Scientific And Ethical Issues Of Animal Experiments Essay

Scientific And Ethical Issues Of Animal Experiments Essay

Length: 1551 words (4.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

As practical and ethical issues play a major role in concerns linked with human experimentation, animal models have since been used in cancer research although the success rate of translation from the animal models to clinical trials have been less than 8%. This meaning the animal models is very limited in their ability to mimic the complex process of human carcinogenesis, physiology and progression where the safety and efficiency is not able to be translated to human trials. Animals can serve a purpose in the information in vivo but alternative techniques have emerged that could eventually replace the link between in vitro studies and clinical applications.
Prior to a new cancer drug being allowed to be dispensed, pharmaceutical companies conduct extensive pre-clinical studies both in vitro and and in vivo (animal experiments) to study the toxicity, efficacy, and pharmacokinetics. There is a growing concern over the limitations of animal research and the inability to provide reliable predictions for human clinical trials (Roberts et al., 2007) as although animal studies are said to be an overestimate by around 30% of the success of treatment, negative results are often left unpublished (Sena et al., 2010).

Colon cancer is a disease in which malignant cells form in tissues where genetic, dietary and environmental factors contribute to the pathogenesis, aetiology and preventative intervention (Potter, 1996). Traditionally animal models like adenomatous polyposis coli (Apc) gene mutant mice or azoxymethane (AOM)-induced rat colon cancer, which eventually show adenomas and carcinomas in the small intestine rather than in the colon (Moser et al., 1990, Fodde et al., 1994), have been used as a preclinical study to evaluate the toxic...

... middle of paper ...

...possible with the work involved with animal models where medicines have been produced with fewer side effects as well as vaccine candidates that may one day prevent HIV infection. Diabetes affects approximately 6.3% of the US population which is the leading cause of death and disability. Diabetes is also known to affect animals having been diagnosed in practically almost every breed of cat and dog. Treatments and medicines have been developed in animal models such as the fast and long acting insulin and islet transplantation for type 1 diabetes which without would cause premature deaths around the globe.
To conclude, animal research for the use of scientific and medical advancement will almost certainly carry on with slow progression for the reduction, replacement and refinement until the alternatives to animal experimentation outweigh the use of animals themselves.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Animal Testing Should Stop Essay

- ... However, it does tell nothing about the health of humans in consideration of the relationship with the disease (“Animal Experimentation,” n.d.). What it only does is to mislead people and delay medical progress (“Animal Experimentation,” n.d.). ARGUMENTATION Animal experimentation is both painful and unnecessary according to the resources in the literature review section. It is because of the fact that animal physiology, anatomy, and metabolism are not the same as the physiology, anatomy, and metabolism of people (“Problems with Animal Research,” n.d.)....   [tags: scientific experiments, animal rights]

Strong Essays
1946 words (5.6 pages)

Essay on The Ethical Treatment Of Animal Experimentation

- In discussions of animal rights, one controversial issue has been animal experimentation. On the one hand, advocates argue that all animals have the right to not be exploited for experimentation. On the other hand, skeptics contend that animal experimentation is necessary in order to improve human health. I strongly believe that animal experimentation is unnecessary as it can be unreliable and cruel. Animals should not be forced to suffer for research. Alternatives for animal experimentation are on the rise and eventually these experimentations will come to an end for the better....   [tags: Animal testing, Animal rights]

Strong Essays
2243 words (6.4 pages)

Essay on Animal Experiments And The Human Studies Approach

- Chapters 5 and 7 The premise of KSF’s argument is that “the human studies approach is often wrong and should not be used to discredit plausible animal evidence for hypothesizing human harm” (KSF, 58). Essentially, the reason for hypothesis building in animals is to reduce the amount of harm that could be applied to humans later on. In practice, KSF explains that the human-studies approach has been used by the U.S. chemical industry to reject experimental data from animals, in favor of “human-epidemiological data” to prove that specific pesticides can affect children (KSF, 60)....   [tags: Scientific method, Science, Theory, Hypothesis]

