Taylor's Life Choices in "The Bean Trees" by Barbara Kingsolver

777 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: How does a child/young person's environment affect their development

In The Bean Trees by Barbara Kingsolver, protagonist Taylor Greer is not your average teenage girl from Pittman, Kentucky. Taylor refuses to remain in her hometown forever, which only leads to teenage pregnancy and motherhood until death. On a mission to escape Pittman’s stereotypical teenage girl image, she buys a ‘55 Volkswagen and embarks on a journey west. Just when she thinks she is home free, Taylor is left with an abandoned three-year-old American Indian girl. Ironically, Taylor ends up as an unplanned single mother. The two end up living in Tucson, Arizona along with another recently single mother and her son. Had Taylor stayed in Pittman her metamorphose process would have differed greatly from her life in Tucson, Arizona In both positive and negative ways, Taylor’s life would have ended up contrasting to how she would have lived it in Pittman. As I paraphrase, Taylor would have presumably become pregnant at a young age, and married to a tobacco farmer similar to every other teenage girl in Pittman (Kingsolver 3). Assuming Taylor would become pregnant; her child/children would have given her a much different experience of motherhood than her inherited daughter, Turtle, did. As Taylor said after first getting Turtle, “When I pulled off the pants and the diapers there were more bruises. Bruises and worse…That fact had already burdened her short life with a kind of misery I could not imagine” (Kingsolver 23). From what Taylor had seen and therefore inferred, was that this child had been beaten and sexually abused. Turtle’s pre-Taylor days were almost certainly filled with terror and abuse coming from someone in her family. This scarred her and caused Turtle to resort to a mute state. For Taylor, this creates a d... ... middle of paper ... ... blown up on top of a sign after a tire tractor blew up, she was petrified of the same thing happening to her. The Arizona atmosphere was visibly different in both literal and nonliteral ways from Kentucky. Taylor’s lifestyle would have been drastically contrasting with how she thrived in her new home of Tucson. Apart from having a night and day experience at maternity, and getting a fresh start at life on her own, Taylor also met a new group of people who changed her in many ways. Lou Ann, who molded her into a better mother, Mattie, who helped her to overcome fears, Esperanza, though she spoke very little, managed to open Taylor’s eyes the horrors of a life she would never have to experience, and finally Turtle, who made Taylor realize what she loved most in life. Pittman, Kentucky did not have any of these individuals to teach the protagonist of this story.

Show More
Related

  • Theme Of Morality In The Bean Trees

    1216 Words  | 3 Pages

    Taylor drives all the way up to Cherokee Nation in hopes of finding Turtle’s real parents back at the diner where she was given to Taylor. From pages 225-227, the official adoption of Turtle began. This adoption is supposed to take place between the child’s real parents, but instead, Esperanza and Estevan pretended to be the parents. What the three of them did was against the law. Estevan and Esperanza saw it, however, as a way to make both Taylor and Turtle’s lives better and easier along the road even though it could get them caught. The reason that they did it for Taylor was because they thought it morally right. As a result of how hard Estevan and Esperanza help Taylor in the adoption process, Turtle is now Taylor’s legal daughter. After Taylor says her goodbyes to Esperanza and Estevan, she calls Lou Ann to tell her about Turtle being her daughter “Lou Ann’s breath came out like a slow leak in a tire. ‘Taylor, I was scared to death you’d come back without her’” (245). Kingsolver uses a simile here, comparing “slow leak in a tire” to “Lou Ann’s breath coming out”. This connects to one of the motifs in the book; tires. Tires represent stability, so when Lou Ann lets out the air in her tire, it shows that everyone’s life has become more stable. This quote also ties

    Read More

  • The Secret Life Of Ellen Foster Sparknotes

    936 Words  | 2 Pages

    This book is about a girl name Ellen Foster who is ten years old. Her mother committed suicide by over dosing on her medication. When Ellen tried to go look for help for her mother her father stopped her. He told them that if she looked for helped he would kill them both. After her mother died she was left under her fathers custody. Her father was a drunk. He would physically and mentally abuse her. Ellen was forced to pay bills, go grocery shopping, cook for herself, and do everything else for herself. Ellen couldn't take it any more so she ran away her friends house. Starletta and her parents lived in a small cabin with one small bathroom. One day at school a teacher found a bruise on Ellen's arm. She sends Ellen to live with Julia the school's art teacher. Julia had a husband named Roy. They were both hippies. Julia and Roy cared a lot about Ellen. After Ellen turned 11 years old she was forced to go live with her grandmother. Ellen didn't want to leave Julia and Roy but her grandmother had won custody. Her grandmother was a cruel old lady. Ellen spends the summer with her grandmother. Living with her makes her very unhappy. Since her grandmother owns farmland she forces Ellen to work on the field with her black servants. Ellen meets a black woman named Mavis. Mavis and her become good friends. Mavis would talk about how she knew Ellen's mother and how much Ellen resembled her mother. Her grandmother didn't think the same. She thought that Ellen resembled her father. She also hated that man. Her grandmother would often compare her with her father. Her grandmother would torture her because she wanted revenge from her father. Her grandmother also blames her for the death of her mother. While Ellen was staying with her grandmother her father died. When her father died she didn't feel sad because she had always fantasized about killing her father. Ellen just felt a distant sadness. Ellen cried just a little bit. Her grandmother was furious because Ellen showed some emotions. She told her to never cry again. After that Ellen becomes scarred for a long time. One day her uncle Rudolph bought the flag that had been on Ellen's father's casket. Her grandmother turns him away. Later that day she burned the flag.

