Essay on The Realist Perspective On The Iran Nuclear Deal

Essay on The Realist Perspective On The Iran Nuclear Deal

Length: 791 words (2.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The realist perspective offers the most convincing explanation for both Iran’s initial urge to build nuclear capabilities and western countries’ response. While constructivist and liberal arguments may address the possible reasons that the nuclear deal may fail, neither is as convincing as the realist argument.
The realist perspective rationally and coherently accounts for the motives behind each country’s decision making during the Iran Nuclear Deal. Realists argue that imposing military force is one way to achieve hegemony for a state, and thus it is not a surprise that Iran, a marginalized country that has continually been in conflict with the United States, has developed nuclear weapons. Realists would argue that it is natural for Iran to develop means to protect themselves, especially since it is often in direct conflict with the United States and could hypothetically achieve hegemony if it used its force correctly.
The United States’ decisions in the Iran Nuclear Deal can also be explained from a realist perspective. After the Iran Nuclear Deal officially passed on July 14, 2015, Al Jazeera quoted Barack Obama when he stated, “This deal is not built on trust. It is built on verification” (Kutsch). As we can see through Obama’s rhetoric, the United States is not expecting Iran to uphold the deal based on pressures from social norms or moral obligation; instead, the United States chose to insert powerful components of the sanctions that would create forced accountability for Iran (Kutsch). Thus, one may deduce that, despite coming to an agreement, the United States still does not trust Iran due to the United States’s realist belief that every state is only looking out for himself.
Furthermore, examining the Iran Nuclear D...

... middle of paper ...

...tions and norms; however, this notion seems absurd, especially considering the millions of lives that could potentially be lost if Iran were to deviate from such norms and employ the nuclear bombs.

Ultimately, the Iran Nuclear Deal can be rationally analyzed from all three paradigms (realism, liberalism, and constructivism). Both liberalism and constructivism argue that the sanctions will pave way to a more stable future, but that seems unlikely for a country with Iran’s tumultuous past. Ultimately, after analyzing both Iran’s and the United States’s actions in the Iran Nuclear Deal, the merits of the realist perspective become clear. Nuclear weapons will continue to be the subject of debate among scholars, and the ongoing Iran Nuclear Deal will be an interesting case study on the effects that weapons of mass destruction have on states’ decision-making.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on America and Iran's Nuclear Program

- The ongoing struggle between the Iran and the United States over Iran’s quest to acquire nuclear weapons has led to different ideas and proscriptions to solve the problem. In one particular quote, an unknown speaker advocates that it is in the best interest of the United States and its allies to strike Iran if diplomacy fails, calling this the most prudent option. This controversial idea must be considered not only in its short-term effects, but also in the long-term result. Although it may be tempting to use nuclear weapons and long-range missiles to disarm Iran, it would be far too costly for the U.S....   [tags: Foreign Relations]

Better Essays
1764 words (5 pages)

Iran Nuclear Deal With Iran Essay

- Iran Nuclear Deal The Nation of the P-5 plus 1 includes China, United States, Russia, and Great Britain plus one is Germany they are trying to negotiate a deal with Iran to prevent Iran from getting a nuclear bomb and having a nuclear arms race in the Middle East. Both sides have different opinion on the matter by expressing their differences of opinion, despite both sides emphasizing who’s right and who’s wrong on the censure simplicity on the subject of the nuclear arms issue which is very complicated....   [tags: United States, Iran, Islam, Cold War]

Better Essays
1022 words (2.9 pages)

Iran 's Views On Iran Essay

- I think Iran is going to have the most powerful and regional influence in the region in the next 25 years. Even though I believe the other tow pillar, Turkey and Egypt, are going to play major role as well, but I do not think they will be as influential as Iran. The realist view of Iran leaders gives them advantage over their competitors. I will argue that the regime in Iran is more stable than the one in Turkey or Egypt. Iran survives decades of sanction and boycott and manage to keep good economic progress in very difficult circumstances....   [tags: Iraq, Syria, Turkey, Iran]

Better Essays
1233 words (3.5 pages)

