Patient Participation in Decision-Making

Patient Participation in Decision-Making

Length: 681 words (1.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓

Are decision making of doctors really beneficial for patients? Often patients give up all autonomy for the doctor’s perceived great knowledge of the health services. But as in all humans self-interest almost always clouds one decision on what is best. Terence Ackerman claims noninterference is bad because it does not consider effects of illness of a patient (Degrazia, Mappes, and Ballard 70-140) . Meaning that noninterference in regards to autonomy; makes the doctors job and decision very simple, “let the patient decide.” This is often a tragic case because most patients do not understand the consequences or benefits of a health decision or procedure. Thus why Edmund Pellegrino argues the central paradox in medicine is the tension between self-interest altruism, which means unselfishness (Degrazia, Mappes, and Ballard 70-140). Lying to patients for self-interest is an injustice on all levels and I will prove why.
In a recent and very disturbing case a doctor named Kermit Gosnell was doing abortions. One may ask, well what the big issue is. Yes abortions are a sad but common part of our society. Before I discuss the terms in how the abortions were carried out, I will disclose who he was helping. People in the West Philadelphia are part a very impoverished community. Dr. Gosnell catered to poor, immigrant, and minority women (Walters, and Dale ). So was he being the hero and savior to these women or doing an injustice? Dr. Gosnell’s procedures often consisted of late term abortions, which is after 23 weeks. Dr. Gosnell was performing abortions as late as 7 months. Often the procedure for late abortions is to dismember the body inside the uterus and remove by pieces. Dr. Gosnell was inducing labor and doing what he termed as “snipping.” After the babies were born he would cut open their necks and with scissors cut the spinal cord (Walters, and Dale ). And with Howard Browdy’s transparency model of informed consent there was a huge injustice to the patients. The transparency model consists of the physicians basic thinking is rendered clear or transparent. This is achieved through talking out loud with the patient and in a language or laymen terms for patient understanding. At least two women died from the procedures, while scores more suffered perforated bowels, cervixes, and uteruses.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Patient Participation in Decision-Making." 22 Nov 2019

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Persuasive Speech : Decision Making

- When you increase participation in decision making it can become quite time consuming, as there are more opinions and ideas it can make it much more difficult to actually come to a conclusion. Often times when we are in the middle of a staff meeting it can become rather heated. You have several groups of associates with varied opinions on what they want to happen, as well as a few associates who just want the meeting to end so they can either go back to work or go home. Delays in decision making weaken my leadership ability directly, by taking time away from other areas in the clinic....   [tags: Leadership, Decision making, Management]

Research Papers
1277 words (3.6 pages)

Essay on Ethics And Ethical Decision Making

- In health care settings nurses are continuously dealing with various ethical problems and dilemmas. Ethical dilemma arises when there are equal moral obligations for or against two or more possible courses of action (College of Nurses of Ontario, 2008). Very often, there are not only simple ethical problems but rather complex issues involved many participants and multiple decisions. According to Wilson-Barnett (1986), nurses are more aware of its participation in decision making involving ethical issues....   [tags: Ethics, Decision making, Bioethics, Virtue]

Research Papers
1072 words (3.1 pages)

The Concept Of Patient Participation Essay

- Patient participation has been poorly defined especially in nursing practice due to lack of freedom from indistinctness or ambiguity in health care (Sahlsten, Larsson, Sjostrom, & Plos, 2008). The concept of patient participation plays an important role in health care nationally and globally. The meaning of patient participation varies greatly based on individual patient and nurse’s perception. This concept analysis it to gain clarity through Walker and Avant concept analysis method by identifying and presenting the purpose, attributes, model case, antecedents, consequences and empirical referents of the concepts....   [tags: Nursing, Concept, Operational definition]

Research Papers
2067 words (5.9 pages)

The Synergy Model For Patient Care Essay

- The synergy model for patient care was created by a panel of nurses from the American Association of Critical-Care Nurses (AACN) during the early 1990s (Hardin, 2013). The synergy model for patient care is a nursing model that is widely used in evidence-based research and nursing practice. This model is predominantly used in the critical care setting and was created as a framework for certified nursing practice (McEwen, 2014). Theory Classification It is categorized as a middle range theory, but according to McEwen (2014), it is considered a high middle range theory (Hardin, 2013)....   [tags: Nursing, Nurse, Patient, Nursing theory]

Research Papers
1208 words (3.5 pages)

Patient Satisfaction : The Nurse 's Role Essay

- Patient satisfaction: The nurse’s role Our one main purpose, as nurses, is most importantly patient care. Nurses know that the need of others is why they are brought onto this role. Although, there are times where patients are dissatisfied with their care. Whether, it is the lack of communication, an issue with the doctor, other staff, or the nurse. What could we do to satisfy patients in there time of need. Patients are cared for by many healthcare personal, but the nurse is there when they are at their worst state....   [tags: Nursing, Nurse, Patient, Health care provider]

Research Papers
1261 words (3.6 pages)

Advance Health Directive ( Ahd ) Did Or Could Have Influenced The Patient 's Care

