Essay about Productivity or Dependency of Immigrants

Essay about Productivity or Dependency of Immigrants

Length: 1824 words (5.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Productivity or Dependency of Immigrants

As the years pass, America becomes an increasingly diverse civilization. Millions of people are enticed to leave their homeland and cross national borders to enhance their quality of life. America represents grand possibilities of better jobs, improved familial economic conditions and an education, whether it be learning a trade or receiving formal academic guidance. Immigrants are stereotypically viewed upon as those who accept the lowest paying jobs that most native-born Americans will not take, which is considered to be productive in nature for the benefit of the American economy. Yet, to the natives of the host country, immigrants are seen as a threat by competing for those scarce jobs that do not require any education or training, especially during an era where unemployment is on the rise. However, isn’t it better for the economy if the immigrants entering the country are productive, even in the lower paying jobs, rather than dependent on financial aide from the government? This question will be addressed, while comparing two different groups of migrants, the Tongans and the Hmong people, in their experiences of productivity versus dependency as they assimilate in America.

Historically, the western culture reigns superior in America, and still stands true today. Immigrants and refugees are compelled to assimilate to the western culture, especially acquiring the language skills needed to communicate with the majority. Learning English is a very difficult task according to the majority of immigrants, including the Hmong and the Tongans. The Hmong originated from China, but had moved around to Thailand, Laos and Vietnam. Their journey to the United States was a long, distressful ...

... middle of paper ...

...this, tension between the two groups could escalate, instilling resentment towards immigrants and refugees by the native-born Americans, and fear of being discriminated against for the immigrants. There has been talk of closing America’s doors, especially after September 11th, or only allowing educated immigrants in who will produce for the economy rather than strain our financial resources. These are extremist ideas and would only create global resentment towards America. Thus, there needs to be some form of meeting in the middle and it is up to our government to appease both sides, in order to maintain America’s tradition of opportunity for all.


Koltyk, J., New Pioneers in the Heartland, 1998, Allyn & Bacon, Needham Heights, MA.

Small, C., From Tongan Villages to American Suburbs, 1997, Cornell University Press, United States of America.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Illegal Immigration Is A Nation Of Immigrants Essay

- For good reason, it is often said the United States is a nation of immigrants. Almost every person in the United States is descended from somewhere foreign country. This article tells how illegal immigration to in United States has positives and negatives economic impact. The overall rate of legal and illegal immigration in the 2000s was almost as high as it was between 1905 and 1915, the peak decade of immigration in American history. 13.9 million Immigrants arrived in the 2000s, bringing the national total to forty million; the number of illegal immigrants in the country continued to grow up, More than 10 million undocumented aliens currently reside in the U.S., and that population is gr...   [tags: Immigration to the United States]

Powerful Essays
772 words (2.2 pages)

Society´s Dependence on the Internet as in The Machine Stops by E.M. Forster

- The Internet provides accuracy, productivity, and possibilities that would affect our day-to-day lives if suddenly missing. Because of man’s resiliency, I don’t think that we would experience Armageddon if the Internet stopped; our world would not be better or worse without the Internet. I believe our world would become different for a while; need and desire would quickly lead the way to new and improved technology to advance and rebuild a more powerful system. I believe that on a personal basis if the Internet were to be lost people would be affected in varying degrees....   [tags: technology, digital immigrants, digital natives]

Powerful Essays
946 words (2.7 pages)

Essay on Theu.s. Government Should Have A More Open Policy Towards Immigrants

- As Franklin D. Roosevelt emphasized: “Remember, remember always, that all of us, and you and I especially, are descended from immigrants.” We have to admit that America cannot be successful without the integral and dynamic immigration waves. Today, the U.S government should have a more open policy towards immigrants; part of that is raising people’s awareness about the issue. It is the best solution to the aging population crisis; it boosts the U.S. economy, and it fulfills humanitarian responsibilities....   [tags: Immigration, Immigration to the United States]

