Mandatory HIV Testing is Wrong Essay

Mandatory HIV Testing is Wrong Essay

Length: 1389 words (4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

TABLE OF CONTENTS
S No Topic Page No

1
Introduction
3

2
Mandatory HIV testing among Pregnant women
4

3
Pros of Mandatory HIV testing for pregnant women
5-6

4
Arguments against Mandatory testing for pregnant women
7

5
Arguments against Mandatory Premarital HIV Testing
8-9

6
Proponents of Mandatory Premarital HIV Testing
10

7
Conclusions
10-11

8
Recommendations
12

9.
References
12-13




Introduction
There are different kinds of HIV testing: voluntary testing, where the person tested makes the decision; mandatory testing, where you are tested whether or not you want to be tested; and routine testing, where, if you got some blood drawn for some other reason, an extra tube of blood would be drawn and sent off for an HIV test. Opt out is
when you choice not to opt in for example to be tested at health facilities
by doctors, opt out is when you decide to be tested on your own time.
Is mandatory testing a better strategy for preventing HIV/AIDS is the main question that is discussed in this document.
This paper discusses various arguments by the proponents and opponents of mandatory HIV testing in two scenarios.
1. Mandatory HIV testing for pregnant women &
2. Mandatory premarital HIV testing.
I personally support the mandatory testing for both the above two groups for some specific conditions though I don’t advocate mandatory testing as the best strategy to be implemented as a prevention strategy for HIV globally.

Arguments for and against mandatory testing for pregnant women can be broadly discussed under the following categories:
1. Legal Arguments: Examples of legal concerns surrounding the practice of mandatory testing include constitutional i...


... middle of paper ...


...fatal consequences, will result in the coercion of mothers by health care workers who believe, erroneously, that they know with certainty what is best for her baby8. HIV testing should be voluntary, and only performed after women are honestly informed of the likely consequences of a positive test.





1. Laurent Mandelbrot et al., Lamivudine-Zidovudine Combination for Prevention of Maternal-Infant Transmission of HIV-1, 285 JAMA, 2083, 2083-2093 (2001).

2. Wolf LE et al. When Parents Reject Interventions to Reduce Postnatal Human
Immunodeficiency Virus Transmission.Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 2001;155: 927-33.
3. Udo Schuklenk, PhD, and Anita Kleinsmidt, LLB, LLM, Rethinking Mandatory HIV Testing During Pregnancy in Areas With High HIV Prevalence Rates: Ethical and Policy Issues, American Journal of Public Health , Vol 97, No. 7, 1179-83, July 2007

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Animal Testing: The Future of Pharmaceuticals Essay

- Millions of chemicals have been discontinued in everyday uses, such as in plant poisons, through animal testing, they have been donned to be unsafe for people and environment. Without animal testing, the general public would still be using these hazardous chemicals. Many humanitarians may be opposed to testing chemicals on animals, but if scientists didn’t test on animals, individuals would have to test the deadly chemicals or live in a world where people don’t know if the chemicals they are using are poisonous and lethal to the human society....   [tags: Animal Rights ]

Powerful Essays
1246 words (3.6 pages)

Mandatory Testing For Pregnant Women Essay

- The Pros and Cons of Mandatory HIV Testing in Pregnant Women [The body of your paper uses a half-inch first line indent and is double-spaced. APA style provides for up to five heading levels, shown in the paragraphs that follow. Note that the word Introduction should not be used as an initial heading, as it’s assumed that your paper begins with an introduction.] Prevalence of HIV Transmission during Birth Global HIV incidence may have peaked1 but calls for scaling up prevention have not diminished....   [tags: Childbirth, Pregnancy, HIV, AIDS]

Powerful Essays
726 words (2.1 pages)

Essay Mandatory Drug Testing for Welfare Recipients and Public Assistance

- Have you ever questioned the tax taken out of your hard-earned money. Questions similar to that are where the money is going and if it is being used properly. In the U.S. news recently those questions have been on a great deal of State’s minds; reaching back to 2003, this issue has been brought up time and time again. The main topic of tax money is the use of assistance money and are the recipients really using the money for the right reasons. There are many problems with the assistance program but the one that comes to mind the most is that many people abuse the money given to buy the essentials and provide, for their family for illegal drugs....   [tags: Mandatory Drug Testing ]

