Mae Ngai 's Reforming Immigration For Good, And Offer My Recommendation For Or Against Publication

Mae Ngai 's Reforming Immigration For Good, And Offer My Recommendation For Or Against Publication

Length: 1347 words (3.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

I am writing in response to your request that I analyze Mae Ngai’s “Reforming Immigration for Good,” and offer my recommendation for or against publication. After reading Ngai’s document, in my opinion, I believe that UTA students will find the article interesting. Ngai’s Piece is very interesting because it addresses a reoccurring problem and can easily be made into a controversial debate. I recommend that UTA students should read the article because it has a different approach than what most people view on Immigration laws; however, I believe that UTA students will disagree with Ngai’s viewpoint of improving the immigration laws which will allow for more immigrants to apply for citizenship. I also recommend that students read it because it is written by a well-educated daughter of immigrants who writes in such a way that allows the reader to understand the viewpoint of a female foreigner.
Ngai’s central claim is that the United States of America’s legalization of the undocumented is humane and practical, but the proposals for controlling future immigration are almost certain to fail. She makes this claim in response to a recent statement by President Obama, who made it clear that the overhaul of America’s immigration laws was his top domestic priority. Ngai supports her central claim by using three proposals that have previously been put in place but did not solve the problem. The two supporting reasons for the central claim are: the promise to “Secure the Border” and what she calls the “one-size-fits-all rule.” These reasons are valid in showing that the proposals have had flaws, but does not show how they have failed. She not only addresses Mexican immigrants, but immigrants from all over the world. So who really cares? At ...


... middle of paper ...


...at the promises made by Congress were and uses facts to prove that they were half measure reforms. In the third paragraph she informs us that because of the promise to secure the border America now has more Mexicans settling permanently than before it was put in place.
Ngai’s arguments are standard issue and have been easily discussed many times already. Shorthorn readers are already aware of what the immigration laws are and what they have done. Even though I believe that Shorthorn readers will not find it as a juicy or an exciting read, I still believe it should be published. Since this article was written by a daughter of an immigrant I feel it’s an interesting refresher from a different viewpoint. Since this the article seemed like an academic inquiry the article could easily be used for references for students who are taking classes and have assignments at UTA.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Letter of Recommendation for Alejandra Galaviz Essay

- It is a great honor to write a letter of recommendation for Alejandra Galaviz. I have known Alejandra for three years in an academic setting. She was one of my finest Spanish students three years ago and she always motivated other students to succeed as well. She has been my most trusted teacher’s assistant for the last two years. She is one of the most mature, helpful, reliable and trustworthy students I have taught in my 12 years of public teaching. As a public high school teacher, I have seen hundreds of students walk in and out of my classroom over the last 12 years, and Alejandra is in the top 1% of students who have had a positive impact on me....   [tags: Recommendation]

Better Essays
848 words (2.4 pages)

Why I Am Against Immigration Essays

- (intro)This country was founded on the principles of immigration unless you are a Native American right?We all have a immigrate background America is a rich country of ethnicity and a true melting pot why. America has often been referred to as the land of opportunity Ronald Reagan truly one of the greatest American presidents often talked about America being ‘’A city on a shining hill’’. Does this mean we are a better country than the rest of the world or this a statement of intent. If you go back and look about what he is saying it means we were simply looking for the purpose making America the place to be opportunity is everywhere....   [tags: Immigration to the United States, United States]

Better Essays
1006 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on The United States and The Fight Against Mexican Immigration

- In the United States it should be a crime not to speak English and Spanish, yet in today’s society Spanish is the second dominant language in the world. There are job posting hiring bilinguals who speak English and Spanish, and are willing to pay top dollar salary for people abilities to do so. The United States should take Spanish in as a second language, by committing these types of actions would then lead the United States raining supreme over other countries in the world, by having two dominant languages....   [tags: Immigration, Laws, Spanish]

Better Essays
721 words (2.1 pages)

