Essay about The National Identity Of Afghanistan

Essay about The National Identity Of Afghanistan

Length: 1282 words (3.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The political backdrop of the destruction of the Buddhas of Bamiyan in revising the national identity of Afghanistan can be explored through Kohl’s idea that archaeological data is manipulated for nationalist purposes. Philip Kohl, a professor of Anthropology asserted in “Nationalism and Archaeology: On the Constructions of Nations and the Reconstructions of the Remote Past” that the field of archaeology in many states is often influenced by a desire to assert their own nationalistic agenda as established by his statement that “control of the past provides a source of legitimization for control of the future” (Kohl 236). this can be applied to the Taliban’s movement of negative curation as they pursued a strategy of erasing specific pasts to control the present.
Igor Kopytoff, a practitioner in cultural anthropology, in The Cultural Biography of Things: Communication as Process frames the definition of a commodity as an “item with use value that also has exchange value” (Kopytoff). Kopytoff also explores how in contemporary Western thought physical objects represent the natural universe of commodities while people are place at the opposite pole as representing the natural universe of singularization (Kopytoff). The Buddhas of Bamiyan are established as commodities shown by how Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York had offered to buy the statues. This can be interpreted to mean that the sale of cultural heritage is not a crime, but the destruction of it is, because it prevents the cultural heritage of ever being sold or possessed again. The media through equating heritage with ancient artifacts and monuments, turned the discussion of damage to Afghanistan’s past into the territory of commodities as well (Pollack). Thus when cul...


... middle of paper ...


...age affects the enemy’s property, while the demolition of the Buddhas of Bamiyan concerns the Afghan Nation’s heritage. Furthermore, the demolition was carefully planned, painstakingly announced to the global media, and cynically documented in all its phases of preparation, bombing and ultimate destruction (Francesco, Lenzerini). In addition, the act was a planned and deliberate act of defiance against the United Nations and the international community.
The examination of the tragic destruction of the Buddhas of Bamiyan by the Taliban regime, shows how nationalistic regimes wield archaeology as a political tool because of the ideological significance placed on these heritage monuments and artifacts. The loss of heritage that derives or negative heritage is a crime that affects generations to come, as it erases the cultural memory that links the past to the present.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Modernization: Afghanistan vs. Turkey Essay

- Afghanistan was used as a buffer zone during the Great Game by Soviet Union and the Great Britain. They did not provide Afghanistan with the means to industrialize and that is why Afghanistan remains subsistence agriculture and a reinter state. With the decline of Colonialism after the Third Angola-Afghan war Afghanistan declared Independent (Barfield). When Amanullah Khan seized the throne he was very enthusiastic to develop a strong and modern state. Before Amanullah Khan only some effort had been taken place for state building according to Charles Tilly which was exterminating the internal rival, during the reign of Amir Abdul Rahman Khan, he centralized the power....   [tags: international relations]

Better Essays
2265 words (6.5 pages)

The Education System Of Afghanistan Essay

- Education in Afghanistan did not start as a formal system. Originally children were educated privately. Their learning took place in religious locations, in homes and regal courts (Zoy, 2009, p. 18). In 1923, the first Afghan Constitution was created. At this time, education was recognized as the right of all Afghan nationals. However, the growth and development of the education system by the Afghan government really started in 1950s-60s. The government was attempting to build a national identity through education....   [tags: Special education, Education]

Better Essays
916 words (2.6 pages)

Importance of Afghanistan in Inner Asian Geopolitics Essay

- 1. Afghanistan: The unique lebensraum Sir Halford John Mackinder in his famous –Heartland theory changed the concept of world geopolitics by saying- “Who rules East Europe commands the Heartland, Who rules the Heartland commands the World-Island Who rules the World-Island commands the world.” Afghanistan geographically lies in the periphery of Central Asia, yet this does not reduce its geostrategic importance in the geopolitical phenomena of this region. Not only geographical contiguity, common racial, ethnic, cultural and religious threads of connection make Afghanistan interlinked with Tajikistan, Uzbekistan and Turkmenistan and other countries of Central Asia....   [tags: modern day theocracies]

