Henry V and Picard

Henry V and Picard

Length: 1013 words (2.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Henry V and Picard

"The Defector" is the 38th episode from Star Trek the Next Generation's third season. This episode is received well by many ST TNG fans. The episode deals with several interesting and conflicting issues such as a traitor / defector, innate human qualities and a Shakespearean type leader. The most intriguing personality on the episode is Jean Luc Picard, the great captain. Picard has many similarities to Henry V, they both probe into every conflict and always prove to be a strong and capable leaders. They are both of strong character, conscientious, objective and intuitive.

The story requires the captain utilize his outstanding qualities to decide if the exiled Romulan on his ship is trustworthy. If Picard believes Jaroc, it would mean going into the neutral zone and destroying a base in order to prevent a war. However, if Jaroc is lying this course of action will make Picard the instigator of a futile war. In the same way, if Henry's cause is unjust, the guilt and blame will lay on his head(Fisher 51). One of Picard's greatest qualities is his objectiveness.

When Jaroc refuses to disclose any information, Picard diligently explores all his options. He decides to send a probe in order to reach the truth. Later, Jaroc attempts to prove his sincerity by revealing his identity. He discloses the emotional reasons for his presence aboard the Enterprise. Picard is not affected by Jaroc.

By reason of his intuition, Picard continues to demand "irrefutable evidence" because he will not risk the welfare of the crew. Not only is he concerned about the welfare of the crew as a whole, but also on an individual level. In the opening to the episode, Picard attempts to aid Data in furthering his understanding of human behavior. Upon Data's request for advice, he suggests Shakespeare. Data plays the role of King when he performs the first scene of Act IV from Henry V(Peterson). In this scene, Henry disguises himself and mingles with his troops to share their ultimate fears on the eve before battle. "They have a discussion of leading one's men to die"(Lynch). Ironically, Picard directs the scene which parallels his position through the story.

The fact that Henry V is one of Shakespeare's histories is very significant because history is the backbone of the episode. References to their history with Romulans are made. Such as to events on Galornden Core, in which Beverly the doctor explains that she recently gained a lot of experience with Romulan physiology.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Henry V and Picard." 123HelpMe.com. 20 Jul 2018

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Jean Luc Picard as a Leader Essays

- Jean Luc Picard as a Leader If the cause is just and honorable they are prepared to give their lives--Jean Luc Picard The cares for lives, continuation of other's future, and the hope of a more successful generation are rarely the thoughts of anyone. Most individuals are self-centered, careless of others, and seek personal benefit. Although these unfortunate qualities make up the majority of the society that we live in, there are few individuals that make up what we call good leaders. Someone who has a thorough, objective, and complete view of a situation are a good leader....   [tags: Star Trek Essays Papers]

Research Papers
1981 words (5.7 pages)

Captain Picard as A Noble Warrior Essay examples

- Captain Picard as A Noble Warrior Captain Picard is a good leader because of his ability to think clearly and objectively in all situations. He does not have pride blocking his ability to think rationally and see all sides of an issue. Also, he is not easily swayed by his emotions and does not allow them to cloud his judgment. Picard's ability to act quickly leads to effective delegating and exemplary leadership. A good leader is one who brings out the best in his people while being a servant to them....   [tags: Star Trek Essays Papers]

Free Essays
917 words (2.6 pages)

Jean-Luc Picard as a Leader Essay examples

- Jean-Luc Picard as a Leader Jean-Luc Picard, Captain of the Starship Enterprise, is a good leader because of his ability to guide and direct his crew in such a way that protects the Federation from its enemies and inspires others to have similar goals. Every leader has their own unique characteristics and Picard is no different. He is able to utilize his crew members' talent's, ship's technology, and his own experiences to be the best leader he can be. Webster's New World Dictionary defines a leader as one who guides or directs in a course that inspires the conduct of others....   [tags: Star Trek Essays Papers]

Free Essays
1223 words (3.5 pages)

Essay on Political Drama in Henry IV and Henry V

- Political Drama in Henry IV and Henry V        The contention that Shakespeare’s histories are in fact political drama appears to fall uneasily on the ears of modern readers.  One reason for this could be the fact that we, as a society, have blurred the connotation of politics to the vaguest of notions – narrow at times, yet far too inclusive.  A young reader is likely to view politics as election and debate, a sort of ongoing candidacy.  Indeed, this may be a valid modern definition, if somewhat limited.  For our purposes, however, this definition is not sufficient to establish a starting point from which to examine Shakespeare’s presentation of political drama....   [tags: Henry IV Henry V Essays]

Research Papers
1493 words (4.3 pages)

Free Henry IV Essays: Falstaff and King Henry

- Henry IV - Falstaff and King Henry Throughout the play Henry IV : Part I,there are many similarities between characters. Two that seem particularly alike are Falstaff and King Henry. Their common traits are demonstrated by Shakespeare in many subtle and not-so-subtle ways. While Falstaff seems to be able to accept himself for what he is, the King appears to be tied up in his image as a great ruler, and thus will never admit to being anything less than great. The characters of Falstaff and the King at first seem to be diametrically opposed opposites in terms of personality, yet they share many common traits....   [tags: Henry IV Henry V Essays]

Free Essays
461 words (1.3 pages)

Essay about The Evolution of Shakespeare's Henry V

- The Evolution of Shakespeare's Henry V Foremost among the characters William Shakespeare develops in his series of historical plays is, undoubtedly, the character of Henry V. Henry, also at times referred to as Harry or Hal, develops through the course of four plays: Richard II, I Henry IV, II Henry IV, and Henry V. From the brief mention of Henry in Richard II to the full focus upon him in Henry V, a dramatic change clearly takes place: the playful carousing youth portrayed in the first play develops into a King and conqueror by the conclusion of the final play....   [tags: Henry IV Henry V Essays]