Realist and Liberalist Perspectives of Globalization Essay

- Why and how did globalization occur. Different perspectives have different explanations as to why and how globalization evolved. Realists argue that international trade is most effective when there is hegemony in the world market, whereas liberalists believe that it is a matter of how countries use the idea of reciprocity in their decision about trade. I agree with the realist perspective because hegemony allows the global economy to enhance and international trade functions the best when a hegemon dominates the world market....   [tags: Globalization, International Trade]

Better Essays
741 words (2.1 pages)

Essay on The Iran Nuclear Deal

- ... 75 percent of the work that it takes to reach 90 percent purity is done once the uranium reaches 3.5 percent, and once it reaches 20 percent it is only a small fraction of the process away from achieving the goal. So Iran’s storage of uranium that are already enriched to 20 percent is very close to being ready for nuclear weapons use. In August of this year, International Atomic Energy Association reported Iran’s stockpiles contain 185 Kg of uranium enriched to 20 percent, which is below the 205 Kg needed to convert into a nuclear bomb....   [tags: weaponry, nuclear, war, program]

Better Essays
2053 words (5.9 pages)

U.s. Obama 's Deal With Iran Essay

- In the US, the Right is obsessed with bombing Iran: radio commentators, journalists and presidential candidates constantly threaten military force against the Persian nation. While it seems likely that Obama 's deal with Iran will make it through US Congress, the world should take right-wing threats of violence seriously. Indeed, the prospect of a republican US President, and a republican controlled US Senate, House and Supreme Court should terrify even the most cynical amongst us. Here, we should reject ideological games and political litmus tests....   [tags: George W. Bush, President of the United States]

Better Essays
1187 words (3.4 pages)

Iran Between Iran And Iran Essays

- Despite official optimistic statements of parties to the agreement, and the fact that Iran has fundamentalist ideology, and the objective of exporting the revolution, many experts rightly believe that “Iran remains Iran.” In particular, Bahraini Foreign Minister Sheikh Khalid bin Ahmed Al Khalifa, said that Iran and ISIS "are two sides of the same coin". On November 21, 2015, Iran once again conducted ballistic missile tests of the middle class “Qadr-110”. The missiles have a range of 1800-2000 kilometers and trials were held in the port city of Shabahar....   [tags: Iran, Ruhollah Khomeini, Iranian Revolution]

Better Essays
776 words (2.2 pages)

A Formal Declaration Of War On Iran Essay

- If Hussein would have waited and had given a formal declaration of war on Iran, things could have turned out differently for the Iraqis. The Iranians would have had time to gather their forces and defend their borders more adequately and caused a lot more resistance for the Iraqis to push through. However, this could have been either disastrous or a big victory for the Iraqis. The now unified and strong border defense could have wiped out the attacking Iraqi force and would have been a devastating blow to the Iraqis from which it would have been tough to recover....   [tags: Iran, Iraq, Iraq War, Iran–Iraq War]

Better Essays
706 words (2 pages)

The War Between Iran And Iraq Essay

- The History of Two Nations at War Iran and Iraq’s relations have been hostile since the Iran-Iraq war, also known as the first Persian Gulf War. The war lasted from September 1980 to August 1988, making it the 20th century 's longest conventional war. Saddam, who was the 5th president of Iraq, was so amused with the continuous battles that he made it a point to have the Iraqi 25-dinar note display the Battle of al-Qadisiyyah on its currency. For nearly nine years, both countries suffered millions of casualties and lost countless amounts of dollars in destruction (Karsh, 2002)....   [tags: Iran, Iraq, Iran–Iraq War, Saddam Hussein]

Better Essays
1017 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on Problems with Iran

- Problems with Iran Iran is a country located in the Middle East. The main source of income for the country is oil, the one object that had greatly influenced its history. Iran's present government is run as an Islamic Republic. A president, cabinet, judicial branch, and Majilesor or legislative branch, makes up the governmental positions. A revolution that overthrew the monarch, which was set in 1930, lasted over 15 years. Crane Brinton's book, An Anatomy of a Revolution, explains set of four steps a country experiences when a revolution occurs....   [tags: Iran Economics Allies History Essays]

Free Essays
3797 words (10.8 pages)