The Theme Of Music In The Wagner Matinee By Willa Cather

1915 Words4 Pages

So much of life can’t be known. To live without some sense of curiosity about what’s out there and what it all means will never lead to true fulfillment. This paradox often ends with lost souls searching tirelessly for some type of idea they can connect to. Each of Willa Cather’s protagonists experiences this same hunger for finding their place on Earth and, at the same time, their connection to something much larger. Though each hunger is unique, in Cather’s works what satiates this longing is somewhat constant. In such works as The Great Short Works of Willa Cather, My Ántonia, and One of Ours, Cather’s consistently unsettled characters find meaning and personal fulfillment in music and the environment.
Music is everywhere in the works of Willa Cather. It exists as a subject and also in the background. Never incidental, it is a symbol or metaphor that underscores the action. Beyond that, music is something that gives meaning to life and connects characters to distant or internal lands.
“The Wagner Matinee,” a hauntingly beautiful short story by Cather, is a good example of the importance of music. It also presents the heartbreak that can accompany being removed from what gives one’s life purpose, another theme throughout Cather’s work. The story centers on a young man named Clark who takes his elderly aunt Georgina to her first classical performance since she moved to a farm with her husband years ago, breaking “a silence of thirty years, the inconceivable silence of the plains” (Great Short Works of Willa Cather, 58). A lover and teacher of music, the only music Georgina had heard in in this time was that of the church choir.
At first Clark wonders whether the music has any effect on his aunt after all this time. Whether s...

... middle of paper ...

...nd streaked with rose colour, thin as a bubble or a ghost-moon. For five, perhaps ten minutes, the two luminaries confronted each other across the level land, resting’s on opposite edges of the world.” It is in that moment that Jim feels once more “the old pull of the earth, the solemn magic that comes out of those fields at nightfall” (My Ántonia, 192).

It’s easy to imagine that for Jim and Ántonia the scenes of nature Cather so lovingly describes throughout her works are like a visual representation of music. The feelings of enchantment, wonder, and meaning that Georgina, Paul, and Eric feel in the presence of music, and that David and Mr. Shirmedia lost, are what they have found in the sweeping plains. Like so many of Cather’s characters, these souls have all been greatly affected by music and the environment on their journey towards fulfillment.

Open Document