Research Papers
1617 words (4.6 pages)

Henry Ford Essay

- When Henry Ford was born on June 30th, 1863, neither him nor anyone for that matter, knew what an important role he would take in the future of mankind. Ford saw his first car when he was 12. He and his father where riding into Detroit at the time. At that moment, he knew what he wanted to do with his life: he wanted to make a difference in the automobile industry. Through out his life, he achieved this in an extraordinary way. That is why he will always be remembered in everyone’s heart. Whenever you drive down the road in your car, you can thank all of it to Henry Ford....   [tags: Henry Ford Essays]

Free Essays
1891 words (5.4 pages)

Henry IV Essay

- Free Essay on Henry IV Sleep is the most important part of a normal life, a refuge from the withering blast of daily activities. King Henry seeks shelter in blissful oblivion from the overwhelming responsibilities of his status, but fails to achieve escape because of his flurrying thoughts. His carefully considered word choice, specifically chosen imagery and well-constructed syntax show that he is not lacking rest because of natural causes, but instead denies himself by worrying about his problems....   [tags: Henry IV Henry V Essays]

Research Papers
672 words (1.9 pages)

Henry James Essay

- Henry James In August of 1904, after more than two decades abroad, the sixty-year-old Henry James returned to the United States for a year. While William James had famously remarked that his brother was "a native of the James family" (W James 517), with little else in the way of national affiliation, Henry considered himself as American as ever after his twenty years in Europe. The book he wrote about his American journey was titled The American Scene only because James's first choice had been taken; he would have preferred to call it The Return of the Native.[1] But James's sense of himself as a native, as one at home in the United States, was shaken by his alienating experie...   [tags: American Scence Henry James Essays]

Free Essays
3090 words (8.8 pages)

Essay about Henry Ford

- Henry Ford "It is doubtful if any mechanical invention in the history of the world has influenced in the same length of time the lives of so many people in an important way as the motor car." So writes an American historian, thinking of the automobile alone. But it does not stand-alone. It was the automobile factory that introduced mass production, a process that has changed the lineaments of our economic and social life more profoundly than any other single element in the recent history of civilization....   [tags: History Biography Henry Ford Essays]

Research Papers
2306 words (6.6 pages)

Later we discover that Commander Tomolok from Galornden Core is the mastermind behind the double plan. More importantly, Starfleet knows who Admiral Jaroc is. To them he is a murderer, responsible for numerous Romulan massacres. Therefore he should not be trusted.

Pilchard's search for reliable information is accomplished about midway through the story. In support of his strong character, Picard possesses great eloquence. He blatantly calls Jaroc a "traitor" and informs him that this is just a "tap on the shoulder". Picard eventually tells him, "You've crossed over, whether you like it or not. If the bitter taste of that galls you, I am truly sorry. But I will not risk starting a war because you think you can dance on the border of the Neutral Zone!" Not until he gave Picard the exact coordinates of where the base should be did they cross into the Neutral Zone. They did this for the sole purpose of attempting to save themselves. Similarly in Henry V it is ultimately the threat to the peace of England that allows Henry to put aside personal feelings and execute three conspirators for the sake of "the health of England" (Fisher 70). An excellent portrayal of Picard's concern occurs when Picard quotes from a soldier's speech in the scene that Data performed, "Now if these men do not die well, it will be a black matter for the King that led them to it."

There is another instance where Picard's exact feelings parallel with Henry's. Immediately after Data's performance, Data wonders why a King would want to pass as a commoner. "Shouldn't a leader be leading?", he asks. Picard tells him to "listen to what Shakespeare is telling you about the man. A king with true feelings for his soldiers would wish to share their fears with them on the eve of battle."

Similarly, Picard is concerned about his crew's spirits. But he realizes that unlike Henry V it is not easy to disguise himself among the crew. Analogous with Henry's ability to communicate with the common class of soldiers, the captain is not afraid to ask for assistance from a crew member(Fisher 69). He asks Data for his objectivity. Amid all this turmoil he can still clearly think of all details and realizes that this may be a cornerstone in history. Picard wants to fulfill his obligation to future generations by providing a dispassionate view of the event.

Some may argue that Picard is not a good leader because he risked the life of his soldiers. But because he can see all possibilities, he does not go into the Neutral Zone without an alternative plan. Picard arranges to have the Klingons come as back-up.

In conclusion, "The Defector" depicts Picard as an ideal captain in a like manner to Henry V and its depiction of Henry as the idealized Christian King(Fisher 69). Picard possesses many qualities which support the notion that he is an allusion to Henry V and additionally, these shared qualities constitute good leaders. Various scenes in both "The Defector" and Henry V depict Picard's and Henry's mercy, pity, and compassion, their absolute sense of justice, their administrative skill, their innate nobility and their ability to communicate with the common class of soldiers and crew. All of these characteristics constitute objectiveness, conscientiousness and intuition which in turn create good leaders.

Works Cited

Fisher, Jeffrey. "Shakespeare's Henry V" Cliff Notes.. Lincoln, Nebraska: C.K. Hillegass, 1994.

Lynch, Timothy. "The Defector.rev" Star Trek. gopher://chop.isca.uiowa.edu:8338/00/startrek/season3/defector.rev(1/15/95)

Peterson, Marguerite. "TNG 3rd season" Shakespeare and Star Trek. ftp://ftp.cosy.sbg.ac.at/pub/trek/lists/shakespe.txt (10/31/92)

Kernick, Phil. "The Defector" Trekker. http://ringo.psy.flinders.edu.au:80/trekker/tng/3/thedefector.html
Return to 123HelpMe.com