In Tylor’s opinion, he sees mythology as a guidebook of examples. He takes into account the beliefs of mythology in a religious standpoint, and dilutes their meaning into being a just a mere speculation that has nothing to do with the real world. In Robert Segal’s book Myth: A Very Short Introduction, he looks into Tylor’s opinion on the relationship of science, religion, and mythology. This notion is backed up by this quote from the book,
“Gods thereby cease to be agents in the physical world – Tylor assumes that physical effects must have physical causes- and religion ceases to be an explanation of the physical world. Gods are relocated from the physical word to the social world. They become models for humans, just one should be for Plato. One now turns to...
... middle of paper ...
...nd the new world are really one (108).” Campbell sees a compromise between the concept of mythology being real, not still needing to have a concrete form present.
The three discussers would proceed to have a discourse on their takes on mythology. Tylor would see a way of trying to debunk Campbell’s ideas through the point that there is no evidence. He would argue that it was not possible, and that it was a lazy attempt to give mythology more of meaning that it deserves. Then, Bultmann would suggest that perhaps Campbell’s journey can be deduce to the metaphor of the journey that man makes through life. The disagreements would escalate without any of the parties budging from their standpoint. It would continue like this until the end of the discussion, where everyone will agree that myth has too many interpretations to determine which is considered real or not.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Greek Mythology played a monumental role in the structural development of ancient Greece, not only as a society, but as individuals. Surprisingly, their religion was not exactly one of originality. In fact, their religion was loosely based on earlier cultures’ religions. It bears many strikingly similar resemblances to some of the oldest recorded religions in history. Ancient Greek religion is a type of polytheism called “Monarchial Polytheism.” That is, they believe in several different gods and deities but there is a supreme ruler above all of them.... [tags: Mythology ]
1268 words (3.6 pages)
- Stories often take inspiration from multiple styles of writings, including classical texts from modern literature. This is especially important when creating a fictional culture or race to create a sense of believability and help the readers visualize how the setting and characters will appear in their minds. Stories may sometimes place an influence on how other character are represented in the author's writing. One excellent example that takes use of ancient stories to create differentiating cultures is The Lord of the Rings by J.R.R.... [tags: Mythology ]
1737 words (5 pages)
- In Greek Mythology, perhaps one of the most rudimental yet one of the most important elements are the Greek Gods and Goddesses. The ancient Greeks created the stories about the lives and journeys of the Greek Gods, known as myths, simply as an endeavor to elucidate nature and all phenomena which were difficult to explain using modern science and logic. These myths about the Gods were spread around the world by explorers and storytellers, and later merged with Greek religion. To this day, numerous myths survived through many writings and through much art.... [tags: Greek Mythology]
1334 words (3.8 pages)
- Theories of Mythology The definition of mythology is derived from the word “myth”. The word itself is developed from the Greek word “mythos”, which means sagas, legend, or fable. The word “myth” is a chronicle that seeks to prove the world around us and is passed down from generation to generation (Lincoln, 1999). It is the nature of humans to marvel about the unknown and explain the unaccountable. It is also the desire for knowing that has inspired humans to fabricate amazing stories of his descent.... [tags: Mythology]
743 words (2.1 pages)
- The Influence of Mythology Ancient myths are the foundation on which societies around the world are based. Ancient myths have an enormous effect on human behavior because they are true stories that provided examples to the believer within a given society. Each society has their own myth, or myths that serve as guides to help the community establish a purpose, a meaning, and a sense of direction. Two ancient societies are famous for their mythology. These societies are Greece and Rome. Ancient Greece and Roman societies fell over 1,000 years ago, but despite this; their mythology still continues to influence our culture today.... [tags: Greek mythology, Zeus, Roman mythology, Homer]
1177 words (3.4 pages)
- Exile in Mythology “If all difficulties were known at the outset of a long journey, most of us would never start out at all” (Journey Quotations). Exile presents itself in many forms throughout Greek and Roman mythology. Regardless of their purpose, however, all Greek and Roman mythological characters realize the above quote by American journalist Dan Rather to be frighteningly accurate. As they step off to begin their ordeal of exile, for some reason, they fail to stay focused on their present, thinking only of their cloudy, uncertain future.... [tags: Mythology]
1440 words (4.1 pages)
- Zeus hurls his thunderbolt and the world trembles. Odin invites fallen warriors in the halls of Valhalla for a drink. Jesus Christ spreads the words of his father and gathers disciples. Buddha sits and meditates the meaning of the universe. Across the world there have always been mythological stories. From the first civilization to modern times, mythologies help explain the vents of the world and attempt to provide answers for unanswerable questions. Though every mythology appears different, if one looks close enough, commonalities appear.... [tags: Mythology ]
2493 words (7.1 pages)
- Greek and Roman mythology is well know. The people of that time period were passionate about the gods and did everything in their power to please them. Like most religions the goal is be like one of the gods in order to achieve good fortune or to gain everlasting life. One of the most interesting characteristics about the Greek and Roman Gods is how the gods are not perfect in that they make the same mistakes that the average human would make. These characteristics were put into place to allow ancient Greeks and Romans to effectively relate to the gods making them more believable.... [tags: Mythology]
1509 words (4.3 pages)
- ... Like his father before him, Kronos feared his children and began to eliminate them. His wife, Rhea an earth goddess, hid her son Zeus until he was fit for war and he eventually over ruled his father and the golden age men were killed off. Zeus become the God of the sky. He created Olympus and ruled all humans and gods from there. Zeus created a second race of men called the Silver Age. Due to them angering Zeus, he banished them to the underworld and replaced them with the men of Bronze Age.... [tags: Greek mythology, Zeus, Gaia, Cronus]
734 words (2.1 pages)
- Hindu Mythology Cosmic myths are concerned with the world and how it is ordered. They seek to explain the origin of the world, universal catastrophes and natural disasters such as fire or floods, as well as the afterlife. Nearly all mythologies have stories about creation. This type of story is technically known as cosmogony, meaning “birth of the world.” (T Lansford, 2006) These Creation stories also include myths of how human beings first came into existence and how death and suffering entered human experience.... [tags: Mythology India Hindu]
2027 words (5.8 pages)