The Ethics of Terrorism: Employing Just War Principles Essay

The Ethics of Terrorism: Employing Just War Principles Essay

Length: 3692 words (10.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Research Papers

Open Document

Essay Preview

The Just War tradition has been seen as a leading perspective on the ethics of war since the writings of St Augustine were rearticulated by Thomas Aquinas. It attempts to provide a framework which validates just conflicts, whilst at the same time applying limits so as to prevent unrestrained warfare. Today, its core principles can be divided into two broad categories: ‘jus ad bellum’ (just resort to war) and ‘jus in bello’ (just conduct in war). For a war to be just, numerous criteria must be satisfied within these categories.

In recent decades non-state terrorism has become increasingly high-profile; indeed, in the twenty first century it has dominated the global political agenda. It is pertinent therefore, to question whether terrorism can be ethically assessed using the Just War tradition.In this essay, I will argue that it is possible to ethically evaluate terrorism by employing Just War principles. I will show that terrorists can satisfy the most important criterion of the Just War tradition. Firstly, they can represent a ‘legitimate authority’ and can have a ‘just cause’. Secondly, terrorism can be a ‘last resort’ and offers a ‘reasonable prospect of success’. Finally, whilst many terrorists do adhere to the principle of ‘discrimination’, the notion of ‘non-combatant immunity’ and civilian innocence is over-simplified. Furthermore, terrorists may perceive themselves to be in a ‘supreme emergency’, therefore meaning the rules of war cease to exist. Terrorism can satisfy the principle of proportionality.

However, before I begin my argument, I must establish a working definition for ‘terrorism’; an important and controversial issue in itself. Walzer describes it as ‘like rape and murder… an attack upon the innocent’ (2005...


... middle of paper ...


...Family Research Council, Accessed Online: 07/11/2010

Roberts, Adams, (1989), ‘Ethics, Terrorism and Counter Terrorism’, Terrorism and Political Violence 1 (1), pp. 48-70

Schmidt Alex P, and Jongman Albert I, (1998) ‘Political Terrorism’ (Amsterdam, Transaction Books)

Smilanski, Saul, (2004), ‘Terrorism, Justification and Illusion’, Ethics, 114, July pp. 790-805

Valls, Andrew, (2000), ‘Can Terrorism Be Justified’, In Andre Valls (ed.), Ethics in International Affairs, pp. 65-80

Walzer, Michael, (1992), ‘Just and Unjust Wars: A Moral Argument with Historical Illustrations’, (New York: Basic Books)

Walzer, Michael, (2005), ‘Arguing About War’, (Yale Nota Bene)

Wilkins, Burleigh Taylor, (1992), ‘Terrorism and collective responsibility’, (New York : Routledge)

US State Department, (2005), ‘Country Reports on Terrorism’, Accessed online: 15/11/2010

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Ethical Decision Making Paper : Ethics

- Ethical Decision Making Paper Bello Hiqmat Damilola Western Kentucky University Ethical Decision Making Paper Since it Human’s nature to be needy and vulnerable, we tend to make various decisions that often result in us violating most of our ethics....   [tags: Human rights, United Nations, Ethics]

Research Papers
946 words (2.7 pages)

Essay on John Locke and Terrorism

- In 1689, A Letter Concerning Toleration, written by John Locke during his self-imposed exile to his friend Philip von Limborch, was published without the author's knowledge. The Letter concerned religious intolerance. It essentially made the case for religious toleration on the basis of philosophical principles. Locke was concerned with the State's toleration of those not subscribing to the orthodox religion of the day and, by putting a high value on the preservation of negative liberty, he proposed the toleration of a wide range of religious beliefs....   [tags: Philosophy of Terrorism Essays]

Free Essays
3031 words (8.7 pages)

Change Foreign Policy to Win the War on Terrorism Essay

- There are many advocacy groups that have long been doing important good works in the international arena, but on issues that have not officially been seen as being a proper part of foreign policy: the environment, human rights, women's rights, the condition of children, labor, international public health issues (e.g., AIDS in Africa), sustainable development, refugees, international education, and so on. The metaphors that foreign policy experts have used to define what foreign policy is rules out these important concerns....   [tags: Politics Political Essays]

Free Essays
1140 words (3.3 pages)

