Essay about Thompson’s Abortion Article: Analogy of the Violinist

Essay about Thompson’s Abortion Article: Analogy of the Violinist

Length: 656 words (1.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Is Thomson’s analogy strong or weak? The main analogy argument based on Thompson’s Abortion article is the violinist scenario she uses. The violinist scenario is an example of abortion but from a different angle. The author describes the scenario as a violinist being plugged to someone to help save the violinist by extracting kidney blood to fight off the poison in the violinist body because you both share the same blood type. This is the only method to save the violinist. The author then states the fact that the only way to unplug yourself is to unplug the violinist, which will kill him. If not, you would have to wait only nine moths until the violinist is fully recovered and you can be safely unplugged from him with no harm done. Therefore, the solution for the argument the author is trying to provide is that you have the same blood type to save the violinist, unplugging yourself from him will kill him, therefore waiting nine months to fully heal the violinist is the right thing to do, and you can save his life. Going back to the article based on abortion, by analogy the author is trying to make a comparison between the violinist scenario and abortion. Two things that are being compared is the life of the mother and her fetus, and the dying violinist who needs help. These two things are similar because both scenarios are in a predicament to save a life, or take a life. Also, another similarity is that the violinist and the fetus are both entitled to the right of life, and their right to life shouldn’t be devalued. The only difference between the two scenarios is that the fetus has no freedom of speech because it lies within the mother’s stomach. The fetus cannot defend its life, and is powerless. Ultimately the fetus cannot b...


... middle of paper ...


...eople joined in marriage. Sex before marriage is not promoted, and as stated before to avoid unwanted pregnancy sex before marriage should be prohibited to decrease the amount of abortions. Furthermore, the point is that the fetus’ did not give the mother his or hers consent to terminate their life.
In conclusion, Thomson’s analogy is weak, out of context, irrelevant, and hypocritical. If its okay to kill a fetus which is still consider alive, than you might as well say it is okay to kill a three year-old kid. It is technically the same thing, the only difference is that one can speak, one can’t. It is also weak because who gave us the right to devalue the right of life for someone else? Also, if the mother is entitled to her body and can do whatever she pleases, the stranger is also entitled to not help the dying violinist. Therefore, Thomson’s argument is weak.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Defense Of Abortion By Thompson Essay

- Within the “Defense of Abortion,” Thompson insinuates an underlying principle, in which she highly values the principle of autonomy, as seen in her essay conversing the illegality of drug use. The implication of the principle of autonomy is an exercise of the belief that an adult is entitled to and has complete control over their body. Thompson’s argument begins with the willingness to take on the initial claim that nothing can be done to end a fetus’ life, insinuating that an abortion is impermissible even to save the mother....   [tags: Pregnancy, Abortion, Human rights, Fertility]

Better Essays
1095 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on A Defense Of Abortion By Judith Jarvis Thompson

- Responsibility to the Unborn In “A Defense of Abortion,” Judith Jarvis Thompson argues that abortion is not always impermissible. Thompson begins her argument by pointing out that the debate over abortion often falls on whether the fetus is a person or not. It seems if we had the answer to this then the answer to if abortion was permissible would be simple. Since this is not the case however, Thompson states that for the sake of argument, the fetus is a person, and challenges that there are still circumstances in which abortion can be justified....   [tags: Pregnancy, Abortion, Abortion debate, Fetus]

Better Essays
1355 words (3.9 pages)

Analysis of Thompson's Article, A Defense of Abortion Essay

- Pro-Choice: Analysis of Thompson's Article, A Defense of Abortion Works Cited Missing In Judith Jarvis Thompson’s article “A Defense of Abortion” she explores the different arguments against abortion presented by Pro –Life activists, and then attempts to refute these notions using different analogies or made up “for instances” to help argue her point that women do have the right to get an abortion. She explains why abortion is morally permissible using different circumstances of becoming pregnant, such as rape or unplanned pregnancy....   [tags: Abortion, Argumentative, Pro-Choice]

Better Essays
1773 words (5.1 pages)

