Revenge Of History: Movie Analysis

931 Words2 Pages

In “The ‘Revenge of History’: Collective Memories and Labor Protests in North-Eastern China” Ching Kwan Lee analyzes three cases of worker protests and their subsequent success or failure. Lee spoke with a southern Chinese worker about the labor protests and the woman described the situation of the displaced laborers as a “revenge of history” where “those who used to benefit most from the warmth of state socialism suffered most under the competition-driven market socialism” (220). The workers in the northeastern provinces had grown accustomed to the state socialist model, which allowed them to thrive in the “huge, self-sufficient, heavy industrial state enterprises” that operated in the region (Lee, 220). When China began to transition from …show more content…

The majority of the movie follows Song and Tang as they begin their cycle anew with Yuan Fengming, a sixteen-year-old boy looking for work in order to pay for schooling for his sister. Yuan pretends to be the nephew of Song as the three of them begin work at a coal mine; however, the situation grows more complicated as Song begins to have doubts about murdering Yuan while Tang grows angrier and more anxious with every delay in their …show more content…

Around the five-minute mark of the film there is a scene with Song, Tang, and what is later revealed to be one of their victims. After a short conversation where the man talks about being homesick and missing his child, Song and Tang proceed to kill him with their pickaxes. The mine boss is told that he died due to a cave-in, and Tang puts on a very public and convincing show of grief over his lost “brother,” demanding that the family be allowed to come say their final goodbyes. He is eventually “convinced” to take a settlement of thirty-thousand yuan and leave the mine with the cremated ashes of the dead man. Much later in the film, around the fifty-minute mark Yuan shows Song a photo of his family. Song then takes Tang aside and begins talking about how the photo of Yuan’s father bears a striking resemblance to the man they killed at the beginning of the film, and that they even share the same last name. Song seems convinced that Yuan Fengming is the son of the man they had previously killed, and his trepidation and doubt about their plan becomes more evident. As the film approaches the eighty-minute mark the three men are in the mine and the dialogue echoes the opening scene, with Tang asking Yuan if he is homesick. Instead of striking Yuan with his pickaxe, Tang delivers a blow to Song’s face and then proceeds to approach Yuan to kill him as

Open Document