Essay on The Scope of Free Speech: Categoricalism versus The Balancing Approach

Essay on The Scope of Free Speech: Categoricalism versus The Balancing Approach

Length: 1014 words (2.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

“Fag burns.” “DIE.” These slurs were scrawled outside the GLBT office at N.C. State last October. Should the instigator be indicted for hate speech in addition to vandalism? Was this expression an act of hate speech? Or was it free speech? Is the message he conveyed protected under the First Amendment? Two and a half centuries ago, the nation’s forefathers drafted the Constitution of the United States. The aim of the Constitution is to protect the values that this nation was built upon. This document, arguably one of the nation’s most important, encompasses values such as democracy, equality, religious tolerance, as well as the freedom of speech.
The free speech clause in the Bill of Rights states: “Congress shall make no law…abridging the freedom of speech” (US Const., amend I). This clause, albeit consists of a mere ten words, holds much power and affluence in the American unique way of life. It guarantees Americans the right to speak freely without censorship by preventing the government from restricting the rights of the people to express their opinions. Consequently, this freedom can encourage citizens’ participation in politics; promote an adaptable and tolerant community; facilitate the discovery of truth; and ultimately create a stable nation. However, how much freedom should be granted to an individual? Where should the line be drawn for the coverage free speech protection? (1) What happens when the exercise of free speech puts other constitutional values in jeopardy? What values should prevail? (2) In an attempt to address these questions, many opposing interpretations have been presented. While some construe this clause in an absolute, categorical approach, others take on a more lenient, balancing stance. (1)
In ca...

... middle of paper ...

...constitutional values. Even though categories can be applied without referencing the underlying principles, the establishment and rationalization of these categories rely heavily upon those values. Otherwise, the legitimacy and stability of the constitution can be undermined. Furthermore, both acknowledge that words that can result in harmful actions, such as yelling “Fire!” in public, do not have immunity from regulation. Even the devoted absolutist Justice Black was flexible when it comes to outlining the borders around “speech” He did not give all speech-like acts complete protection and was quick to classify speech acts that are out of bounds of the First Amendment. (1)

Ultimately, the divergence in interpretation boils down to the age-old conundrum: Rules versus standards.
Inevitably, there will always be those that will abuse the right to free speech.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about Efficient Distributed Dynamic Load Balancing

- Introduction Load balancing is the strategy of load redistribution among the computational elements(CE) of a heterogeneous network where they work cooperatively so that large loads can be distributed among them in a fair and effective manner. Load Balancing strategies ensure that the workload is distributed over all CEs according to their processing speed and availability in such a way that the overall execution time is minimized. But there are a wide variety of issues that need to be considered for heterogeneous environment....   [tags: Distributed Load Balancing]

Free Essays
3035 words (8.7 pages)

Speech : Speech - My Speech

- For my “How to do” speech my goal was to share with the class an interesting and informative way to learn something new. Due to the speeches time limit, I knew I needed to be well prepared. I wanted to be less nervous before and during my speech. While presenting I was nervous, but I didn’t really have time for these feelings to sink in because I was focused on the information I wanted to share with the audience. I enjoyed presenting in the second group of speeches so I could see my peers different types of speaking style....   [tags: Graduation, Commencement speech, Speech]

Strong Essays
969 words (2.8 pages)

The Implementation Of Balancing Project Essay

- The typical triangle with three interdependent variables, cost, time and scope, must include another important constraint operating in every project: Quality. This constraint should be analyzed in two ways, product and process quality (Wysocki, 2014). A project could be delivered in time, meeting cost and scope, however, it might to fail to comply quality standards (Schwalbe, 2014). The process of balancing project constrains includes the followings, but are not limited to: Scope, Quality, Schedule, Budget, Resources and risks (PMI, 2013)....   [tags: Project management, Management, Quality management]

Strong Essays
836 words (2.4 pages)

Essay about Cost, Time And Scope

- Most of the projects are approved out of three constraints; they are cost, time and scope. These three are important factors commonly called as triple constraint or frequently represented as a triangle. The above figure represents how the project should be deliverable with certain ideas, such as • project should be delivered within cost • Project should be delivered on time • Projects must meet the agreed scope – no more, no less • Project must also meet customer quality requirements Any organization when they take up project, they will do the work and be successful within this triple constraint....   [tags: Project management, Work breakdown structure]

Strong Essays
703 words (2 pages)

Speech Note On Speech Disorders

- Introduction Thousands of children suffer from speech impediments every year, and schools have the responsibility to treat them. A speech impediment is “a condition that makes it difficult to speak normally” (“Speech Impediment,” n.d.). I decided to research and write about speech disorders in schools, because I suffered from speech disorders when I was young and spent every elementary school year trying to treat it. It took me seven years to finally speak like the other students in my classes, and there must be a better system to treat children faster and more effectively....   [tags: Speech disorder, Speech sound disorder]

Strong Essays
1078 words (3.1 pages)

Speech Acts : Speech Act ( Speech )

- Speech Acts “Hey, can you reach that,” I asked pointing at a book on the top shelf. The boy standing next to me looked around before replying to ensure that I was, in fact, speaking to him. “Uh, yeah. The blue one?” He responded to confirm which book I had been pointing at. “Yep. Thanks, you’re a life saver.” “No problem,” he said as he handed me the book. I smiled at him before turning to walk back to the table I had been studying at. After reading that nothing about the interaction seems strange without understanding speech acts, particularly indirect speech acts....   [tags: Speech act, Pragmatics, Philosophy of language]

Strong Essays
1132 words (3.2 pages)

Freedom Of Speech And Expression

- Freedom of Speech and Expression Although we are guaranteed freedom of speech in our fundamental freedoms under section two of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, and freedom of expression under section two (b) of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, the Anti Terrorism Act infringes this right. Much of “political activity, including expression and activism that challenges government policy is and always has been a target of high policing in Canada.” (Larsen, M., 2015) Perhaps the government feels threatened by new ideas and does not want to be challenged....   [tags: Freedom of speech, Censorship, Freedom of thought]

Strong Essays
879 words (2.5 pages)

Graduation Speech by Faculty

- Congratulations. Today is your day. You're off to Great Places. You're off and away. You have brains in your head. You have feet in your shoes. You can steer yourself Any direction you choose. You're on your own. And you know what you know. And YOU are the guy who'll decide where to go. You'll look up and down streets. Look 'em over with care. About some you will say, "I don't choose to go there." With your head full of brains and your shoes full of feet, You're too smart to go down any not-so-good street....   [tags: Graduation Speech, Commencement Address]

Strong Essays
684 words (2 pages)

Graduation Speech

- Ladies, gentlemen, parents, friends, family, staff, fellow students: Instead of taking up more time and reading my speech, it is available to you at http://www.olen’ Thank you. No, just kidding. But seriously folks... Today we are gathered here to celebrate our graduation from 12 long years of schooling. The education granted to us has been a privilege. One so graciously given to us by the citizens of our state, by our community, and by our parents. Today would not be possible without them....   [tags: Graduation Speech, Commencement Address]

Strong Essays
1011 words (2.9 pages)

Balancing Act Essay

- Balancing Act For the working adult, being a full time college student can be quite stressful. It can also be challenging, fun, and rewarding. In order to become a successful student you must learn to balance and organize the different elements of your life. Three of the major elements will be work, studying and relaxing. If you can learn to balance these elements, you will find that success will be easier to achieve. As adults, most of us must work a full time job in order to support ourselves....   [tags: Essays Papers]

Strong Essays
453 words (1.3 pages)