Trail Of Tears Dbq

728 Words2 Pages

“We are on the eve of leaving that country that gave us birth, it is with sorrow we are forced by the white man to quit the scenes of our childhood...we bid farewell to it and all we hold dear.” These powerful words were uttered by vice chief Charles Hicks of the Cherokee about how he and his people faced the imminent threat of removal. The people who lived on these lands for thousands of years were forced off their ancestral lands, “out of the disagreement between the state of Georgia and the Cherokee regarding the right to rule certain areas within the state” (Flaherty). This path they followed to the west is known infamously as the Trail of Tears. Numerous laws, orders, ethics and morals were destroyed in the process for the Native Americans’ …show more content…

In the first place, the events that lead to the Trail of Tears were not justifiable as they were highly immoral. At the time, when Whites traveled they were given the best care - clean places to stay and access to the medically trained, if necessary. The antithesis was given to the vast majority of the Native Americans travelling the Trail of Tears. Before removal, the Native Americans were held in stockades - like prisoners and felons - where diseases like, “Dysentery, measles, and whooping cough were [rampant] … Before the removal process even began, an estimated 2,000 to 4,000 Cherokees died in those stockades” (Bowes). In these ‘prisons’, the people who cultivated and lived on North America for thousands of years - were reduced to animals. Without proper care, the Natives dropped like flies. Yet, white bystanders let this continue. Furthermore, Whites justified removal by calling the Native Americans savages and criminals. The irony is undeniable. In fact, the Native Americans had, “absorbed much of the white settlers’ …show more content…

United States law at the time required all treaties to be negotiated peacefully and fairly with the Native Americans. Yet when settlers ‘relieved Natives of their land’ the process used, “involved bribery and intimidation and was devoid of federal government protection of Native Americans in conflict with the states” (Ball). The latter about fairness was also encroached upon when Cherokee forfeited vast amounts of land for a mere 50 cents; following the discovery of gold, the land was sold at $30,000 (Williams 156). On top of this, when Georgia and pressed for laws removing Native Americans, the esteemed Chief Justice John Marshall states in Cherokee Nation v. Georgia (1831), that the authority of Georgia did not extend over the independent, sovereign nations of the Native Americans - in essence, they were useless (Ball). Typical of his presidency, President Andrew Jackson arrogantly defied the court order saying, “John Marshall has made his decision; now let him enforce

More about Trail Of Tears Dbq

Open Document