    Read More

  • The Hero's Journey Demonstrated By Leigh Anne Touhy

    1078 Words  | 3 Pages

    Leigh Anne leaves her Ordinary World by Crossing the Threshold into the Special World, where she must overcome a series of challenges. Leigh Anne’s journey begins when she helps out a juvenile in need. As a wife and a mom of two Mrs. Touhy seems to live a normal life in her Memphis, Tennessee home. Ole Miss graduate Leigh Anne Touhy and husband Sean Touhy run a fast- paced and hardworking household in their quaint Tennessee home. A Campbellian Hero must have an Ordinary World that she is able to leave in order to get to the Special World. Heroes do not always look the same, or even appear as a Hero, “Heroes wear many faces because of their responses to the numerous needs of individuals” (Brown). Young Michael Oher is trying to find a place where he fits in and is accepted, when the Touhy family welcomes him with open arms. She soon realizes that Michael in is need of help and she says herself, “I just think Michael needed somebody, and it was so evident that there was nobody in his life. And it just broke my heart” (Touhy). Leigh Anne reacts to her call to adventure briskly and almost without second thought. Leigh Anne Touhy is the matriarch of the Touhy family, and she is the one that runs things. She does not have a mentor, no...

    Read More

  • Silas House

    529 Words  | 2 Pages

    I read a few chapters from Silas Houses novel A Parchment of Leaves its set in Kentucky. The story is about a young Cherokee Indian woman in the early 1900’s. The young woman’s name is vine she live in the hills of Kentucky in a place called Red Bud camp. She meets a young white Irish boy who her family is not too happy about the mother more than the father “them Irish ...

    Read More

  • Abandonment in The Bean Trees

    1170 Words  | 3 Pages

    Taylor Greer has lived in Kentucky all her life. Yet, the life available to her in Kentucky is not what she always dreamed of: "none of these sights had so far inspired me to get hogtied to a future as a tobacco farmer's wife" (3). Living with her mother, Taylor becomes more independent and striven to find a better life. Taylor's father disappeared before she could even remember what he looks like: "And for all I ever knew of my own daddy I can't say we weren't except for Mama swearing up and down that he was nobody I knew and was long gone besides" (2). Taylor's father's abandonment contributes to Taylor's dislike in men: "To hear you tell it, you'd think man was only put on this earth to keep urinals from going to waste" (112). She does not trust any men and Kingsolver displays this by not adding many male characters to the novel. Taylor feeling of being abandoned by her father scars her, even thought she does not express it clearly.

    Read More

  • Gloria Naylor's Mama Day

    1245 Words  | 3 Pages

    George and Ophelia grow up in significantly different environments with exposure to vastly dissimilar experiences; their diverse backgrounds have a profound impact on the way they interpret and react to situations as adults. George and Ophelia both grow up without their parents, but for different reasons. George grows up at the Wallace P. Andrews Shelter for Boys in New York. The Shelter’s strict surroundings did not provide the warm and inviting atmosphere that a mother strives for in a home. The employees at the Shelter are not “loving people,” (p. 23) but they are devoted to their job, and the boys. At a young age, Ophelia loses her mother. We learn very little about her apparently absent father. Mama Day and Abigail raise Ophelia. Abigail provides a source of comfort and love for Ophelia as she fulfills the role of mother figure. Mama day, Ophelia’s great aunt, acts more as a father figure. “If Grandma had been there, she would have held me when I broke down and cry. Mama Day only said that for a long time there would be something to bring on tears aplenty.” (p. 304). Ophelia grows up on the small island of Willow Springs. Everyone knows each other and their business, in the laid-back island community. The border between Georgia and South Carolina splits down the middle of the island. Instead of seeing any advantage to belonging to either state, the townspeople would prefer to operate independently. For George and Ophelia, the differences in their backgrounds will have a tremendous impact on many facets of their adult lives.

    Read More

  • Dorothea Dix

    1574 Words  | 4 Pages

    The thought of her brothers still being in her former home environment in Maine hurt her. She tried to think of a way to get at least one of her brothers, the sickly one, to come and be with her. She knew that her extended family was financially able to take in another child, and if she showed responsibility, there would be no problem (Wilson, 40). She found a vacant store, furnished it, and turned it into a school for children (Thinkquest, 5). At the age of seventeen, her grandmother sent her a correspondence, and requested her to come back to Boston with her brother (Thinkquest, 6).

