Twelfth Night Suffering

761 Words2 Pages

Twelfth Night is one of Shakespeare's best romantic plays. It is charming, humorous, and highly compelling. Yet it seems to have a rather grim view of its primary subject matter: human love, and the ways in which it affects, addicts, and ensnares people. Although the play ends happily, and indeed, shows the characters finding various forms of romantic fulfillment, there is no denying how difficult and at some points excruciating love is for the characters. As a result, the play seems to suggest that one must suffer and experience pain in order to be happy. Love is a terribly painful experience for many characters in the story. Both Viola and Sebastien feel miserable because they believe someone they love is dead. Viola becomes even more despairing …show more content…

(3.4 326–330)

Then, after being interrupted by the officer who arrests him, he continues, But oh, how vile an idol proves this god! Thou hast, Sebastien, done good feature shame. In nature there's no blemish but the mind. None can be called deformed but the unkind. Virtue is beauty, but the beauteous evil, Are empty trunks, o'erflourished by the devil. (3.4 331–337)

For the most part, these sufferings come about as a result of mistaken identity and disguise, leading to the belief that love itself may be a trap. And love does seem to be quite an effective trap in Twelfth Night. Out of love for Sebastien, Antonio finds himself under arrest. Out of love for Olivia, Malvolio is nearly driven insane by Sir Toby and his accomplices. And, due the fact that her male persona leads Olivia to love her, Viola is nearly killed by Orsino. Interestingly, most of the examples of love being a trap come from people behaving in ways that were unacceptable at the time: Antonio's love for Sebastien, for example, is likely homoerotic in nature. Malvolio's desire for Olivia is deeply intwined with his desire to rise up on the social ladder. And Viola's disguise effectively changes her gender, leading to various problems; admittedly, she expresses dislike for the disguise in the line, “Disguise, I see thou art a wickedness” (2.2 25). In sum, most of the examples of this “love is a trap” scenario result from characters committing socially taboo acts, such …show more content…

Malvolio clearly spends a lot of time fantasizing about Olivia before he even reads the forged letter Toby and Maria leave for him. Orsino spends a great deal of his time lying about lugubriously and thinking about how much he wants Olivia to love him, yet one gets the feeling that he seems to be more interested in thinking about Olivia than actually having her. If he did have her, he would probably become bored. He idealizes her; at one point, when his servant says that Olivia will mourn her dead brother for seven years, he

Open Document