Better Essays
2696 words (7.7 pages)

Afghanistan Under the Rule of the Musahiban Family Essay

- ... This tunnel is vital for the economic growth of Afghanistan. Another important success in the history of Afghanistan was the emergence of an intellectual class and their efforts for political reforms. The university student become active politically and demonstrated in the streets. For mobilizing rural area a lot of energy needed. The university students were living in mass and had shared common identity. In the past the politics were played by the royal family and now we have intelligentsia and Islamic scholars claim in politics....   [tags: economy, education, success, failure]

Better Essays
2051 words (5.9 pages)

Women’s Rights Violations in Afghanistan Essay

- Ever since the Taliban took over they have been violating the rights of their people especially the women. If seen anywhere alone or uncovered the women get punished usually either getting beat or held captive. This is very common for the women in Afghanistan to experience. The Taliban uses the Islamic Koran book as their way of doing things. The Islamic Koran is a sacred book seen as almost like a bible. The Taliban interprets what they get out of this book into their way of life. However their interpretation of it is more of a punishing form for the women....   [tags: The Taliban, Islamic Militants]

Better Essays
1414 words (4 pages)

Richard Nixon And Gerald Ford, Former National Security Advisor And Secretary Of State Of Iraq And Syria

- Henry Kissinger, former national security advisor and secretary of state to US Presidents Richard Nixon and Gerald Ford, is arguably the finest political brain of his generation. In 2014 at the ripe old age of 91, Kissinger published his magisterial tome “World Order,” a peerless peek back at history tracing the evolution of the incumbent international system of rules from pre-Westphalian Europe in the Middle Ages to the global response to militant Islamic extremism in the guise of Al-Qaeda and more recently the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS) over half a millennium later....   [tags: Pakistan, Afghanistan, Taliban, Richard Nixon]

Better Essays
1113 words (3.2 pages)

Government Reform And Development Projects Essay

- One year passed from the Afghan presidential elections, but yet the government is lagging. More than half of the government is acting. Peace talk is deadlocked, insecurity has increased and even expended from south and east to the north and west. Unemployment and poverty is at its peak. Government reform and development projects are paused. Institutions have been weekend and more than half of the cabinet seats are vacant. Tension between president and CEO has paralyzed the system and as result country is in the severe crisis....   [tags: Afghanistan, Kabul, Terrorism, Taliban]

Better Essays
1069 words (3.1 pages)

Split Personality Of The Russian National Character Essay

- ... Opposing forces that have compounded to produce what we see today has shaped Russian culture. Even the language is a byproduct of the interaction of a lot of other languages. Was it really a victim to whatever was thrown its ways from the west under the umbrella of westernization that came from Europe. To begin with there was barren land and then came the barbarians, followed by Greeks and Romans and finally the Mongols. Turks were there, controlling a part of it. Be it the Bolsheviks or the Proletariats or the reign of Peter the Great or the defeats at the hands of Napoleon or annihilation of his army or the defeat of German near Stalingrad, some things have stayed the same and in the l...   [tags: culture, government, unity]

Better Essays
927 words (2.6 pages)

Essay about Afghanistan National Reconciliation and Peace Process

- Summary: After decades of war in Afghanistan in late 2001, first attempts have already been made by Afghans and international organizations to consult the Afghan people on how to build capacities in pace-building which was an encouraging sign. However, the people in general are still too reluctant to speak about their suffering during the war. Instead, their current priority is to struggle for economic survival in the highly competitive post-conflict reconstruction business with its emerging social injustice....   [tags: War in Afghanistan, Afghans, Conflict, Economy]

Better Essays
1872 words (5.3 pages)

Essay about Preserving a Country's National Identity

- One of the main issues that has become a major concern in many countries all over the globe is the issue of national identity. This concern has been intensified by the spread of globalization with all its effects. In today’s globalized era, the traits of national identity have been eroded in favor of a more global character. Technological developments in all fields, and especially in mass-communication technology, have transformed the world into a global village. Consequently, preserving a country’s national identity has become a dilemma for many governments....   [tags: government dilemmas, national symbols]

Better Essays
654 words (1.9 pages)