Wait a second!
More handpicked essays just for you.
More handpicked essays just for you.
Women's role in religion
Comparison of religion gender roles
Gender roles through RELIGION
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
Recommended: Women's role in religion
Is Religion Inherently Sexist?
Alba K. Marcano
INTRODUCTION
The Oxford Dictionary defines sexism as “Prejudice, stereotyping, or discrimination, typically against women, on the basis of sex”. While sexism has been present in most aspects of human life both today and in the past, religion remains one of the oldest sources and justifications of this behaviour. However, two religions, Christianity and Islam, present two views of the topic. Both the sexist and non-sexist aspects will be examined and compared in this text in order to prove whether or not these religions are inherently sexist. 85
OVERVIEW 1 – Christianity
Sexism in Christianity has been present from the beginning. In the story of the world’s creation, in Genesis, the woman, Eve,
…show more content…
This is a belief echoed several times in the Gospel by Jesus Christ, according to B. A. Robinson, author of the article Women's roles in the Bible: The status of women in the Christian Gospels. Another example of gender equality in Christianity the ordination of female bishops and priests by the Anglican Church. Michael Adie, the Bishop of Guildford in 1992, states: “the ordination of women is a reasoned development, consonant with Scripture, required by tradition”. Many countries agree with this opinion, and have in fact already ordained women (House of Bishops 2004). …show more content…
In fact, in both religions, women are thought to be inferior to men. This is a belief backed by religious texts in both religions: in the Bible, Eve is told: “you will be subject to him [your husband]” (Genesis 3:16), while in the Qu’ran, a man is said to be worth two women, in terms of inheritance, bearing witness, etc.: “The male shall have the equal of the portion of two females” (Qu’ran 4:11). This way of thinking is the base for modern-day misogyny in both religions. 100 Yet, both religions are slowly beginning to accept women as something more than wives and mothers. Recently, Christians and Muslims have begun accepting women in the role of religious leaders, in Christianity as bishops, and in Islam, as imams. While women have been able to lead religious prayer in Islam under strict circumstances, such as when the congregation is composed uniquely of women or of close family members, in 2005, Dr. Amina Wadud was one of the first women to lead a mixed-gender congregation in prayer (Elewa and Silvers, 2010). One the other hand, Christian women were not able to be religious leaders until recently because the Scripture was against it: women were specifically prohibited from officiating a mass (1 Corinthians 14:34). Nonetheless, certain branches of Christianity, such as Anglicanism now allow women in positions of power, as mentioned in Overview 1.
In Women, Church, God: A Socio-Biblical Study, Caleb Rosado uses a socio-biblical approach to discuss the role of women in the church today and how they were treated in the Bible, during the patriarchal times. Rosado looks at the connection between what people believe now, their culture, and how they treat women in regards to how one perceives God. This book contains ten chapters in which several topics are discussed, including the nature of God, the treatment of women in the Bible, patrimonialism, servitude, and servanthood.
It is evident that men are often viewed as being superior or more important than females through a variety of different aspects. In the text, Eve and Adam:Genesis 2-3 Reread by Phyllis Trible, Trible discusses the story of Adam and Eve and how this biblical piece is what essentially created the gender roles that are presented in todays society. The first illustration of male dominance is seen when God creates the first human being which happens to be a man (Trible, 141). The males role is to to maintain the garden, take care of the animals and essentially be the one who is in charge (Trible, 141). A woman is only created in order to keep the male company and help him therefore, the woman takes on a secondary role while the man has the primary role clearly showing that men hold more power in society. Another clear example of male domination comes from the text, The Creation and Fall of Man and Woman by Rosemary Agonito states that the reasoning for gender differences is due to Adam and Eve disobeying God by eating from the tree of knowledge. When Adam and Eve make the chose to eat from the tree God gives them both
The bible has been the center of many debates and has been used correctly and incorrectly. My objective in this paper is to illuminate the many flaws in the century-old yet ever present interpretation of the bible that suggests women are lesser than men. I will also commend and explain the use of the bible during the civil rights movement.
“It is time that we all see gender as a spectrum instead of two sets of opposing ideals. We should stop defining each other by what we are not and start defining ourselves by who we are” (Emma Watson). Since the beginning of time, Eve was portrayed as the first sinner and this could be the reason why women are still paying for her sins to this day, from either education to jobs and look to stereotypes. Though now women are crawling out of the hole of inequality faster than before and soon women will be able to reach the light they have been waiting to grasp.
Judith Lorder writes in Night to His Day: The Social Construction of Gender, "talking about gender for most people is equivalent of fish talking about water" because gender is so routine that its "assumptions and presuppositions" are taken for granted and left unquestioned and unchallenged. Institutions such as religion has remained virtually unchanged for hundreds of years and has teachings that are outright sexist, which limits lives of women because it creates the idea that there are just two extremes and no in-between : the virgin or the whore. Men do not have to face persecution or tyranny in instutions and social systems have a patriarchal foundation. Gender inequity operates within instutions because the institutions are in the control of men who are privileged from the gender inequity. Institutions limit women 's lives by excluding women who do not conform to their expectations or follow their "rules." The rules or norms within these instutitions were determined by men which explains why women 's problems or limitations are not a concern for
There are many socially constructed beliefs that help feed gender inequality. One of the primitive and initial source that influences gender inequality is tradition developed by religion.
