The Freeloaders, by Megan McArdle: Article Analysis on Illegal Music Download

The Freeloaders, by Megan McArdle: Article Analysis on Illegal Music Download

Length: 1045 words (3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

What do you think about free music downloading? Do you think it should be allowed or not? The article entitled “The Freeloaders,” written by Megan McArdle, is based on the issue that many people are sharing and downloading music files for free, and that many people accept this behavior. It is also based on how the music file-sharing is affecting the success of music industry negatively. While McArdle is persuasive when she claims that music file-sharing is not benefiting the music industry and the entertainment industry financially, I also see that there is a lack of solid evidence to back up her argument, which complicates this issue. Her arguments seem very opinion-based.
McArdle argues that although music file-sharing is easily assessable and available in the millennium generation, free music file-sharing is causing damage to individuals involved in the music industry and in the entertainment industry. McArdle starts off the article by mentioning that record labels suffer the most financially in the year 2009. She also mentions that for the last decade, record labels business are experiencing decreases in revenues. McArdle criticizes the millennium generation for violating property rights of recording labels and the music industry. Moreover, McArdle points out that many young people in this millennium generation are the ones who are downloading music for free. She discusses how hard it was for people to look for music and to copy music in the past history compared to the present. She also points out that young people in the millennium generation do not see downloading music for free as a huge problem. She concludes her article by stating that perhaps music piracy is not such a negative trend. Although it affects individua...


... middle of paper ...


... issue of file-sharing, and the decline in music sales due to people downloading free music. Besides using vague information and few statistics, she is also making many assumptions about the facts that she is stating in this article. When she is making too many assumptions, I am not entirely persuaded to steer clear from downloading music for free. Therefore, this is why I do not think this article is effective.
In conclusion, McArdle does a fairly good job laying out the main points to support her stance against music file-sharing. However, she could use more specific details and evidence to help strengthen her arguments. Her arguments are weakened as she provides many generalities, and no data or strong evidentiary support.



Works Cited

McArdle, M. (2010). The Freeloaders How a generation of file-sharers is ruining the future of entertainment. The Atlantic.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

College Can Pay Off, By Megan Mcardle Essay

- In the commentary College can pay off, but to varying degrees author Megan McArdle talks about her thoughts on the biggest investment one can make, themselves. The article spends most of the time talking about the United States as a society and how college benefits everyone differently. Megan discusses the fact to some students college may never pay off, while for others it is a very necessary part of life. The article includes a few interesting facts that really makes it seem apparent, everyone should go to college....   [tags: Academic degree, University, College tuition]

Strong Essays
1166 words (3.3 pages)

Essay on Should Download of Music Be Illegal?

- Many people love music. There are no situations where people do not feel music. Some shops, for example, play music to make customers feel comfortable. In the past, people bought or rent CDs from the shops whereas now, it is a mainstream ways that people download music from internet sites like iTunes. Even though prevalent internet allows people to obtain many kinds of mu-sic in the world, the illegal downloading or sharing music from the internet site become the problem. Recently, the number of the people who download or share copyrighted material like music has been increasing, so some people argue that the downloading or sharing copyrighted material from internet should be il...   [tags: Profit, Industry, Artists]

Free Essays
575 words (1.6 pages)

To Download Or Not To Download Essay

- The Internet is an extremely useful resource to obtain information on just about any topic. A relatively new feature of the World Wide Web is the technology for the sharing of music in MP3 format. A popular site to download “free” music is called Napster. This program allows people to share music files, discover new artists, and become part of the music community. Although Napster is controversial, the program should still remain accessible to Internet users and music lovers. Marc Geiger, a supporter of the program, states that “Napster is ‘totally community oriented,” (“Napster…”)....   [tags: essays research papers fc]

Strong Essays
2455 words (7 pages)

To Download Or Not To Download Essay

- The Internet is an extremely useful resource. Using it, one can obtain information on nearly any topic. A relatively new item of Internet technology for sharing music has emerged and brought with it, countless legal debates: Napster. Napster allows people to share music files, discover new artists, and become part of the online-music community. Although Napster’s opponents argue that sharing music files is immoral and should cease immediately, the positive elements that Napster brings to the Internet overshadow any regret for its use....   [tags: essays research papers fc]

Free Essays
1989 words (5.7 pages)

The Criminal Act Of Download Music / Media From The Internet Essay

- Laws are established to protect people. Often times, an evolution concerning the interpretation of law can occur. The advancement of technology is something that has spurred, not only the evolution of interpretation, concerning law, but has also changed the law. Such is the case when discussing the downloading of music and other media, without paying for it. This essay will explore the question of it should be a criminal act to download music / media from the Internet. It will also compare if downloading music is equal to the theft of Compact Disc from the local Wally-World....   [tags: Law, Crime, Criminal law, Theft]

Strong Essays
939 words (2.7 pages)

Essay about Music Industry

- The current state of the music business is disappointing, yet progressive. It’s extremely interesting the way it has morphed and continues to do so. The switch to digital music has brought about a new era which affects all aspects of the business. There are varying opinions on whether the business has improved or declined, but the one thing that holds true is the fact that it is changing and the future of music will form before our eyes. It’s quite clear that there are advantages and disadvantages regarding the current industry, but is it the same as it used to be....   [tags: digital music, music, free download, CD]

Strong Essays
1361 words (3.9 pages)

Essay on Music Piracy

- As a result of music piracy, the United States economy loses about $12.5 billion per year (RIAA). Not only do wealthy record labels and headline artists lose money, but songwriters, music publishers, music engineers, and even record store clerks suffer losses. Music pirates are people who share and download music over the Internet without paying for it. Piracy has been an ongoing issue for record companies and the artists they represent. It started all the way back in the days of cassette recorders and blank tapes....   [tags: Music]

Strong Essays
1597 words (4.6 pages)

Ethical Dilemma Of Napster Essay

- Ethical Dilemma of Napster The ethical dilemma of computer downloads, namely music downloads, has been under great scrutiny in the last few years. Napster, if any one symbolizes the new technology, was the front runner in developing the new digital trading. The ethical issues seem to revolve around the all mighty dollar. Some particular musicians, namely Lars Ulrich from Metallica and Dr. Dre (rap star), have had some serious issues with Napster. Their claims have merit, but so do the claims of the creator and users of Napster....   [tags: Download Music Sharing Internet]

Free Essays
1445 words (4.1 pages)

Essay about Music Downloads

- Technology Essay: the iRiver H140 Today, digital music has taken over the music industry replacing formats such as compact discs, cassette tapes, and records. One of the most popular ways to collect and play digital music is the mp3 player. Music in the format of mp3s has become much more popular than other methods of playing music including CDs, creating a great demand for mp3 players; therefore there has become a variety of mp3 players available to purchase. The iRiver is one model of mp3 player that is very beneficial to those who own it, especially students of UCSB....   [tags: essays research papers fc]

Strong Essays
1396 words (4 pages)

\Napster Case Essay

- . Introduction: Amidst the hot debate about whether or not music should be free, there are ethical and moral considerations as well. MP3 music downloading has become the latest fad for computer owners. One computer site where users can download MP3 songs is Napster. The emergence of digital entertainment, whether an MP3, Liquid Audio book, or streaming video, has caused an inevitable shift in the entertainment market from a commodity base to a service base. One reason is that the digital medium eliminates acquisition cost for the consumer....   [tags: Napster Music Download ]

Free Essays
1629 words (4.7 pages)