    Read More

  • The Bean Trees

    506 Words  | 2 Pages

    Taylor Greer had been running away from premature pregnancy her entire life. Afraid that she would wind up just another hick in Pittman County, she left town and searched for a new life out West. On her way getting there, she acquires Turtle, an abandoned three-year-old Native American girl. Taylor knows that keeping Turtle is a major responsibility, being that she was abandoned and abused. Yet, Taylor knows that she is the best option that Turtle has, as far as parental figures go. "Then you are not the parent or guardian?’…. ‘Look,’ I said. ‘I’m not her real mother, but I’m taking care of her now. She’s not with her original family anymore." (Kingsolver 162) As the story progresses, Taylor accepts Turtle as part of life. This sacrifice later turns into a blessing.

    Read More

  • Glass Essay In Crank

    637 Words  | 2 Pages

    The book is set in Reno, Nevada. Kristina gets clean for her baby but only a couple of short months after she has Hunter, she starts getting bored again. Het mother and step father have agreed to look after Hunter if she gets her GED and goes to college. Kristina decides to hit up her old party buddy, Robyn. Sneaking around her parents back in Crank, has made Kristina's parents put her on restrictions and be watched at all times. But Kristina's mom thinking it's a "college fair", agrees to let her go. While at Robyn's, she meets Trey. A roommate of a friend who would become the love of her life. Due to college, Kristina only sees Trey every few weeks and gets a phone call or two a week since Trey is always "busy". She gets a job shortly after at 7/11 so she can support her "old" habit, which she claims she can still have a great life and not become addicted by smoking small quantities. To everyones surprise, Kristina's father deci...

    Read More

  • meow meow

    1073 Words  | 3 Pages

    At nineteen, she got married and moved to Las Vegas. Her world was turned upside-down; she went f...

    Read More

  • Symbiotic Relationships In Kingsolver's The Bean Trees

    997 Words  | 2 Pages

    When Taylor and Lou Ann meet, they form a symbiotic relationship and fill the missing gaps in each others lives. Once the two women move in with each other, Lou Ann fills Taylor’s missing gap of motherly experience and opens her eyes to a life full of responsibilities. Lou Ann is soft, motherly, and worrisome. Because of the fact that she is afraid of almost everything, she fits perfectly into the worrying mother role in she and Taylor’s relationship. “For Lou Ann, life itself was a life-threatening enterprise. Nothing on earth was truly harmless.” (112) This shows how Lou Ann looks at the bad side of many things in life and how each things serves as a threat to her and her baby. We see Taylor go through a major transition from confident and stubborn to tenderhearted and doubtful. After Turtle’s terrible incident, Taylor constantly blames herself for what happened. “At night I lay listening to noises outside, listening to Turtle breathe, thinking: she could have been killed. So easily she could be dead right now.” (228) This shows how she now worries about things just as much as Lou Ann used to. Taylor

    Read More

  • An Analysis Of Taylor's Quest In The Bean Trees

    1006 Words  | 3 Pages

    Taylor had a goal, a reason to achieve it, had many challenges along the way and in the end found her reason to thrive. Had Taylor stayed in town, there is a good chance she would have followed the rest of her peers, getting pregnant ad married without any thought to the world outside. Taylor Greer learned that she could rise above small town culture, be herself and thrive. This can be a lesson to readers and critics that life is a quest, and the most important part of it is our development and to find our place in the

    Read More

  • Independence In Barbara Kingsolver's The Bean Trees

    1112 Words  | 3 Pages

    Diane von Furstenberg once stated “I wanted to be an independent woman, a woman who could pay for her bills, a woman who could run her own life.” Independence plays a big role in being able to be successful in life. Taylor, a girl that can be described as “different ,” is a person who is a strong believer in doing things by herself. She moved out when she learned how to drive and never went back. She gains a child and soon settles down in Tucson Arizona, where she starts her own life. In the novel The Bean Trees, by Barbara Kingsolver, there are many obstacles Taylor goes through to set the theme of independence.

    Read More

  • Social Class In Jeannette Walls The Glass Castle

    1160 Words  | 3 Pages

    Ever since she was a young girl. Jeannette had set high goals for herself. Since she was so advanced in school and genuinely enjoyed learning, it made sense that she would want to do big things with her life. Whether it was being a veterinarian or a geologist, her dreams extended far beyond her homes in little desert towns or Welch, West Virginia. However, because of her poverty-stricken home life, many people believed it didn’t seem likely that she would be so successful. One day, while living in Welch, Jeannette goes to the bar to drag her drunk father back home. A neighborhood man offers them a ride back to their house, and on the ride up he and Jeannette start a conversation about school. When Jeannette tells the man that she works so hard in school because of her dream careers, the man laughs saying, “for the daughter of the town drunk, you sure got big plans” (Walls 183). Immediately, Jeannette tells the man to stop the car and gets out, taking her father with her. This seems to be a defining moment in which Jeannette is first exposed to the idea that she is inferior to others. Although this man said what he did not mean to offend her, Jeannette is clearly very hurt by his comment. To the reader, it seems as if she had never thought that her family’s situation made her subordinate to those

    Read More

  • A Pair Of Tickets

    1395 Words  | 3 Pages

    This story is about a young Lady that lives in California with her mother and Father. She

    Read More

More about Taylor's Life Choices in "The Bean Trees" by Barbara Kingsolver

Open Document