The Optimist's Daughter Eudora Kelva Character Analysis

1545 Words4 Pages

When death strikes, no two people are affected in the same way. Some are strong and cope with it well, while others can barely even function. Death certainly changes a person's life, mainly for the worse. In Eudora Welty’s The Optimist's Daughter, Judge McKelva’s death had the surprising effect of changing Fay and Laurel for the better; they became more adventurous and open to new experiences, and learned that they could find family in people who were not related to them.
Laurel McKelva, Judge McKelva’s daughter, has had a rough life. Experiencing the death of her father, husband, and mother certainly shaped her personality to the way it was portrayed in the book. She was often closed-minded, controlling, and quiet. She overthought everything, …show more content…

She viewed herself as superior to others and was constantly making a judgement about them. She questioned others frequently, which resulted in her having the attitude that she couldn’t trust anyone. Fay even admitted “I haven’t got anybody to count on but me, myself, and I.” (54) She never took responsibility for her actions, and always blamed them on other people. When her late-husband, Judge McKelva, passed away because of her aggressive actions, she blamed it on the doctor. She said to his lifelong doctor, Dr. Courtland “All I hope is you lay awake tonight and remember how little you were good for!” (42) When decisions were made without her permission, specifically operating on her husband, a whole new side of Fay was illustrated. She blamed the unsuccessfulness of the surgery on the medical staff. When the nurses accused her of making his retina slip, they tried to kick her out of the hospital, which angered Fay. She yelled at the staff saying “You went in my husband’s eye without consulting my feelings and next you try to run me out of this hospital!” (36) This just showed how on edge Fay was, and how easily she could break. Although Judge McKelva was a capable adult, Fay still felt as if every decision should be made by her. When she didn’t get her way, it was everyone else’s fault. After the Judge passed away, she angrily yelled at the doctor “I knew better than to let you go in that eye to start with. That …show more content…

Laurel recognized, with the remarks of others, that she had no one. Mrs. Chison, a close friend to Laurel pointed out “You was cheated. You ain’t got no father, mother, brother, sister, husband, chick nor child. Not a soul to call on, it’s just you.” (69) Fay also found the importance of friendship and memory in life. She began to recognize the significance of a stable home. According to Jennifer Bussey “It is a safe haven where Laurel and Fay can be truthful with themselves among people who know them well enough to know when to challenge them and when to leave them alone.” Laurel was originally from Chicago, Illinois and Fay was from Madrid, Texas. The two decided to spend some time together at the house in Mount Salus, before returning to their hometowns. In this time together, they got to know each other much better. Through their talks, they both recognized the fact that they needed to move on with their lives. Laurel said “The past is no more open to help or hurt than was Father in his coffin. The past is like him, impervious, and can never be awakened. It is memory that is the somnambulist. It will come back in its wounds from across the world, calling us by our names and demanding its rightful tears. It will never be impervious. The memory can be hurt, time and again-- but in that may lie its final mercy. As long as it’s vulnerable to the living

Open Document