The Implications of Quasi-Democracy in China Essay

The Implications of Quasi-Democracy in China Essay

Length: 862 words (2.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview


Muhlberger notes that the definition of democracy has historically been restricted to nations that are adhere to the Western conception of democracy (25). Yet, Muhlberger claims that even within authoritarian regimes, there are components of democracy at the grassroots level. He defines “quasi-democratic” as “any group willing to submit to decisions arrived at by discussion and voting (formal or informal) or abides judgment of elected representatives” (Muhlberger 27). In this essay, I argue that there have been quasi-democratic elements even within the Chinese Communist tradition. These elements at the local level signal the potential for China to fully transition into a democracy in the future.
Muhlberger notes the historical tradition of quasi-democracy within Chinese political development. Under most emperors, village administration was the responsibility of the villagers themselves (Muhlberger 30). Village temples typically provided services on behalf of community. In areas of weaker clan and temple organization, cooperative organizations fulfilled role of providing services (Muhlberger 31). Thus, the Chinese villages enjoyed a certain level of autonomy. Furthermore, this local organization to provide needed goods and services is characteristic of self-governance. Although encapsulated within an authoritarian regime, these beginnings of village self-government revealed quasi-democracy.
This autonomy has considerably increased with the introduction of competitive village elections through the 1982 China constitution (Horsley 44). Village committee elections give hope to the possibility of liberal democratization of the rest of China. Horsley claims that the introduction of competitive elections has opened the path to the ...


... middle of paper ...


...slow and careful process. Given the historical quasi-democracy within China, the possibility of democracy could perhaps be realized. Furthermore, the importance of village elections and the Tiananmen Square incident demonstrate the increasing importance of the individual in Communist China; by focusing on collective action at the local level, China has the potential to become fully democratic in the future.



Works Cited

Jamie P. Horsley (2001). “Village Elections: Training Grounds for
Democratization.” The China Business Review 28 (2, March-April): 44-52.
Kopstein, Jeffrey, Mark Irving Lichbach, and Yu-Shan Wu. Comparative Politics: Interests, Identities, and Institutions in a Changing Global Order. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2000. Print.

S. Mulhberger and P. Paine (1993). “Democracy’s Place in World History.”
Journal of World History 4 (1): 23-45.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Democracy in Russia and China Essay examples

- As post-communist countries struggle to modernize and adopt a democratic regime, Russia and China each face obstacles unique to their own political and historical context. The main findings of this paper reveal that economic and political liberalism are closely linked and that economic liberalization facilitates democratization. Thus the shortage (rather than surplus) of economic liberalization has contributed to Russia’s deficit of democracy and has been one of the major obstacles of democratization for Russia....   [tags: China]

Better Essays
1570 words (4.5 pages)

Essay on Democracy in China

- Introduction The topic of democracy in China is a highly controversial topic. Although China has not democratised, it has done well in the global situation amongst its democratic competitors. Since the path to democracy is different for each country, we cannot expect that China would follow the same path or same model of democracy as the western nations. This essay will look at what democracy is and how it can be placed in a Chinese context as well as looking at the proponents and opponents of democracy in China....   [tags: The China Model, Political Meritocracy]

Better Essays
3306 words (9.4 pages)

China's Future Democracy Essay

- Thesis: In viewing China’s political background, as well as the current state of affairs, it is reasonable to predict that China will eventually become a democracy. History Looking back in history, one of the most dominant figures in Chinese politics in the 1930’s was Mao Zedong. Mao is very well known as the leader of the CCP as well as a dictator. Mao was inspired by revolutionary potential of peasantry and wanted to create a revolutionary strategy that would rely on their strength. During the First Five-Year Plan, a period between 1953 and 1957, some of the goals of the communist Chinese government were to increase heavy industrial production, collectivize light industry and retail enter...   [tags: China]

Better Essays
1837 words (5.2 pages)

