Nightman Cometh Case Study

781 Words2 Pages

QUESTION PRESENTED Under California Law, should Charles and Paddy’s be held liable by the court for negligence and award Dennis with compensation when the incident occurred as a result of Dennis’ and Charlie’s destruction of the property, Charles owed no duty to Dennis, Dennis knew the foreseeable risk just as well as Charles, and Paddy’s had posted warnings for the damages that caused the incident in question?
STATEMENT OF FACTS
Charles Kelly (“Charlie”) and Dennis Reynolds (“Dennis”) have been work colleagues and close friends for several years. Both of them work at Paddy’s Pub (“Paddy’s”), a bar located near the Universal Studios lot in Pasadena, CA and spend a great amount of time in each other’s company.
Despite their friendship, Charlie and Dennis have two very distinct personalities and backgrounds. Charlie, although never earning a degree, is a successful playwright whose hit “The Nightman Cometh” received serious critical acclaim. At Paddy’s, he is often the one left in charge of the less-desirable work, which he complies with nonetheless. Apart from not being as proficient as Dennis …show more content…

Like a regular discord between long term friends, both parties argued back and forth in a rousing manner until Dennis had to excuse himself. Before saying goodbye, Dennis proceeded to say he was going “ask the waitress out tonight”, regardless of Charlie’s feelings, and that Charlie had to make sure to Paddy’s Pub’s basement and the bathrooms were clean, in case Dennis brought “the waitress” back to the bar. The waitress, a woman that works in a coffee shop near by, has been the object of Charlie’s love and desire for “most his life”, a fact that Dennis was well

Open Document