- Advance Health Directive 
 Discuss about how an Advance Health Directive (AHD) did or could have influenced the patient’s care. 
 Introduction Advance Health Directive (AHD) is a formal way through which people make decision about their future healthcare in the event of them losing their decision-making capacity.1 AHD often involved the medical treatment that a patient wishes to receive as well as the appointment of an attorney to make future healthcare decision on behalf of the patient.1 AHD is part of Advance Care Planning (ACP), which is also known as the living will process through which people, in consultation with their family, friends and health professionals, make decisions about t...   [tags: Medicine, Health care, Decision making]

Research Papers
1052 words (3 pages)

The Effect Of A Patient Advisory Council ( Pac ) Has On Adult Inpatient Satisfaction

- Illustration of the Impacts generated by a Patient Advisory Council For decades, patient satisfaction has been considerably lower in the United States compared to other countries (Joachim, Blendon, Zaslavsky, & Campbell 2016). Patients and family members are increasing by asked to be more involved in the healthcare evolution. Today, patient satisfaction is a commonly used tool used to assess quality care. The aim of this research is to reveal the effects a Patient Advisory Council (PAC) has on adult inpatient satisfaction....   [tags: Patient, Health care provider, Healthcare]

Research Papers
1853 words (5.3 pages)

Essay Participation, Facilitation and Power

- Model for everyday/everynight An everyday approach to participation is a concept that identifies the involvement of the person. The assessment and care plans are discussed with the people they are written about but are not always written with. Often the assessment and care plans rely on the input of medical or relatives to complete areas choice. It can be argued, how this could be possible to determine when the person with dementia is not asked to contribute. This experience of non-inclusive decision making describes the participation of another person, a proxy-respondent and not the respondent person’s viewpoint (Tyrrell,2008)....   [tags: Communication ]

Research Papers
1476 words (4.2 pages)

Essay about Chimerix’s Decision to Grant an Experimental Drug to a Terminal Patient

- Josh Hardy of Virginia struggled with health issues throughout his young life. After his most recent bone marrow transplant in January 2014, he was unable to recover and lay hospitalized with an adenovirus. The rare experimental medicine is not available in hospitals like St. Jude which he is in. The life-saving medication is only carried by a specialized company called Chimerix. The drug Brincidofovir has not yet been released by the Food and Drug Administration to the public yet. Chimerix previously had a “compassionate care” program that enabled those in medical need to request Brincidofovir and they were granted with the drug, however Chimerix recently strayed away from this program and...   [tags: values, denied, hospitality]

Research Papers
2991 words (8.5 pages)

Making Decisions: A Case Study Essay

- MAKING DECISIONS: A CASE STUDY OF INCLUSION, COMMUNICATION AND WELL BEING Introduction and rationale Communication is the sharing of information and it is needed to confirm our identity and our individualism. Allan and Killick (2008, p.212) describe the relationship we have with others in “As social animals, we conduct our lives in the context of relationships which rely on communication”. A person with dementia can often be excluded from the communication process through many internal or external barriers....   [tags: Inclusion, Communication, Well Being]

Research Papers
1907 words (5.4 pages)

Almost none of the sedated patients knew their babies had been delivered alive and then killed. Many were first-time mothers who were told they were 24 weeks pregnant, even if they were much further along
Under Pennsylvania law, abortions are illegal after 24 weeks of pregnancy, or just less than six months, and most doctors won't perform them after 20 weeks because of the risks. Those are acts of a virtuous doctor who puts the patient and well-being first. These are average prices for abortions: Up to 12 weeks LMP- $395; 13 & 14 weeks LMP- $495; 15 & 16 weeks LMP- $650; 17 & 18 weeks LMP- $825; 19 & 20 weeks LMP- $1050; 21 & 22 weeks LMP $1350; 23 weeks LMP - $1750; More than 23 weeks LMP- $2250 ( madison). His prices were not that much different, Dr. Gosnell was saying yes where majority of other doctors would have said no. Gosnell didn't advertise, but word got around. Women came from across the city, state and region for illegal late-term abortions. People knew near and far that if you needed a late-term abortion you could go see Dr. Gosnell, white women from the suburbs were ushered into a separate, slightly cleaner area because Gosnell believed they were more likely to file complaints. They paid $325 for first-trimester abortions and $1,600 to $3,000 for abortions up to 30 weeks. The clinic took in $10,000 to $15,000 a day he made millions since the clinics opening in 1979 (Walters, and Dale).
I am totally against what Dr. Gosnell was performing. Not only was he going against what is the accepted standard for other doctors, he was lying to his patients. I am strong advocate of Roger Higgs who believes lying should be totally a last resort after all alternatives have been sought out (Degrazia, Mappes, and Ballard 70-140). Dr. Gosnell was lying to give comfort to the women there and receive money. On the surface of the women it seemed like a win-win situation, but in reality women were being physically destroyed and swindled. After the abortions they would still suffer from lack of sanitary condition, instruments, and proper procedure. There are few to no supporters of what he has done for so long.

Works Cited

Walters, P. , and M Dale. "DA: West Philadelphia abortion doctor killed 7 babies with scissors." 6 ABC Action News 21 jan 2011. Web. 19 Oct. 2011. .
Madison abortion Clinic
Degrazia, D., T.A. Mappes, and J.B. Ballard. Biomedical Ethics. 7th . New York: McGraw-Hill Higher Education, 2011. 70-140.

Return to