Should Begging Be Legal For A Public Place? Essays

Should Begging Be Legal For A Public Place? Essays

Length: 1001 words (2.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Begging is the solicitation of money or food, usually in a public place, with little or nothing given in return. There are different kinds of begging: primary where the need is fundamental that needs fulfilled immediately. Secondary satisfies an essential but not vital need and tertiary satisfies a need that is not vital. It is important to define these before evaluating which, or if any should be criminalised.


Currently in Scotland begging is legal under the Civic Government (Scotland) Act 1982 However in England and Wales begging remains illegal under the 1824 Act. In England since 2003 community sentences can be issued instead of fines. This is significant as people who have to beg cannot often afford to pay fines. Comparing this to Europe, for example, Charleroi in Belgium begging is allowed in the city centre but not on Sundays. In Lausanne, Switzerland begging on public transport is illegal. This demonstrates that although begging is universal jurisdictions take different approaches in dealling with it. This creates a problem because harsher punishment in one area may force the beggar to move elsewhere. Therefore, regardless of criminalisation, I would argue for a uniform approach. This may be difficult worldwide but could be achieved across the UK.


I propose however, that begging should not be criminalised. Begging is somewhat positive because it highlights social problems. Barrett argues, beggars convey a ‘symbolic message that social controls have broken down’. According to the Columbia Survey, receiving requests in person makes citizens more willing to defend beggars rights. This demonstrates those who are confronted with begging are more likely to want to help. Crimninlaistion creates a paradox because givin...


... middle of paper ...


...gging are valid, there are better solutions than the criminal Law. Agreeing with barrett, the most effective solution is to help individuals generate their own income, by creating of jobs, although this is difficult in practice. The alternative is to ensure beggars get their benefits. Although this is not easy, it is better than criminalization. The symbolic nature of the criminal law becomes eroded by such wide use. With begging in particular, Fernandez argues ‘noncriminal’ intervention would be more effective and less costly.


The arguments on both sides have been eveulated and I find myself firmly in the view that begging should not be criminalised. While admitting there is a problem, it does have some beneficial aspects and would be better addressed outside of the criminal law as it should be reserved for serious matters and not penalise the most vulnerable.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Homelessness Of The United States

- We have all seen them. Men, women and sometimes even children begging for spare change to pay for their next meal. Some people may take pity upon a homeless person and give them money, food, or maybe just a glance that may or may not be so kind. Although we have all probably had an encounter with a person living on the streets, not many people acknowledge the fact that this is a keen issue in the United States of America. There is homelessness all over the world and more remotely, it exists in our very own backyard....   [tags: Homelessness, Poverty, Begging]

Better Essays
1108 words (3.2 pages)

Euthanasia Should be Legal Essay

- Euthanasia Should be Legal       Euthanasia is the intentional causing of a painless death. Euthanasia should be legal in every state. It is already legal in some areas and if put to a vote in every state, it most likely would become legal. Every state resident should be given the opportunity to vote on the issue. It should also the right of a competent patient to decide his own life, or death. If it is within an individual's rights to commit suicide it should be legal to ask for help if needed....   [tags: Euthanasia Physician Assisted Suicide]

Better Essays
1102 words (3.1 pages)

Mass Media in the Political and Legal Environment Essay

- Mass media is considered by many to be a great influence in the United States. It can be influence in many aspects of one’s everyday life beyond the television or the internet. It can have an impact on one’s critical thinking skills in either negative or positive ways. It has the ability to be allowed to sway one’s emotions and even one’s reasoning skills. It clearly affects the way one communicates including changing the way the nation speaks such as with slang words. It also has the ability to change the ethical and moral compass of a nation, especially that of the United States....   [tags: freedom of speech, FCC]

Better Essays
1218 words (3.5 pages)

Marijuana Should Be Legal For Medical Purposes Essay

- Marijuana is a cannabis drug that may be used for medical purposes. It was used to soothe malaria and constipation in many Asian countries including India and China (Ashton). It has the capability to relieve the pain of a serious sickness like malaria as well as a common every day stomach sickness like constipation. Marijuana has also been used therapeutically for the common disease asthma (Ashton). It “exert[s] a bronchodilator action on the small airways” therefore allowing a person to breathe better (Ashton)....   [tags: medical marijuana should be legal ]

Free Essays
2143 words (6.1 pages)

Essay on Marijuana Should Not Be Legal

- Should marijuana be legal. This issue has been argued by people throughout the past few years. Marijuana has been illegal since the early 1900’s, but scientists have recently figured out that there are some uses of marijuana that could benefit people in need, people who are suffering, and people who have diseases such as arthritis. Many people in our society try to persuade the government to legalize the use of marijuana. In the article “Should Marijuana be Legal?” ‘Soon We Will Know…’ by Dr. James L....   [tags: James Goddard, should marijuana be legal]

Free Essays
904 words (2.6 pages)

Marijuana Should Be Legal Essay

- America’s controversial debate over whether marijuana should be legalized has been baffling many communities and citizens for some time now. Due to the vital decision being made by the government, many political and federal aspects are being considered. Marijuana has been used pharmaceutically tracing back all the way to ancient times and is legal to use for medical purposes in the United States. Marijuana’s medical uses should be enough to have the plant considered a legal substance. Medicinal use of cannabis has been unearthed for thousands of years as treatment for whooping cough, constipation, lower fevers, and rheumatic pains, to induce sleep, and reduce headaches....   [tags: legal issues, marijuana]

Better Essays
1788 words (5.1 pages)

It's Time to Stop Child Trafficking Essay example

- According to the factsheet from United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICFE), which is a global organization and active in more than 190 countries and territories through country programmes and National Committees “The huge transnational industry of trafficking in human beings generates approximately up to $10 billion per year” (www.unicef.org). Even though child trafficking is an illegal and underground trading, there are still huge numbers of child trafficking by we are known. Nowadays, most countries have better laws to protect their own citizens....   [tags: legal issues, UNICEF]

Better Essays
1658 words (4.7 pages)

Essay on Public Restrooms Should Be Legal

- Claim Where do you go to the bathroom when you are in North Carolina. Public restrooms should be available to all people in the public. North Carolina passed House Bill 2, people are now required by law to use the bathroom that corresponds with the sex on their birth certificate. This was a target for transgender people using public bathrooms. The few exceptions are for custodial purposes, a person needing medical assistance, a minor under the age of seven, and a person that has been temporarily designated for use by that person’s biological sex....   [tags: Transgender, Gender, Rape, Restrooms]

Better Essays
2332 words (6.7 pages)

Should Public Punishment Be Legal? Essay

- Torture based on the definition is the act of causing severe physical pain as a form of punishment or as a way to force someone to do or say something or it is something that causes mental or physical suffering. In the times when torture was legal many people enjoyed watching the person being tortured as a form of entertainment. Public punishment was probably originally conceived to prevent people from committing crimes, but its continuing popularity over the centuries seems to have been due more to its value as entertainment than to its value as a way to prevent people from committing crimes....   [tags: Cerebrum, Cerebral cortex, Brain, Human brain]

Better Essays
1407 words (4 pages)

Legalization of Marijuana Should Not Happen Essay

- The legalization of marijuana is a very controversial issue that is being debated across the United States. In the article "Going to Pot?," by Damon Linker, Linker attempts to persuade readers that legalizing of marijuana can cause more harm than help. This publication was released in November of 2001. Although two other writers, Richard Lowry and Andrew Sullivan, try to change readers beliefs Linker maintains his stance against marijuana. Without discrediting their facts he explains and defends why he feels they are wrong....   [tags: cannabis should not be legal]

Better Essays
967 words (2.8 pages)