that he was a retired marine who had received the Congressional Medal of Honor in 1987 for being wounded repeatedly by the same person in combat. These claims were made in an attempt to have him gain more respect from his peers. The claim was that Alvarez had violated the Stolen Valor Act of 2005. The Stolen Valor Act of 2005 states that there are protections against claiming to have received some type of military honor, such as the Medal of Honor and other military decorations and awards (GovTrack). The Government stated that there was first amendment value applicable to Alvarez’s false statements, and that his statements caused harm to others. By making this statement, it was argued that the value of the award of Honor would drop and that this type of false speech falls under the same category as speaking falsely on behalf of the government or as a government official. However, since his statements were not made with the intention of financial benefits or special treatment, his false claims may not be illegal because they were made for the purpose of gaining respect.
The case was decided 6-3 in favor of Alvarez. The Supreme Court ruled the Stolen Valor Act unconstitutional in violation of the First Amendment. Justices Kennedy, Roberts, Ginsburg and Sotomayor joined in a plurality opinion. The plurality stated that freedom of speech under the First Amendment protects lying and false statements. Although the lies are frowned upon and socially unacceptable, the First Amendment protects those types of statements. With the application of strict scrutiny to this case, the Justices within the plurality found that the Stolen Valor Act was very broad and if it had more specific restric...

... middle of paper ...

... to Barnum, people who have awards such as the Purple Heart and Medal of Honor effect not only those who hold them, but those that see others wearing them. Being a decorated veteran will change another person’s perspective of someone, even without meeting him or her previously. Barnum argues that these lies are detrimental to society and the government needs to do its job to protect its symbols and awards (Barnum, 849).

Works Cited

Speech Restrictions That Don't Much Affect the Autonomy of Speakers [comments]
Constitutional Commentary, Vol. 27, Issue 2 (Fall 2011), pp. 347-360 Volokh, Eugene 27 Const. Comment. 347 (2010-2011)

False Valor: Amending the Stolen Valor Act to Conform with the First Amendment's Fraudulent Speech Exception [article]
Washington Law Review, Vol. 86, Issue 4 (December 2011), pp. 841-874 Barnum, Jeffrey C. 86 Wash. L. Rev. 841 (2011)

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Insight on the Life and Works of Julia Alvarez Essay

- A novelist and a poet, Julia Alvarez is considered to be one of the greats when talking about American literature. At her current age of 64, she has a numerous amount of writings and has won many awards. Personal life experiences from her youth to the Civil War to now have highly influenced her works (Heredia). Descriptive and influential, it is clear why Alvarez’s publications have influenced society the way they have today. Aged 64, Julia Alvarez is considered to be one of the greatest American writers of current times....   [tags: american writers, styles, culture]

Strong Essays
1228 words (3.5 pages)

The Contribution of the Latina Voice: Julia Alvarez Essay

- Julia Alvarez originated from a Dominican American background, from which she used her experiences as an immigrant to write novels and short stories. In addition, Alvarez wrote about her experiences from the Dominican Republic and the United States, which provided her with over twenty works of literature. By writing over twenty literature works, Alvarez established herself as an inspiration and a contribution to American Literature. In short, Alvarez used her Dominican American background and experiences to write her books that all dedicated to the Latina voice in American Literature....   [tags: immigrant, domican american, trujillo]

Strong Essays
1112 words (3.2 pages)

How the Garcia Girls Lost Their Accent by Julia Alvarez Essay

- Julia Alvarez is a Dominican-American writer and poet, the author of “How the Garcia Girls Lost Their Accent,” a novel that some critics might say is autobiographical opposed by Alvarez’s opinion of it applying to any culture or background. This story narrates the growing-up ventures the Garcia Girls go through as the family abruptly moves from the Dominican Republic to the United States. Julia Alvarez experiences a similar process of a childhood in the Dominican Republic, being an immigrant in the United States, and finding her identity as an adult between two countries....   [tags: Literary Analysis, Dominican American Author]

Strong Essays
1055 words (3 pages)

