Two arguments of the event are described. There are those who support what the Border Patrol did because they believe any illegal immigrant should not be tolerated in this country no matter what the situation is because it would be against the law. She has no right to be in the country some would argue due to undocumented records and arriving to this country illegally. According to the Urban Institute, children immigrants with the needs of public services are more complicated by the lack of legal status among their parents (Capps and Fortuny 2006). Some may say this is why illegal minors, such as Rosa Maria, are not supposed to be crossing to the U.S. Others would say it is not fair for a child to be detained due to something that is out
The United States needs more border control. The Government has put up to long with the struggle to keep unwanted substances and threats out of this country. Border control needs to be increased because of the threat of terrorism, Unneeded drugs, and the safety of U.S. citizens.
In “The Border Patrol State” Leslie Silko makes accusations of the border patrol’s mistreatment of American citizens of Mexican decent, making the argument with almost evidence. Silko, a critically acclaimed poet, sees the border patrol as a governmental assembly addicted to interrogation, torture, and the murder of those they see fit.
In his address to a joint session of Congress on January 8, 1918, President Woodrow Wilson declared freedom of the seas in times of peace and war. Looking back, it seems ridiculous to think that anyone could challenge the right of individuals to navigate the oceans freely. However, fast-forward to the twenty-first century and we can see an analogous debate over the issue of immigration rights, with territorial borders being the main topic of discussion. The system of immigration in the United States is complex and oftentimes restrictive, and while revisions to the system usually include increasing quotas or other solutions to let in certain groups of people who deserve special consideration (such as those whose skills are needed in a particular field), they are still very limited solutions. The obvious question that arises from letting in some people but not others is that of fairness. Is the accident of birth or luck of being in the right place at the right time enough to justify restrictive citizenship to a select few? I would argue not. I intend to argue that a commitment to human rights entails the position that borders ought to be open in order to guarantee other human rights, especially the right to migrate.
ICE (Immigration and Customs Enforcement) deportations has raised frequently; Immigration arrests rose 32.6 percent in the first weeks of the Trump administration, with newly empowered federal agents intensifying their pursuit not just undocumented immigrants with criminal records, but also thousands of illegal immigrants who have been otherwise law-abiding (Sachetti). The numbers have tripled from last year, more families have been taken apart and not anyone has known what to do about the situation. In the 100 days since President Donald J. Trump signed Executive orders (EOs) regarding Immigration Customs Enforcement (ICE) has arrested more than 41.000 who are either known or suspected of being in the country illegally. This reflects of
In regards to Celia Sanchez, she is the backbone of the family undoubtedly keeping the family together. Being an immigrant to the United States it is noticeable that her English barrier is hindering her progress as an American Resident to move forward and understand the language and paperwork. The lack of the understanding of the language opens doors for her to be exploited since she is part of a vulnerable population.
The liberties and rights of YOUNG immigrants, both illegal and legal, are being set aside by the Obama Administration, favouring adult immigrants who could be more valuable to the American economy and thus achieving a higher priority than the young, “They've had to open temporary shelters because the existing ones are filled to capacity. Journalists are not allowed inside, but leaked photographs of a Border Patrol holding facility in Nogales, Arizona, show cramped cells without enough food, beds, toilets or showers. They seem more befitting of refugee camps Americans hear of in war-ravaged regions of the developing world than right here at home. From those less-than-ideal conditions have risen allegations of sexual abuse, threats of violence, strip searches and filthy conditions. A complaint filed Wednesday (June 18, 2014) by the American Civil Liberties Union and four immigrant rights groups lists accusations made by 116 children. Half described a lack of medical care. Others describe ice-cold holding cells in which bright fluorescent lights were kept switched on day and night. About 70 percent of these children said they were held by the Border Patrol longer than the statutory limit of 72 hours. President Barack Obama has announced an interagency Unified Coordination Group to respond to humanitarian
Mounted Watchmen of the U.S immigration service patrolled the border in an effort to prevent illegal immigration since 1904, but their efforts were irregular and undertaken. The inspectors, operated out of El Paso, Texas. Though they were no more than 75, they patrolled as far as west as California trying to restrict the flow of illegal Chinese immigration. In the Early years, officers were quickly recruited for the new positions. The border patrol expanded to 450 officers. Liquor smuggling was a major concern because it often accompanied alien smuggling. President Franklin D. Roosevelt combined the Bureau of immigration and Bureau of Naturalization Service in 1933. Border Security TodayHomeland security became a primary concern of the nation
"As Growth Stalls, Unauthorized Immigrant Population Becomes More Settled." Pew Research Centers Hispanic Trends Project RSS. N.p., n.d. Web. 05 Oct. 2014.
