Nelly Roussel's Freedom Of Motherhood

1748 Words4 Pages

In the last decades of the nineteenth century, middle-class Parisians became obsessed with their own demise. After France’s embarrassing defeat in the Franco-Prussian War, many used degeneration theory, a scientific model developed in the 1800s that described the gradual decay of a species, as a way of explaining the loss. These pervasive fears of degeneration, coupled with rising anxiety concerning France’s low birthrate, created a climate where stability was both rare and necessary. Many French men looked to what they had seen as constants before the war as a means of finding stability, and one of the most treasured consistencies was the system of gender roles. While French men doubted their own virility as it related to their capacity to …show more content…

Accampo speaks of a specific lecture that took place on November 20, 1905; several newspapers publicized Roussel’s “Freedom of Motherhood” by defaming it as a depopulation speech. Nevertheless, as Roussel spoke, "Her audience was attentive and enthusiastic, interrupting her numerous times with applause." Therefore, despite negative press, many French people other than Roussel clearly held her same views; the separation of loving sexuality and procreation, along with her dramatic revelation of the truth of motherhood, resonated with many in her audience and beyond. At the same time, Accampo points out that Roussel’s critics rarely attended her lectures but instead attacked her ideas from afar. Her analysis reveals two popular concerns with Roussel’s message: "she brought into public discussion an issue that had previously been private, and she did so as a woman. She also created fears that more women would abandon their proper maternal responsibilities." Both of these ideas relate directly to the rhetoric surrounding virginity. First, Roussel unlocked the secret world of sexuality by discussing it so publicly. Whether sexual enjoyment or contraceptives, her topic choice did not conform to the ignorance mothers and suitors sought of young women. Furthermore, Roussel’s subtle …show more content…

The New Catholic Encyclopedia explains, “Virginity is the state of one who has not had sexual relations...It may be therefore attributed to men as well as to women, Apart from considerations of religion and virtue, however, it has generally been more highly honored in women than in men.” Virginity was commonly spoken of as “taken” or “lost”, and if a women did not guard herself against the advances of men, “elle perdra son prestige.” The majority of medical doctrine in Europe up until this point held that the breaking of the hymen was the telltale sign of a loss of virginity. For a society so obsessed with the act of penetrating the hymen, however, very little literature appears to connect the action of hymen-breaking to the concept of

Open Document