Powerful Essays
1258 words (3.6 pages)

Essay on Technology in Forster's The Machine Stops

- The Internet provides accuracy, productivity, and possibilities that would be devastating if suddenly missing. Because of man’s resiliency, I don’t think that we would experience Armageddon if the Internet stopped. I do believe our world would become larger for a while. The miles shortened by email would lengthen due to postage delivery. The nanosecond returns to a minute, and memory would be placed back in photo albums and diaries. All changes would be temporary until necessity, and personal desire would lead the way to new technology....   [tags: digital immigrants, digital natives, technology]

Powerful Essays
732 words (2.1 pages)

Media System Dependency Theory Essay

- Media system dependency is a theory that predicts people in society will use media for interpersonal needs and goals. It is researched as a system that allows people to meet these goals through sources of information found in different media forms (Loges & Ball-Rokeach, 1993). While media does help us understand who we are, and possibly what we may be becoming, it can also give us insight to the outside world. Media gives the consumer what is desired, and often that is the intense, hostile, and sometimes hopeless views of the world around us....   [tags: Media System Dependency]

Powerful Essays
3057 words (8.7 pages)

A Genealogy Of Dependency By Nancy Fraser And Linda Gordon Essay

- In “A Genealogy of Dependency”, written by Nancy Fraser and Linda Gordon the author’s dissect the word dependency. Dependency is in relation to welfare and government assistance, and how this one meaning has changed throughout history. It is very important to note that although dependency has not always carried a negative mark, it has once upon a time and when it did it was comparable to native people, black people, and women in particular. In this essay I will discuss three main areas from this book that I considered important to me....   [tags: Unemployment, Welfare, Slavery, Dependency]

Powerful Essays
738 words (2.1 pages)

Human Dependence on Gadgets Essay

- The history of gadgets goes back to those times when humans first started creating tools to make their lives easier. Various devices and appliances were created for specific practical reasons and were perceived as novelties in the beginning, due to the cautiousness in dealing with anything unfamiliar. The industry and technological advances of today has facilitated the invention of gadgets so numerous and varied that today most of the human life aspects are controlled or affected by technology. Once people started and ended up their day by looking at someone they loved....   [tags: Face to Face, Digital Technology]

Powerful Essays
899 words (2.6 pages)

IT and Productivity Essay

- PRO- As we have discussed in the previous sections that information technology is making its mark into a number of field. We can see the impact of information technology in many fields. We will now see how information technology has been effective in a number of sectors and how each sector has benefitted from IT. 1. Financial Sector Financial sector has evolved rapidly over a period of time and its one of the areas of economy that has benefitted the most from Information Technology. Consider 40-50 years back all the records has been kept in the thick ledger books....   [tags: financial sector, agriculture sector]

Powerful Essays
1207 words (3.4 pages)

Immigrants in America Essay

- America is traditionally a country of immigrants. Very few people today have relatives who were Native Americans, many of them because of religious persecution, and others because of they were just looking to start a new life on the exciting untouched frontier. For instance, in Florida, the first arrivals were European, beginning with the Spanish explorer Ponce de Leon who explored the land in 1513, following French and Spanish settlement during the 16th century. From the past, America was seen as a country of opportunities....   [tags: Mexican immigrants, immigration]

Powerful Essays
515 words (1.5 pages)

Substance Abuse and Chemical Dependency Essay

- Substance Abuse and Chemical Dependency Substance abuse is the improper use of chemicals that can alter the way one’s mind and body functions (TCC). In most cases, these chemicals would be referred to as a drug. Substance abuse can and may lead to chemical dependency or addiction. Dependence is the development of tolerance to chemicals which leads to symptoms of withdrawal. Substance abuse is a process that reflects a complicated interaction between the individual, the abused substance, and society (   [tags: Drugs Social Issues Dependence Essays]

Powerful Essays
633 words (1.8 pages)