Many proponents of illegal immigration believe illegals are beneficial to the American economy. [Statistic] Because of this statistic, Liberals argue that It should be the least courtesy That Americans grant legal status to workers who benefit the agricultural industry. The waste of workers deported back to Mexico would be catastrophic to America's farms. The undocumented workers are essential to supporting major industries like agriculture and construction, among the most important industries of the American economy. Undocumented workers are essential to supporting the American economy. The liberal argument is that the jobs that most illegal immigrants take are jobs that Americans do not want. Undocumented people work hard and are among
“One of Canada's greatest assets is our creative and hard-working entrepreneurs, and we want to make sure that they have the capital they need to build our nation's innovative enterprises. Leveraging investments from immigrant investors will help support the continued growth of the Canadian economy, a priority for our government.” – James Moore, Minister of Industry ("Strengthening Canada's economy..." 2014).
Nonetheless, it is true that immigration has its own flaws. The oppose side against immigration argue that with no restriction with immigration this country will be facing national problems. It will be freely open to terrorism and crimes. Immigrants are more likely to bring up the crime rates that this country already has. Immigrants dont bring the good this country, they want inpose a culture that this country is not and they are just taking the jobs away. Immigrants dont intregate to the american culture, they dispate it and want to change it. In the article “Too Many: Looking Today’s Immigration in the Face“ Steve Camarota says, “immigration: a social phenemon of enormous signficance, affecting everything from nation’s schools to the
More than 550,000 LPRs in 2011 were women and more than 600,000 were married individuals. By 2026, it is predicted that the government will have a shortage of 20 million workers. In the US, 5 states have become minority-majority, which means that less than half of the population of that state is non-Hispanic white and the minorities combined have become the majority.For the first time in 2012, the majority of babies under age 1 were black, Hispanic, Asian, or another non-white race. Some immigrants have proved to have been terrorist threats. Illegal immigrants that are caught are put through deportation. Drivers licenses for immigrants in the United States are illegally given out to them somehow. The United States border militarization is beginning to become weak. The United States are always using
Nowhere else in the world does an invisible line draw such a disparity in wealth and lifestyle. Our border with Mexico divides one of the West's richest countries with a struggling third world economy. The nature of the border presents many unique issues; Mexican refuges looking for a better life here in America, Mexican drug lords exporting drugs to drug savvy America, American jobs going overseas for cheaper labor, as well as the integrating of our two cultures. Mexican immigration is a liability in our country, for reasons that I will state. Yet despite its threat to the American way of life and economy, many powerful elites believe in amnesty because: it drives down labor costs (but they forget to mention workers wages as well), it is "racist" (or at least many political figures will have you believe), and it is a huge untapped constituency. I believe that it would be in the United States best interest to increase our military presence and use of high tech surveillance on the border and continue to work bilaterally with Mexico, as well as create harsher domestic laws to help limit the flow of illegal drugs and immigrants into our nation.
Garcia fled Mexico with her parents in the early 1990’s in hopes of a better life. Due to President Trump’s executive order, Garcia was deported (www.cnn.com/2017/02/09/us/arizona-guadalupe-garcia-de-rayos-protests). Although Garcia did get into trouble after she was arrested for working illegally and falsifying documents, I don’t believe her intentions to be in America were bad. Some people believe that the community has the right to control issues of this sort, not so much the politicians. I know that many Americans think that all undocumented immigrants are “bad” or “dangerous” people and that is not so. Many families fled to this country for the sake of their children, to try and give them a better life, and as a parent of two small children I can totally relate and understand that aspect of it. In between the immigrants with good intentions there are many that don’t have great intentions. There have been several studies over the years that concluded that immigrants are less likely to commit crimes than people born in the United
between October of 2013 and September 30 of 2014, Customs and Border Control came across 67,339 children without a parent or legal guardian. The largest number of children recorded was 27 percent of the total. This total came from Honduras. Guatemala followed with 25 percent of the total, El Salvador with 24 percent, and then Mexico, last, with 23 percent. Since the number of unaccompanied children was at its highest peak in the summer and the all of 2014, the amount of children that arrive at the southern border has impressively depleted. Between October 1, 2014 and April 30, 2015, US Customs and Border patrol has apprehended 3,514 unaccompanied minors from El Salvador, 6,607 from Guatemala, 1,977 from Honduras, and 6,519 from Mexico. Forty-five