The Virus Entering The United States Essays

- Cassandra Alvarez Professor Regis English 123: Intermediate Composition 6 February 2015 The Virus Entering the United States The Ebola virus disease has recently made a significant entrance into the United States, causing an uproar of fear and concern. Ebola is a fatal disease that has begun to make a reoccurring appearance within the United States, which ultimately alerted everyone to be cautious of others within the same proximity. Numerous medical offices have implemented asking their patients if they have traveled to West Africa, or if they have been exposed to the virus when booking an appointment in order to provide them with the best service possible....   [tags: Barack Obama, United States, Health care]

Strong Essays
1983 words (5.7 pages)

In The Time of Butterflies, by Julia Alvarez Essay

- The Dominican Republic in the twentieth century can be summarized as brutal. The novel In The Time of Butterflies, written by Julia Alvarez was set during the time period 1938 to 1994. During part of that time dictator Rafael Trujillo ruled the island. Although this book is considered historical fiction, it tells the story of four Mirabal sisters: Dede, Patria, Minerva, and Maria Teresa. They called themselves “Las Mariposas”. The four Mirabal sisters exist in real life. In the book as well as in real life, the sisters are seen as a symbol of courage and strength to the people in the Dominican Republic....   [tags: In The Time of Butterflies Essays]

Strong Essays
3040 words (8.7 pages)

Snow, Yolanda by Julia Alvarez Essay

- Culture molds the character of writers and gives a variety of different perspective on certain life experiences. In Julia Alvarez’s short story Snow, Yolanda, an immigrant student, moved to New York. While attending a Catholic school in New York, bomb drills were performed. The teacher would explain why these drills were important. Yolanda later found out that her first experience of watching snow was not the best experience one could possibly have. Julia Alvarez was an example of how a Latina writer identified herself in a new culture outside of her comfort zone....   [tags: culture, latina writer]

Strong Essays
1194 words (3.4 pages)

Mother Of Invention By Julia Alvarez Essay

- In Julia Alvarez’s short story “Daughter of Invention” the speaker needed to read and Write to save her life. In this character’s case, she needed to read and write to save her social life. In as an immigrant who moved from the Dominican Republic to the United States, she needs to become part of the culture of the country. Learning English and be able to speak the language well is important to being accepted into the culture. She described United States culture as hostile and “took root in the language” to help merge herself with the culture ()....   [tags: Writing, Essay, Dyslexia, Learning]

Strong Essays
1092 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on Santiago Alvarez Films

- Introduction Santiago Alvarez is honored in the world as the pioneer of revolutionary Cuban filmmaker as well as his documentary masterpieces also contribute a remarkable achievement in Latin America films. Santiago was given birth on March 8, 1919, who is the son of an immigrant Spanish family in Cuba. He was involved in learning politics at his very early age since his father arrested as a result of anarchistic activity. Subsequently, at the age of 15, Santiago began to work as a printer’s apprentice and then he became a strike planner speedily after he participating in the workers’ union....   [tags: documentary films]

Strong Essays
2640 words (7.5 pages)

Court Cases Upholding the Amendments Essay examples

- Amendment 1 1. United States V. Alvarez, 567 U.S._ (2012) 2. Xavier Alvarez, member of the Three Valleys Water District Board of Directors, was asked and invited to give some background information on himself to the rest of the Water District Board during a meeting with the Walnut Valley Water District Board. While giving his speech, he had provided false information about himself concerning his time as a Marine, and his gracing of the Congressional Medal of Honor. As it turns out, he had never won a Medal of Honor, nor had he ever served in the Marines....   [tags: xavier alvarez, stafford school, terrance graham]

Strong Essays
1094 words (3.1 pages)

How The Garcia Girls Lost Their Accents By Julia Alvarez Essay

- George Bernard Shaw once said, “Progress is impossible without change, and those who cannot change their minds cannot change anything.” This saying can relate to the counterculture, and to the novel “How the Garcia Girls Lost their Accents” by Julia Alvarez. In this novel, four sisters, Carla, Yolanda, Sandra, and Sofia reflect how they responded to society’s movements during the 1960’s. This civilization was a subculture within a larger culture. It was seen as controversial because it was made up of numerous movements that consisted of contrasting values, morals and behaviors seen in the 1960’s....   [tags: Vietnam War, Cold War, Dominican Republic]

Strong Essays
918 words (2.6 pages)