Throughout almost every time period in history, and in nearly all world cultures women have always been thought of as being lower than men. Most societies are patriarchal and leave men as the powerful decision makers. This idea has only recently started to change more towards equality among the sexes in the last one hundred years or so. However, the religions of Islam, Western Christianity and Byzantine Christianity, although they all showed some semblance of wanting to help out women, all were really just reinforcing and justifying the patriarchal conditions of their cultures. They also went to further probe that different religions do make a difference for women.
Women of these times were obviously not equal to their male counterparts. In modern days however, women are thought of as equals in society. The problem is that they are still not being treated as equals in a religious aspect as well as many other aspects. Elizabeth A. Johnson draws attention to how, despite being considered equal in Genesis, women had their worth ignored “Consistently subordinated and demeaned in the theories, symbols, rituals, A large wave of pro women thinking has arisen in the form of feminist theology. This line of thought draws from Genesis and the idea that men and women were created equally.
Today, women share the same equal rights and opportunities as men; nevertheless, that has not invariably been the case. Before the Jazz Age era, gender discrimination between men and women in society was considerably popular. Women were seen as inferior to men. Their jobs were to care for the home, children, and other domesticated duties while men were able to work, get an education, and become doctors or lawyers. Many women like Susan B. Anthony, Elizabeth Cady Stanton, Ida B. Wells, Sojourner Truth, Zora Hurston, to mention a few, seen the unfairness in women's rights and fought for equal rights for women through different movements, efforts, protests, and even marches to abolish women’s rights. As a consequence, women now pursue not only higher education and higher paid jobs/ businesses, but their rights. One of the world’s most controversial issues among churches of today is the role of a woman. Many people are confused about the duty of a woman and how she is supposed to serve God because of history. History taught us to never deny someone of gender, race, or even diversity since he or she has human rights. However, this issue should not be viewed as men versus women because this is not a political issue; instead, it should be viewed as the structural of a church. Women should not be priests, pastors, or even rabbis for God condone women for being priests, pastors, and rabbis as well as proscribed.
The depreciation of women and their overall inferior position in society can be attributed to the androcentric interpretations of the Hebrew Bible, especially the story of Adam and Eve. Throughout history, the story of Adam and Eve has been used by men to point out the inherent evil in women by pinning the eventual expulsion of Adam and Eve from Heaven on the neck of Eve. Eve has long been blamed for the expulsion from Heaven and in effect, women, even up until today, are portrayed as the “gateway to sin.”
There is clear evidence of rape culture in the bible, but several analysts provide a new perspective on the text. Genesis sets the initial scene of the world, it contains the first creation story (Genesis 1:27, Coogan and Brettler). The description provides the audience with an image of God creating man, female and male simultaneously, "So God created man in his own image, in the image of God created he him; male and female created he them”. This can be interpreted as God implying equality between the two genders. As Elizabeth Cady Stanton states in The Original Feminist Attack on the Bible, “ The masculine and feminine elements, exactly equal and balancing each other, are as essential to the maintenance of the equilibrium of the universe”
I find myself many times totally immersed in thought. Many times I find myself mentally debating politics and arguing both sides. Other times I ponder some of life’s greatest questions; where did life begin? what is the purpose of life? My mind could wonder for hours jumping from topic to topic, but the topic I always bring myself back to is Christianity. It started as a freshman when I decided to spend a whole evening trying to use math and science, (specifically the rate the sun grows every year) to prove the earth was too young for evolution to have occurred. Then while reading political satire I found myself taking notes about how the Bible if read and understood correctly is not sexist and does not advocate for the stoning of sinners.
Interpretations of the Bible are influential to our society because in the United States, approximately eighty-three percent of the population is Christian, according to a poll performed by ABC News. Perhaps the Bible is written with women subservient to men because the very story of creation is written as such. Genesis serves as the foundation of not only our universe, but also the religious text. In the biblical story of creation, Adam came first, then came the animals, and then last of all came Eve, putting the origin of women last. Then, it is Eve who is vulnerable enough for evil to deceive her into taking the apple and she who persuades Adam to follow her example. This sets up a basis that women are inherently weak and sinful for the rest of the faith to be built upon. (Stanton)
Initially, Old Testament describes women as the corrupter of man. However, through interpreting the action of Jesus Christ, we see that he holds women in equal roles as men, to include mention of female apostles. The New Testament does not promote equality but does mention the acts of Jesus. Finally, the Qur'an places women in a subservient role allowing men to keep their under control, by any means. Interpretations of the Gods word under the disguise of organized religion are the product of the gender discrimination of the time and continue to paint women as lesser creatures in the eyes of God.
Gender equality has been an issue for centuries. Ever since the days of the bible, women