The ‘Sensation-Brain Process Identity Theory Essay

The ‘Sensation-Brain Process Identity Theory Essay

Length: 750 words (2.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The ‘Sensation-Brain Process Identity Theory’ posed by J.J.C. Smart is the view that a sensation is a just a brain process. In the strict sense of identity a sensation and a brain processes are two names for one thing. Similarly, the one thing people refer to when they talk about ‘the morning star’ or ‘the evening star’ is Venus. There exists only one physical component to this world from which we derive other statements like ‘the morning star is the last star you can see in the morning.’ ‘The morning star’ happens to be Venus. A sensation happens to be a process. A brain process more obviously is also a process. When we talk about sensations or a brain process we are talking about the same process. The one particular process being referred to ‘is’ in the strict sense a single thing like Venus. When we talk about a sensation or a brain-process we do so to designate one and the same component of living humans.
Assuming his existence, the name Superman picks out a particular individual. We can refer to this individual thing by the name Superman. Superman is just a name which picks out a particular guy who also happens to be referred to by another name Clark Kent. Superman and Clark Kent are strictly identical. The two terms refer to one thing i.e. a superhero alien who disguises himself as a nerdy reporter. Similarly brain-processes and sensations refer to the same thing. A sensation state is a state of a physical component. A Brain state is a state of a physical component. The very same physical component ‘is’ being referred to by reporting either sensation states or brain processes just like referring to the same alien by talking about ‘Superman’ or ‘Clark Kent’.
Smart does not think that Sensations are caused by brain processes...


... middle of paper ...


... it means to experience a lower than average amount of molecular kinetic energy. In the second case Smart would say the Russian peasant is referring to the amount of molecular kinetic energy in the Russian tundra. Smart uses the case of lightning as an example of this. People can talk perfectly well about lightning, but know nothing about electrical discharges. Smart on page 147 puts it as “Note that there are not two things: a flash of lightning and an electrical discharge. There is one thing, a flash of lightning, which is described scientifically as an electrical discharge.” In the illiterate peasant case, Smart thinks the peasant is talking about something which ‘happens to be’ identical in the strict sense to a brain process. The peasant is referring to a brain process in the same way as when people refer to electrical discharges when talking about lightning.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

There is No Captain Kirk: A Theory of Universal Lack of Personal Identity

- There is No Captain Kirk: A Theory of Universal Lack of Personal Identity There are multiple ways to interpret the second scenario provided to us. In general, the Captain Kirks in scenario two are either identical or they are not. Since we know that anything can only be numerically identical to itself, we also know that the two Kirks are not numerically or perfectly identical to each other. Thus, the question we are left with is: how are the two Kirks identical and how are they not....   [tags: Identity Essays]

Free Essays
1996 words (5.7 pages)

Behaviorism, Functionalism and the Identity Theory Essay

- “The universe contains only material or physical entities”, this is what materialism holds. However, the greatest challenge that goes to materialists is that of offering a plausible account of mind in a purely physical term. Therefore, some seductive analysis of mind with pure physical explanation of mental status must be suggested by materialists. There are three main theories that have been formulated to explain these scenarios. These theories include behaviorism, functionalism and the identity theory....   [tags: Materialism, Mental State]

Better Essays
1055 words (3 pages)

Kripke’s Modal Argument Against Type Identity Theories Essay

- Type identity theories are mainly concerned with the premise that the brain and the mind are identical and discuss mental states and reduce them to the physical. Saul Kripke made some influential criticisms to type identity theory. Kripke’s criticisms rely on views about essentialism, modality and possible world semantics, (Hanks) Kripke’s argument is directed at the thesis from Identity theory that each physical state is identical to an undifferentiated mental state, Kripke relies upon the concept of a rigid designator, and the necessity of this rigid designator to disprove statements of identity....   [tags: Saul Kripke, physical state, mental state, brain]

Better Essays
1889 words (5.4 pages)