The Moral Permissibility Of Abortion Essay

- Thompson on the Moral Permissibility of Abortion The standard argument against abortion rests on the claim that the fetus is a person and therefore has a right to life (Thompson, 1971). Judith Jarvis Thomson shows why this standard argument against abortion is a somewhat inadequate account of the morality of abortion. She argues for the conclusion that abortion is sometimes permissible. She begins the essay by pointing out on whether or not the fetus is a person. If fetuses are persons then abortions must be impermissible, and that if fetuses are not persons then abortions must be permissible....   [tags: Abortion, Pregnancy, Fetus, Abortion debate]

Better Essays
1346 words (3.8 pages)

The Debate Of The Permissibility Of Abortion Essay

- The permissibility of abortion has been a crucial topic for debates for many years. People have yet to agree upon a stance on whether abortion is morally just. This country is divided into two groups, believers in a woman’s choice to have an abortion and those who stand for the fetus’s right to live. More commonly these stances are labeled as pro-choice and pro-life. The traditional argument for each side is based upon whether a fetus has a right to life. Complications occur because the qualifications of what gives something a right to life is not agreed upon....   [tags: Abortion, Human rights, Abortion debate]

Better Essays
1114 words (3.2 pages)

An Ethical Debate Against Abortion Essay examples

- An Ethical Debate against Abortion Each day throughout our world, medical professionals suction thousands of babies from their mothers’ wombs through a procedure called abortion. The law protects and provides consent to both the mother and the medical professionals for these procedures. However, the babies seemingly have no right to protection or life themselves because of the argument regarding when a fetus is determined be human and have life. Pro-life author, Sarah Terzo, in a LifeSiteNews.com article, relays the following testimony supporting this from a medical student upon witnessing his first abortion, “Rejected by their mothers and regarded as medical waste by their killers,...   [tags: Abortion, Pregnancy, Morality, Abortion debate]

Better Essays
2366 words (6.8 pages)

Abortion Is Not Permissible? Essay

- Thompson is right to claim that, even if a fetus is a person, abortion is still permissible when pregnancy results from consensual sex, or nonconsensual sex. (WC 26) Thompson defends his argument that pregnancy resulting from consensual sex is permissible by using an analogy. The imaginary analogy says to imagine living in a world where people seeds could fly around like pollen, you try to protect yourself by using protective screens in front of your windows. However, in some cases the screen protectors are defective meaning seeds can find holes and get into your apartment or during the heat weather you decide to open your windows allowing seeds in your apartment....   [tags: Abortion, Human rights, Pro-choice, Pregnancy]

Better Essays
1549 words (4.4 pages)

The Strongest Argument Of Defense Of Abortion Essays

- In this essay, I will hold that the strongest argument in defence of abortion was provided by Judith Jarvis Thompson. She argued that abortion is still morally permissible, regardless if one accepts the premise that the foetus is a person from the moment of conception. In what follows, I agree that abortion is permissible in the ‘extreme case’ whereby the woman’s life is threatened by the foetus. Furthermore, I agree that abortion is permissible to prevent future pain and suffering to the child....   [tags: Pregnancy, Fetus, Abortion, Childbirth]

Better Essays
1822 words (5.2 pages)

Essay on The Ethics Of Abortion Is Morally Justified Or Not?

- The ethics of abortion is a topic that establishes arguments that attempt to argue if abortion is morally justified or not. Philosopher Judith Jarvis Thomson wrote a pro- choice piece called “A Defense of Abortion.” In this paper, she presents various arguments that attempt to defend abortion by relating it to the woman carrying the fetus and her right in controlling her body. On the other side of the spectrum, philosopher Don Marquis wrote a pro- life paper called “Why Abortion Is Immoral.” Ultimately, Marquis argues that abortion is immoral with rare exceptions because it is resulting in the deprivation of the fetus’s valuable future....   [tags: Human, Religion, Abortion, Morality]

Better Essays
1549 words (4.4 pages)

Essay about An Ethical Argument Against Abortion

- Each day throughout our world, medical professionals suction thousands of babies from their mothers’ wombs through a procedure called abortion. The law protects and provides consent to both the mother and the medical professionals for these procedures. However, the babies seemingly have no right to protection or life themselves because of the argument regarding when a fetus is determined be human and have life. Pro-life author, Sarah Terzo, in a LifeSiteNews.com article, relays the following testimony supporting this from a medical student upon witnessing his first abortion, “Rejected by their mothers and regarded as medical waste by their killers, society allows these babies to die silently...   [tags: Argument Against Abortion]

Better Essays
2133 words (6.1 pages)