Strong Essays
799 words (2.3 pages)

Animal Experimentation Is Not Ethical! Essay example

- An ongoing conflict among the human species is that of animal cruelty, whether it be by scientific experiments, tests, or research. I frequently wonder, do the individuals performing these atrocious tasks ask themselves if what he/she is doing is ethically correct. I believe that it is not right to treat animals in such an inhumane manner, but to treat them as our own kind, for they are clever, spirited beings. These helpless animals cannot defend themselves against abuse. In my opinion, it is morally appropriate to grant the same rights to animals as we human beings acquire and to end, or even just to minimize, animal cruelty in laboratories....   [tags: ethics, animal rights, rhetorical]

Strong Essays
731 words (2.1 pages)

Animal Testing: A True Ethical Dilemma Essay

- Imagine a life locked away in a cage with no form of control on your existence. It’s cold, dark, and you are scared. You don’t have a choice of what you eat, where you live, or how you are treated. You are unsure if it is day or night or what will happen to you next. You are locked away in a prison cell and you committed no crime. This is the life of a laboratory animal. Animal testing is the use of animals for scientific research purposes and experiments. It can be used for the findings of cures and medicines to testing new drugs, to understanding the behavioral psychology of the animals themselves....   [tags: Animal Rights]

Strong Essays
1612 words (4.6 pages)

Cruel Experiments on Animals Essay

- Animals have been used in testing for over 2,000 years. Animal experimentation was established around the second century. Mice, rabbits, bunny’s, reptiles , guinea pigs and other animals are all victims of animal experimentation . Companies such as Almay, Revlon, Opi and Wet n’ Wild are some of the companies that do not test on animals. According to the website RSPCA, it is estimated that more than 100 million animals are used in experiments each year across the world. Scientists say that animal experimentation is necessary for a variety of things....   [tags: animal experimentation]

Strong Essays
630 words (1.8 pages)

Animal Ethics And Animal Experimentation Essay

- A major ethical concern that has been under speculation for many of years is focused around animal ethics, and whether or not certain animal practices are just or inhuman. There are many questions that focus around fundamental issues concerning the moral status of animals. It is critical to understand the difference between a concern for animal welfare and a concern for animal rights. A current issue that is important to understand and analyze is animal experimentation, and although many consider it to be an unethical practice, there are many pros and cons to the controversial topic....   [tags: Animal rights]

Strong Essays
737 words (2.1 pages)

Essay on Animal experimentation in the UK

- Animal experimentation, also known as animal research and animal testing, is an experimental procedure in which animals are used within academic, scientific, research, biological and commercial establishments. It is when using live animals is considered legal, protected and regulated by law, because their ability to benefit humans is very important. Moreover, people of the world have improved their understanding about their lives, their health, the problems related to health and how to solve them, how to prevent them in the future by carrying out such experiments on animals....   [tags: Ethical Issues, Animal Testing]

Strong Essays
2477 words (7.1 pages)

Essay on Animal Cruelty

- Is animal testing cruelty or science. This is the question that many people ask to themselves, and is one of the many controversial topics in today’s society. In my point of view animal testing is cruelty because animals can’t talk for themselves so they get kill and hurt, and we also violated their right by doing this. Anjo a member of the Animal Liberation Front (ALF) said “Animals feel pain; they have a right to decent life” (Nancy Day 2000, pg.12). It is difficult to determine how many animals are used for research, but experts agree the number is declining....   [tags: Science Experiment, Animal Testing]

Strong Essays
1901 words (5.4 pages)

Animal Experimentation Essay

- I have always had a great admiration for animals. Being an animal owner of two dogs, I believe that they are a friend of the human and both benefit from each other in the sense of company and joy. They are also great contributors to the balance of the eco system. These are some of the various reasons why I chose this topic. In this research paper I will inform you, the reader of the horrible experiences that innocent animals have to endure due to the fact that supporters believe that animal experimenting is a humane method of bettering our lives....   [tags: Animal Rights ]

Strong Essays
1831 words (5.2 pages)