Confederate Controversy: Heritage or Hatred?

700 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Essays on the confederate flag

Natalie Smith Mr. Cline English 2H: 07 19 August 2015 Confederate Controversy When majorities of people see the Confederate flag they think it symbolizes racism, oppression, and even supremacy. The other portion of people say that the Confederate flag is a representation of heritage, history, and states’ rights. In my personal perspective no matter what faction you choose the flag was ascended at a particularly delicate time period. The period known as the ‘Civil War’, which was caused by two major divisions including States Rights’ and money. I do not agree that the removal of the Confederate flag would be necessary considering the fact that not only the South owned slaves but also the North was just as guilty. The Union …show more content…

Dylan Roof brought the controversy back into play when he took the lives of nine African Americans at the Emanuel AME church. Found on Roof’s Facebook were pictures of him holding the Confederate flag, which to many brought back the treacherous memories of slavery, but not really the flag itself. Removing the flag would not eliminate the past it would only be taking a way the history of our freedom. I simply believe we cannot blame an object especially one that has been part of our history for hundreds of years. People who think that the Confederate flag is a symbol of racism do not understand the true heritage and evolution of our country. Even now with a whole new American flag the same colors, the same stripes, and the same stars are still represented just in a different pattern. Dylan Roof deserves everything he got but we cannot let our nation repeat its mistakes, and by eliminating the Confederate Flag would make absolutely no sense. The Confederate flag was raised before slavery even was an issue during the war, and before the Civil War there was another flag. The flag of June 14th, 1777, which was flown far before the Confederate flag well over fifty years, was a time period when slavery was around. If you blame the …show more content…

We should not look at the Confederate flag as a emblem of discrimination and prejudice, but as a point that we took the slavery out and put in the liberty and raised it high. Dylan Roof will be loathed against no matter what he does or what he posted on the Internet because of what he did to innocent people. The Confederate flag should be put in the hands of those who know what it actually symbolizes and somebody who wont make any misconceptions. It is a precious part of our history and not something that should be recognized as an

Show More
Related

  • Brown versus Board of Education and Raising the Confederate Flag

    1524 Words  | 4 Pages

    ...more overpowering and overwhelming than any general feeling of Southern pride. America has obtained a reputation to be an accepting and open minded country, welcoming all of any race, couture and religion. The Preamble states clearly that America will establish justice and insure domestic tranquility for all. Neither of these entities are accomplished in America as long as the Confederate flag remains raised. Our nation is furthermore divided by racism through a flag that is possibly being used as a degradation tool. This battle with racism has become far too large for American citizens and anything that is viewed as racist in such a manner as the Confederate flag is, should be censored from society, in only a helpful practice. A state flag should be capable of uniting its citizens, instead of dividing them. The Confederate flag should be lowered immediately.

    Read More

  • Pros And Cons Of Slave Insurrection

    723 Words  | 2 Pages

    Slave insurrection occurred in a multitude of ways. Slaves practiced everyday resistance as well as planned and executed more elaborate forms of resistance. One form of resistance was strikes. During a strike Negros would flee to the swamps or forests and send back word that they would return if their demands were made. Demands would often include food, clothes, fewer beatings, shorter hours, or a new overseer. If demands were met they would return. However during the Civil War the demand of payment of wages. During this era they won “lifting themselves by their own bootstraps from chattels to wage workers”.3

    Read More

  • Compromise Of 1850 Pros And Cons

    1301 Words  | 3 Pages

    The Compromise of 1850 is composed of five laws proceeded on September of 1850 that distributed with the matter of slavery. In 1849 California demanded permission or authorization in order to enter the Union as an independent and free state, prospectively upsetting the balance between the free and slave states in the United State Senate. Senator Henry Clay established a series of resolutions on the 29th of January 1850, aiming to seek a compromise and avert a crisis between the North and the South.“South Carolina Senator John C. Calhoun prepared his last speech during the course of the great debate over the Compromise of 1850, a controversial set of resolutions sponsored by Senator Henry Clay that moved the slavery question squarely to the

    Read More

  • It's Time to Change the Flag of Mississippi

    698 Words  | 2 Pages

    Although many corporations have contributed large sums of money to campaign for a new Mississippi flag, that would replace the existing 1894 Confederate flag and improve economic and racial relations throughout the state, chances are slim that a change will occur. Many Mississippians are simply not ready for change and few African-Americans are actually pushing for a change. Many Mississippians view the original flag as part of the state’s heritage and do not want to replace it with a new one. However, I believe it is in the best interest of the state of Mississippi to change the flag, not only to ease racial tensions, but also to boost economic conditions.

    Read More

  • Civil War - North Vs. South

    830 Words  | 2 Pages

    In the early American colonies, the south and the north developed into two distinctly different colonies. Although their origins were both from Europe, their customs and living habits became so different that it would play a major role in America’s history. There are many reasons why these differences occurred but only a few major reasons stand out. Religion, greed and the composition of the colonies are some of the major reasons why the north and south grew to be so different in the late 1600’s. Different religions in specific colonies varied, but the people from the New England region were generally more devoted to their religious beliefs, whereas people from the south felt religion wasn’t as important. Children from the north are taught from The Bible as soon as possible and this instills high moral values into the people. In the south only the wealthiest families could afford education, causing the common population to be ignorant and un-educated. The people of New England were willing to work together and help each other for the sake of the community because they felt that they were working under God’s will. (Doc. A) The south on the other hand worked to better themselves through the Headright System, which ended up pitting the people against each other instead of working with each other. The people of Massachusetts agreed: "We whose names are underwritten, being by God’s providence engaged together to make a plantation…" (Doc. D) This shows that reli...