Letter of Recommendation Essay

- Dear Sir/Madame I am writing this letter to give my highest possible recommendation for Mr. Smith. I know Mr. Smith through his work in my office. Mr. Smith first approached me two years ago about the possibility of an internship in our company for the summer. At our first meeting I described the general outline of the project the he might work on. He asked good questions and appeared intelligent. He then went to the library and found many papers on the subject and read them carefully. He did this independently - I did not ask him to do this....   [tags: Letters of Recommendation]

Free Essays
356 words (1 pages)

Immigration in the US Essay

- “They are willing to sell themselves in order to find a better life for themselves or to have money to send back home, or to make sure their children are raised in a better county.” (Bell 1). For decades, beautiful Russian and Asian women have been seen in catalogs as mail-order brides. Although the mail order bride industry promises American men a beautiful, obedient, foreign wife, it fails to mention the negative atmosphere included within these situations. Mail order brides should be banned in the United States in order to reduce the increase of domestic violence amongst women (Chittenden 5), the testing of a bride’s selflessness (Bell 1), and internet scams (Internet Relatio...   [tags: Immigration ]

Better Essays
1481 words (4.2 pages)

Recommendation Letter for Former Employee Essay

- November 20, 2004 Mr. Richard Pillsbury Manager, Marketing Services All Industries Inc. 111 Strawberry Bend, Suite 1551 Smallville, OH 05252 Dear Mr. Pillsbury: This is in response to your recent request for a letter of recommendation for Mary Lamb who worked for me up until three years ago. Mary Lamb worked under my direct supervision at Technical Technologies for a period of five and a half years ending in August 2003. During that period, I had the pleasure of seeing her blossom from a junior marketing trainee, into a fully functioning Marketing, Program Co-Ordinator, in her final year and a half with the company....   [tags: Business Recommendation Letters]

Free Essays
389 words (1.1 pages)

Essay on Keyboarding Software Packages: Analysis and Purchase Recommendation

- Keyboarding Software Packages: Analysis and Purchase Recommendation TABLE OF CONTENTS I. INTRODUCTION A. Purpose and Scope B. Procedures II. FINDINGS A. Overview of Software Being Evaluated B. Evaluation of Software 1. Based on Cost 2. Based on Ease of Use 3. Based on Feature Set 4. Based on Help and Support 5. Based on Supported Configurations III. SUMMARY, CONCLUSIONS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS A. Summary of the Problems and Procedures B. Summary of the Findings C. Conclusions and Recommendations INTRODUCTION Every company needs to ensure that it is receiving the utmost in productivity from its employees....   [tags: Software Recommendation]

Better Essays
1161 words (3.3 pages)

Essay on Immigraton in the U.S.

- Immigration in the U.S. While immigration has played an important role in the building and formation of America, new federal laws have resulted in mass immigration. “America was primarily founded on immigrants, however, immigration must be controlled legally, and immigrants should be treated equally despite what country they come from. America has the most liberal laws towards immigrants than any other country.” Luis Barker, Chief Patrol Agent In-Charge, US Border Patrol, El Paso, TX. Throughout history, Congress has enacted laws and has had to amend them to control the flow of both legal and illegal migration to the United States....   [tags: Immigrant Immigration United States America]

Better Essays
1277 words (3.6 pages)

Essay on Immigration Laws

- Prior to 1882, there were not any formal acts that controlled immigration. The Act of 1875 merely prohibited the importation of women for purposes of prostitution and the immigration of aliens "who are undergoing conviction in their own country for felonious crimes, other than political..." The Act of 1882 levied a head tax of fifty cents "for every passenger not a citizen of the United States," and forbade the landing of convicts, lunatics, idiots, or of "any person unable to take care of himself or herself without becoming a public charge." The Act of 1885 blocked the immigration of aliens under contract to labor....   [tags: Immigration ]

Better Essays
1228 words (3.5 pages)

Essay about Immigration Laws

- A topic crucial to the world today is illegal immigration. Illegal immigration is when people live in a country without permission from the government, nor have any legal documentation. As more and more illegal immigrants enter the United States, it either upsets some people, or others feel like they should just grant them ability to pursue life, liberty, and happiness because that is what the Constitution says. Some people feel that illegal immigrants should be protected by the same rights and laws as American citizens....   [tags: Immigration]

Better Essays
1304 words (3.7 pages)