Pro Democracy Protests Of Hong Kong Essay

- Pro-democracy protestors in Hong Kong took to the streets earlier this week in protest of the financial hub’s future as either an enclave of freedom or another communist-controlled city. The protest was sparked by anger over China 's refusal to allow the open selection of candidates for Hong Kong 's leader in the city 's first democratic election scheduled for 2017. Contrary to the pre-specified agreement, a panel of Beijing supporters will pick two or three candidates to run. At stake in this contentious issue is not just the election but also the future of the former British colony as a semiautonomous city and the prospect of the pro-democracy movement spreading to the mainland....   [tags: Hong Kong, Mainland China, Democracy]

Better Essays
719 words (2.1 pages)

Essay about Democracy Is The Best Form Of Government

- Democracy When it comes to the topic of whether democracy is the best form of government, most of us will readily agree that in theory, a well-planned democratically elected institution should represent an accurate sampling of the general population which it has been elected to serve. Where this agreement usually ends however, is on the question of which particular form of democracy is the best overall representation of the concept in question, and as to whether or not this ideal representation outweighs any other type of competing institutional system....   [tags: Democracy, Republic, Representative democracy]

Better Essays
1528 words (4.4 pages)

Essay about Ideologies of the Democracy Movement in China

- Ideologies of the Democracy Movement in China After Deng Xiaoping gained power in 1978, a new political atmosphere was promised for the Chinese people. A promise of a free land with a modern economic state was made by Deng in order to gain public support. During Deng’s reign, a series of economic reforms were made. These reforms had major impacts on both the economy and the society of China. Although it has been argued that Deng was leading a totalitarian regime, historians tend to overlook the idea that the Chinese have different ideologies and morals than people in the west....   [tags: Politics Political]

Better Essays
3349 words (9.6 pages)

The Economic Rise of China Essay

- The economic rise of China during the past few years has had the greatest influence on my thinking, especially in respect to economics, finance, my personal values and social responsibility. I was born in Shanghai in the early 1980s when China’s economic reform just began and the nation opened its doors to the outside world. I can still recall the relatively low living standards during my childhood: televisions and vehicles were rare; people seldom dined out; a majority of commuters were on bicycles – there were no subways or highways, even in the biggest city in China....   [tags: China]

Better Essays
1059 words (3 pages)

Essay on Confucianism and Its Implications in Modern China

- Confucianism and Its Implications in Modern China Confucianism is a time enduring philosophy that has stood up to invading clans, war, resentment, enforcement and infringement of new philosophies, and eventually, revival. For almost 80 years, up until the late 1970’s, Confucianism and its ideas and values have been all but wiped away from China. Though effort was made to remove Confucianism for good from China by the Communist leader Mao Zedong in 1949, the ideas and values were so deeply embedded into peoples mind and the culture that even suppression could not keep it out of the culture and practices....   [tags: Philosophy Ethics Papers]

Better Essays
3387 words (9.7 pages)

Democracy Movements in China Essay

- Democracy Movements in China Democracy Movements in China Democracy Wall In 1978, stimulated by the opening of China to the West and also by the "reversal of verdicts" against the 1976 Tiananmen protesters (These demonstrations against the gang of four had been condemned as counter-revolutionary at the time but were now declared a revolutionary act), thousands of Chinese began to put their thoughts into words, their words onto paper and their paper onto walls to be read by passers by. The most famous focus of these displays became a stretch of blank wall just to the west of the former forbidden city in Beijing, part of which was now a museum and park and part the cluster of residences for...   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
3693 words (10.6 pages)

Essay on Democracy

- Democracy has become the most widespread political form of government during the past decade, after the fall of all its alternatives. During the second part of the 20th century, the 3 main enemies of democracy, namely communism, fascism and Nazism, lost most of their power and influence. However, democracy is still only to be found in less than half of this world's countries. China with a fifth of the total population "had never experienced a democratic government" and Russia still doesn't have a well established democracy....   [tags: Politics Political Democracy]

Better Essays
1025 words (2.9 pages)