    Read More

  • Southern Pro-Slavery Rhetoric

    1613 Words  | 4 Pages

    Southern Pro-Slavery Rhetoric By 1860, the slave states had approximately four million slaves making up approximately one-third of the South's population. However, opposition to slavery began as early as the 1700's by religious leaders and philosophers in North America and Europe who condemned the practice, arguing that slavery was contrary to God's teachings and violated basic human rights. During the Revolutionary War, many Americans came to feel that slavery in the United States was wrong because they believed that protection of human rights was one of the founding tenets of the United States, and slaves were not accorded rights. Slavery was likely opposed more rapidly in the North, in part because fewer people in the North owned slaves.

    Read More

  • Civil War and The South's Loss

    1824 Words  | 4 Pages

    nation of mechanics…You are bound to fail.” Union officer William Tecumseh Sherman to a Southern friend.

    Read More

  • Slavery And Southern Honor

    1654 Words  | 4 Pages

    To southern men, honor was everything. I dictated their standing in society, whether or not they could own slaves; it basically was a secret caste system. A man held in the highest honor experienced a good life from a social stance in the south. The honor system used in the south was related to the language used by southern gentlemen.# Honor and Slavery by Kenneth S. Greenburg attempts to explain the vernacular and customs used by men in the antebellum south. It would be hard for a person in today's society to understand the way honor was shown; it would have even been a challenge for men living in the Northern United States to understand at that time.# As Greenburg states, "Since the language of honor was the dominant language of the men who ruled the slave South, we will never understand masters, the nature of slavery, or the Civil war without first understanding that language."# To be a powerful man in the south, society also had to consider you to be an honorable man. Honor and power in the South were parallel to each other; a man with a high honor ranking was usually a prominent member of society.#

    Read More

  • Essay On Confederate Statues

    658 Words  | 2 Pages

    One reason Confederate status should not be taken down is because the Civil War is apart of our country’s history. It is stated in “Monumental Battle” by Laura Anastaisa, “‘We never addressed the legacy of the Civil War or slavery, and what it means to the country now and what it meant then,”’ This presents the idea that the Civil War was not given enough credit. It ended slavery! Yes, there were still people back then that wanted to keep their slaves, however, they didn’t win, and ended up

    Read More

  • Persuasive Essay On The Confederate Flag

    730 Words  | 2 Pages

    The Confederate flag was used symbolically during the Civil War. For Southerner’s, the flag represented a source of southern pride as well as a way of remembering the fallen Confederates. As the Civil War proceeded, the meaning of the flag began to change. Currently, the flag is being used as a symbol of racism. Due to this change in meaning, controversy over the flag has been exponentially growing.

    Read More

  • Controversial Legacy: Examining Robert E. Lee

    1127 Words  | 3 Pages

    Did you know that just outside of Lexington, Virginia (where Lee is buried) a Confederate battle flag, which Lee defended flies from an 80-foot pole on private property and after the property owner put up the flag he also put an ad in the local newspaper that read no “black people” are allowed on his property until further notice? Also a fact, the Confederate flag, which Lee defended, is the emblem of the KKK, a white hate group that is anti-black, anti-Catholic, and anti-Jewish.

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast The United States And Confederate States

    826 Words  | 2 Pages

    Formed at the eve of the Civil War, the United States (USA) and the Confederate States (CSA) were created for multiple reasons. The main reason of the formation includes that of political issues and slavery issues. Other ideas include the military, economics, etc. The USA was led by President Abraham Lincoln and the CSA was led under President Jefferson Davis. The CSA included the states of Virginia, North Carolina, South Carolina, Georgia, Alabama, Florida, Tennessee, Mississippi, Arkansas, Louisiana, and Texas. The United States and Confederate States can be compared based on their advantages and viewpoints in the fields of how and why they were formed, the rights of the federal and state governments, views on slavery, economic issues, and the military strategies.

    Read More

  • Argumentative Essay On Confederate Monuments

    365 Words  | 1 Pages

    In conclusion, people should not take down confederate memorials as they are part of the history. They remind us of the cost of freedom and equality; they force us to remember the ignominious truth of the past; they serve as a mighty tool to educate the racists. We need them to avoid recommitting the same

    Read More

  • Percival Everett's The Appropriation Of Cultures

    524 Words  | 2 Pages

    Why be suppressed by a symbol deemed against African Americans when identity is purely subjective? Barkley was tired of having to constantly be reminded of a horrible time, so he took the symbol as his own and changed the meaning. He referred to the flag as representing black-power, which was the complete opposite of what society thought. This created a huge statement and made people stop and think about what an African American man was doing flaunting a confederate flag.

    Read More

  • Kelsen's Pure Law Theory

    956 Words  | 2 Pages

    Kelsen’s theory or Pure Law generally dictates that the law is the law void of any morality. Which begs the question, is putting someone to death based on the displaying of a flag, moral? Although it is morally wrong to kill anyone, the law clearly states that anyone deemed a traitor would be put to death. Therefore, this law would be viable. Unless, there were some type of civil war to over throw the confederate government to change the norm of this law. Thereby making this law not

    Read More

More about Confederate Controversy: Heritage or Hatred?

Open Document