Powerful Essays
2059 words (5.9 pages)

Is Animal Testing Wrong or Right? Essay

- Ninety two percent of all animal testing that is effective on animals are ineffective on humans (ASPCA). Despite this alarming statistic, scientists still use animals in these experiments. Scientist give the animals no choice in whether they or going to be used in an experiment. Animal testing is when scientist use products, vaccinations or other things they develop for humans and use on animals. Scientist use all types of animals, but the most common are rats, mice, birds, reptiles and amphibians (ASPCA)....   [tags: scientists experiments, animal testing, cosmetics]

Powerful Essays
968 words (2.8 pages)

Mandatory Prenatal HIV Testing Essay

- Mandatory Prenatal HIV Testing This particular journal researches prenatal HIV testing as it relates to vertical transmission. Randomized controlled studies involving HIV- positive pregnant women at various stages of pregnancy were monitored and evaluated in an effort to find conclusive reasoning for prenatal testing. Women of different income levels, educational and ethnic backgrounds were involved in these studies. The AIDS Clinical Trials Group Study 076 as well as following randomized controlled trials were used in order to test whether prenatal testing was an effective means of preventing the vertical transmission of the HIV virus....   [tags: Papers]

Powerful Essays
892 words (2.5 pages)

Essay on The Pros of Mandatory HIV Testing and Disclosure of HIV Status

- The Pros of Mandatory HIV Testing and Disclosure of HIV Status The universal precautions of the Centers for Disease Control do not eradicate all risk to the patient or health care provider, says Baillie et al. (p. 129). While health care providers in all institutions have been educated in universal precautions, Beck, a registered nurse, cautions that some employees have failed to comply with the recommended procedures from the Centers of Disease Control. Some nurses find goggles, gloves, and other protective gear to be cumbersome to wear and/or too time consuming to put on and remove....   [tags: AIDS Health Medicine Medical Essays]

Powerful Essays
2494 words (7.1 pages)

Is Animal Testing Right Or Wrong? Essay

- Opinions are a dime a dozen and everyone has one when it comes to the century old issue of animal testing. These tests are used throughout the world for various experiments on animals. Is animal testing right or wrong. There are several pros and cons of animal testing and I will review both sides of this issue. The testing of animals can benefit the human society because the researchers come up with cures for humans from the animal tests. The researchers utilize a variety of methods to do these tests....   [tags: Animal rights, Animal testing]

Powerful Essays
1110 words (3.2 pages)

Mandatory Drug Testing for Student Athletes Essay

- High schools in various school districts have conducted research to try and prove that mandatory drug testing can prevent drug use among student athletes. Mandatory drug testing already occurs at the college and professional level in almost all sports. Drug testing is required at the higher levels because steroids and other drugs are often used to gain a competitive advantage (Bouchard and Sprague 1). To ensure that students remain drug free and improve their performance not only in their sport, but also in the classroom, it is necessary for authorities to perform a mandatory drug test throughout each high school (Issit and Newton 1)....   [tags: Essays on Drug Testing]

Powerful Essays
1418 words (4.1 pages)

Mandatory Drug Testing for Student Athletes Essay

- Many times in an athletes life are they asked or peer pressured to do some type of drug that is supposed to help them be a better athlete. Well it’s all-illegal, and to save the stress on the teammates and coach’s, along with all of the fans, why not drug test them. It would make sense to save all of the stress put on everyone. Drugs start as low as middle school athletics, but yet they are not drug tested. They think because they aren’t drug tested that it is okay for them to do these things and still be able to play sports....   [tags: Essays on Drug Testing]

Powerful Essays
1472 words (4.2 pages)

Animal Testing Is Not Wrong Essay

- Medical sciences are required to keep us healthy when there are diseases spreading and animal testing is a key part of this research. Animal test is not wrong because it is the only way to keep ahead in the arms race against disease. Disease keep changing and evolving so scientist must keep researching and making stronger, more potent medicines to combat them. Thus we must use living creatures as test subject for the medicines. Experimenting on animals sounds cruel and it is, but the threat of disease out ways the cruelty that is inflicted on the animals....   [tags: Animal testing, Human, Cell, Stem cell]

Powerful Essays
721 words (2.1 pages)