Smart’s Belief That Brain-processes are Identical to Mental Sensations Essay

- Explain the way in which Smart argues that brain-processes are identical to mental sensations with respect to what he says about topic-neutral sensation language. Smart argues from the stance of identity theorist and believes that mental sensations are identical to a corresponding brain-process. Much of Smart’s paper is a counter argument against an identity theorist’s greatest rival, the dualist. Most of the human body has been explained by science in terms of biology, chemistry, and physics; though the brain remains largely mysterious....   [tags: identity theorist]

Better Essays
786 words (2.2 pages)

Essay on Responses to the Doctrine of Mind-Brain Identity

- Responses to the Doctrine of Mind-Brain Identity To be in pain is, for example, is to have one's c-fibres, or more likely a-fibres, firing in the central nervous system; to believe that broccoli will kill you is to have one's B(bk)-fibres firing, and so on. The Blackwell Companion to Philosophy:Chapter 5 'Philosophy of Mind' by William G. Lycan The theory or doctrine of mind-brain identity, as its name implies, denies the claim of dualists that mind and brain (or consciousness and matter) are distinct substances....   [tags: Philosophy Philosophical Papers]

Better Essays
2365 words (6.8 pages)

Meditation and the Brain Essay

- Meditation and the Brain When discussing the relationship of brain and behavior, the materialist view of human experience runs into conflict with the historically dominant religious accounts. Recent studies, however, suggests that there may be a "middle view" between the two world-views. Religions, especially Buddhism, stress the role of meditation in one's spiritual growth. Meditation has tangible psychological and physiological benefits, though, which can be explained strictly in neurobiological terms....   [tags: Biology Essays Research Papers]

Better Essays
1523 words (4.4 pages)

Intent as a dichotomic agent between folk psychology and identity theory

- The framework of choice for the contemporary philosophers of mind is physicalism, a position that integrates the study of mind within the ‘scientific’ human knowledge regulated by the laws of matter and energy. In this paper, I will provide arguments that support the incompatibility between two different theories of mind, namely mind-brain identity theory (IT) and folk psychology (FP) on logical grounds. The first part of the essay will familiarize the reader with the basic concepts, definitions and some of the key arguments employed by IT and FP....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
1681 words (4.8 pages)

Implicit Personality Theory and Stereotypes Essay

- According to Baron, Byrne & Suls in their book Attitudes: Evaluating the social world. (1989) they defined the term Social Psychology as “the scientific field that seeks to understand the nature and causes of individual behavior in social situations”. (p. 6). There are many concepts of social perception, two of these that will be looked at in this essay are Implicit Personality Theory and stereotypes. Implicit personality theory describes the beliefs, biases and assumptions, that an individual uses when he or she forms impressions on a stranger based on limited information....   [tags: Bias, Assumption, Prejudice]

Better Essays
1636 words (4.7 pages)

Dissociative Identity Disorder Essay

- Dissociative Identity Disorder (DID), formerly known as Multiple Personality Disorder (MPD) is considered by the American Psychiatric Association to be one of 4 main kinds of dissociative disorders (DSM-IV): "The essential feature of dissociative disorders is a disturbance or alteration in the normally integrative functions of identity, memory, or consciousness" (8). If identity is the main function affected, the person is said to have DID. Most non-DID people have one identity comprised of many parts that work harmoniously together....   [tags: Biology Essays Research Papers]

Better Essays
1529 words (4.4 pages)

Bhagavad Gita: The Theory of Soul vs. the Body Essay

- Imagine yourself walking past a homeless man. His hopeless eyes catch yours while he asks, “can you spare (should be spare) some loose change, please look to your soul.” If you were to look deep into a mirror past the exterior fixtures of the face and see into the inner sanctum: what would you find. Why do people reference the soul before the actions of the body, and why do we associate the soul to a higher state of harmony. In the short novel Bhagavad Gita, Krishna, the Vrishni prince believes that the only way to ultimate harmony is to reject the body, including the brain and embrace the soul....   [tags: harmony, body, soul, mind]

Better Essays
1282 words (3.7 pages)