Deontologists judge the morality of their actions in accordance to how those actions adhere to the rules (Hursthouse, 2010), without regard to consequences or other external factors (Fox and Demarco, 2001). In this case, the rule was that the students must submit the assignment on that particular day, and no later. As such, the teacher has no choice but to record Sean's work as un-submitted. There is an inherent duty to comply with the rules (Waller, 2005) from the deontological viewpoint, which overrides any mitigating circumstances; as justification for their actions are based on what is permissible and what is wrong (Blackburn, 2003).
This is not to say the teacher would not have granted Sean with an extension had Sean had a plausible reason as to why he was unable to submit his work, as the rules do allow for extensions under certain circumstances. Sean however did not offer such reasons, thus the ability for the teacher to give him an extension is not available. Although such action may compromise the overall grade Sean achieves, this would not phase the actions of a deontologist. This is not to say however that the decision to take such action would come easily, as personal feelings are morally neutral (Billington, 1993) and may contrast with the course of action taken.
If the teacher had decided to grant Sean with an extension it coul...
... middle of paper ...
...real world. Oxford: Oxford university press.
Hursthouse, R. Virtue ethics. The Stanford encyclopaedia of philosophy (winter 2010). Zalta, E (ed). Accessed 3rd Jan 2012. Available at:
Israel, M and Hay, I. (2006) Ethical approaches pp.12-22 from Research Ethics for social scientists. London: Sage publication isbn 9781412903905
Mulgan, T. (2005) The demands of consequentialim. Oxford: University press.
Prichard, H. (1912) Does moral philosophy rest on a mistake? Mind vol 21 pp 21-37
Sinnott-Armstrong, W. (2011) Consequentialism. The Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Zalta, E (ed.) Accessed 7 Jan 2012. Available at
Waller, B. (2005) Consider ethics: Theory, reading and contempory issues. New York: Pearson longman.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Ethical judgment is not a definite restriction for the method and production of knowledge in art field, but it does relatively limit the production of knowledge in the natural science fields. Since the ethical judgment is an authority in a majority of people’s notion and mind, people tend to follow ethical standards and harder to develop the further knowledge. In addition, reason is one of the ways of knowing and moral principle is a crucial factor that shapes the pursuit of knowledge. The extreme cases in the natural science and in distinctive areas of knowledge violate the reason that undermines the moral obligation.... [tags: Essays on Ethical Judgement]
994 words (2.8 pages)
- Introduction When we talk of ethics, we mean moral issues that govern a person or group of people. For example, Accountants have the code of conducts which specify what is right and what is wrong. There are several ethical issues in the workplace, such as bribery, sexual harassment, plagiarizing, theft… We are going to base this project on Sexual Harassment, theft, plagiarizing, and bribery. PLAGIARIZING. Plagiarizing is taking credit for work done or performed by someone (employee or colleague) and presenting it as your own.... [tags: bribery, harassment, plagiarism, theft]
2090 words (6 pages)
- ... Coming here and adjusting into the system, was very different for me, and a task on its own. Being an international student, there are pre-determined differences that are instilled into society. Most people from local areas assume that you speak ‘Indian’ because I’m from India, or use Fahrenheit to describe the temperature outside, instead of Celsius. Adjusting to the culture of the United States is a big adjustment, but as I saw this semester blow by, I realized that people often forget to realize that they have learned so much.... [tags: judgement, morals, values, decisions]
623 words (1.8 pages)
- The Impact of Personal Values, Organizational Values, and Cultural Values on the Workforce When we are called upon to make decisions, several factors are taken into consideration before this decision can be made. Depending on the type of decision, such factors could be cultural beliefs, personal beliefs, and organizational beliefs. We have come to realize that there are fundamental challenges in trying to apply ethical principles in a cultural and organizational environment. Each culture has unique distinctions in values, which may or may not be considered ethical by each individual within society.... [tags: Business Organizational Behavior (OB)]
976 words (2.8 pages)
- Secularised ethics can be defined as “The basic principles of right action, especially with reference to a particular person, profession etc.” Christian ethics however cannot be as simply defined. Ethical values of Christians cannot be reduced to a set of rules that can be easily followed and obeyed. A definition that gives an idea of Christian Ethics can be given in this form, “Christian Ethics is fundamentally a matter of participating in the unfolding drama of God’s creative and redemptive purposes for the world.... [tags: Ethics, Christian Ethics, Morality]
1990 words (5.7 pages)
- Jon Krakauer’s personal account of the 1996 Mount Everest tragedy in which eight climbers perished, Into Thin Air, addresses the tenacious nature of climbers and their unrelenting desire to reach their goal – the summit. This strong ambition ultimately tests the climbers’ concerns with other elements of life such as family, environmental responsibility and moral judgement, all of which are endangered by their individual desire to reach the summit. Whilst the climbers are undeniably selfishly driven to the summit, Krakauer’s retrospective account of the expedition suggests that the climbers were concerned and aware of the damaging consequences of their pursuits but acting on this concern was... [tags: Mountaineering]
1138 words (3.3 pages)
- Introduction The statement ‘Teaching – reflections, questions, decisions’ sums up what it means to be an effective teacher. Teachers are constantly making decisions about professionalism and ethics, teaching strategies, classroom management, and how to keep their students motivated. These decisions can have a major impact on student learning and how effective they are as teachers. Questioning is an essential—and one of the most important—instructional skills that a teacher can possess. Teachers need to be able to ask the appropriate types and levels of questions, such as the high and low order questions based on Bloom’s taxonomy, as well as being skilled in responding to students answers.... [tags: Professionalism and Ethics in Teaching]
2558 words (7.3 pages)
- Ethics is something that is very important to have especially in the business world. Ethics is the unwritten laws or rules defined by human nature; ethics is something people encounter as a child learning the differences between right and wrong. In 2001, Enron was the fifth largest company on the Fortune 500. Enron was also the market leader in energy production, distribution, and trading. However, Enron's unethical accounting practices have left the company in joint chapter 11 bankruptcy. This bankruptcy has caused many problems among many individuals.... [tags: Business Ethics]
1868 words (5.3 pages)
- The Impact of Ethics on Decision Making Ferrel and Gardiner (1991) say there are two criteria to ethical choices on top of being legal. The first being; “One does not infringe on the basic inalienable human rights – such as life, freedom of speech and privacy, due process – recognized by our society (ethical formalism).” Basically stating the respect of others should be considered in all decisions. The second states each person should strive towards an increase in self-esteem and mental health.... [tags: Ethics Morals Decisions Essays]
1017 words (2.9 pages)
- Ethics Development Ethics guide the decision-making and actions of an individual. More extensively, collective employee ethics shape the direction of a company. This document will explore sources of ethical influence, both for individuals, and organizations. It will further explain the need for ethics at an organizational level, how those fit in with directions and goals of an organization, and finally conclude with the effect both individual and organizational ethics have on society. Personal Ethics People find themselves facing questions with negative and positive consequence each day.... [tags: Ethics]
1419 words (4.1 pages)