Michael Ignatieff's The Lesser Evil: Political Ethics in an Age of Terror

- “The U.S. need only measure up to its own best traditions and prove itself worthy of preservation as a great nation.” This statement by George Kennan, criticizing U.S. policies during the Cold War, is relevant in questioning today’s principles of American policy combating terrorism. In his book, The Lessor Evil: Political Ethics in an Age of Terror, Michael Ignatieff challenges antiterrorist policies, proposing the need to maintain public review and accountability of governmental actions. A critic of the “lesser of two evils” philosophy utilized by U.S....   [tags: Antiterrorist Policies, War on Terror]

Research Papers
2547 words (7.3 pages)

The Moral Compass Must Maintain Our Humanity Essay

- Numerous moral issues challenge us every day. Resolving these issues may lead to the neglecting of right from wrong, which is our moral compass. The moral compass helps maintain our humanity. Knowledge of the moral compass is one thing but applying it is another. The lack of utilizing the moral compass alters political decisions, science improvements, and the management of issues. Many political decisions are done for right reasons but have long-term effects. The event of 6 August 1945 shows us a way the United States mismanaged their moral compass....   [tags: Morality, Human, Terrorism, Black Death]

Research Papers
1271 words (3.6 pages)

War of Terroism Essay

- In liberal democracies, most political acts are indeed legal, yet some instead decide on another way of influencing political decisions. Terrorism, is a seemly violent method intravenously employed by marginal groups to gain the focus of others on their case. Dyck defines terrorism as “the threat or use of violence, usually directed at civilian populations, in order to create some form of political change” (Dyck 401). The acts of terrorism that took place in the United States on September 11, 2001 are a powerful mementoes of how some choose to engage in violence in order to make a political statement....   [tags: Terrorism ]

Research Papers
1808 words (5.2 pages)

Essay about The War On Terrorism And Terrorism

- In September 2001, the United States suffered an attack in New York City that would firmly place fear in the hearts of Americans. 9/11 marks the beginning of the terror age in US History. The War on Terrorism has been fought for over a decade to try and bring an end to this foreign disease and to eradicate terrorists as a whole. However, the current United States counterterrorism policy should be amended as it is counterproductive; and if it continues, our world will soon be filled with terrorists....   [tags: Terrorism, Counter-terrorism, United States]

Research Papers
1302 words (3.7 pages)

Essay on The War Against Terrorism: The Taliban in Afghanistan

- Since 1996, the Taliban has created an environment of terror and disorder within the country of Afghanistan. Although terrorists within Afghanistan and of the Islam religion believe that they are justified in their actions, it is made clearly apparent that Terrorism must be stopped altogether. Defining the Issue Terrorism is translated to mean ‘army in the shadows’ and is defined as the threat or use of violence to win certain rewards or goals ( Dictionary.com, 2010). The earliest known Terrorist organization similar to those of today was the Zealots of Judea, formed when fanatics of the Jewish faith revolted against the of the Roman oppression....   [tags: terrorism, war on terror]

Free Essays
3763 words (10.8 pages)

The Declaration Of The War On Terrorism Essay

- Following the attacks by the terrorist organization Al Qaeda on September 11, 2001 the United States entered into a war that can be best described as ubiquitous and ambiguous. The declaration of the “War on Terrorism” is quite literally as open ended of a declaration as one could possibly imagine given the interpretation of winning a war relies on the defeat of an enemy. Clausewitz describes war as “an act of force to compel our enemy to do our will” (Clausewitz, 75) and perhaps the most commonly quoted portion of his theories of warfare being “war is merely the continuation of policy by other means” (Clausewitz, 87)....   [tags: Al-Qaeda, United States, War on Terrorism]

Research Papers
726 words (2.1 pages)

The Attack Of The War On Terrorism Essay

- The attack heard around the world that no one saw coming took place on September 11, 2001, in New York City. It was masterminded by a terrorist group known as Al Qaeda. The attack left American citizens in a devastated and bewildered state of mind. Al Qaeda managed to kill 2,996 innocent people. This first attack served as a ripple effect for many years to come. Al Qaeda also managed to indirectly kill 48,644 Afghan, 1,690,903 Iraqi, and 35,000 Pakistani people. A majority of these were killed in the crossfire of U.S retaliation following the September 11 attack....   [tags: George W. Bush, War on Terrorism, United States]

Research Papers
1121 words (3.2 pages)