Misako's Book Report

1075 Words3 Pages

When the 1890s hit Japan and the country was being polished and renewed by every political and economic change, the government then decided to create a civil code so that Western nations would move forward with treaty revisions. As the years passed, the civil law changed with the people it affected and what their social standing was in society. Of course, women as wives still had obligations to follow. "Once wed, a woman could not testify in courts of law, bring legal action without her husband's permission, or initiate a divorce except in cases of desertion or extreme cruelty" (McClain 257). McClain also states that if a marriage were to fail then the women is to leave the house and the child stays with the father. This is where Some Prefer …show more content…

"He thinks it's a surface you cultivate, and underneath you're a chaste wife and a virtuous mother" (Tanizaki 87). This statement from the book and Misako reactions to Takanastu words show that maybe he was spot on. In the beginning when Kaname would withdraw from her sexually, Misako shed tears for the loneliness and stopped. The tears, however, would return when Aso came into the picture. In chapter eight of Some prefer Nettles, Misako affair is brought to light and shows how Kaname has hoped for someone to come along and give Misako what Kaname himself could not. All things considered, it seems that maybe Misako's modern tendencies stem from the fact that Misako needs to cover the embarrassment and pain of not having Kaname's affection after years of marriage and a child between the two. "The new laws treated a "wife" as a useful but replaceable module" (McClain 257). With Kaname he feels a women should either be a goddess or a plaything and Misako is neither in Kaname's eyes which sets Misako out to find someone who can give her the pleasures that she desires. Kaname and Misako's relationship is based more on the traditional marriage then they think. Kaname treating Misako with respect but sees no use of her in a sexual or emotional level. Following this evidence, Misako seeks the satisfaction of her needs with Aso. While the social standards of this agreement …show more content…

This part of the novel gives a perspective of the Bunraku puppet theater and the appeal of this art back in the 1950s, where Some Prefer Nettles takes place. Although Kaname only agrees to attend the play as to satisfy Misako's father. Kaname finds himself drawn to one of the puppets named Koharu, where the puppeteer handled this puppet like a treasured child. Kaname focused on Koharu movements and face itself. With this focus of this particular puppet he starts to see the traditional beauty of Japanese culture. The way Koharu somehow represented a "doll-like" women where people would see "classical beauty was withdrawn, restrained, careful not to show too much individuality" (Tanizaki 25), as the ideal woman. A modern women would be the complete opposite; a modern women would be too opinionated, too colorful. As Kaname starts spending more time with Misako's father and O-hisa, Kaname starts to view himself as an old soul as well. The beauty of O-hisa and the old fashion clothing that O-hisa was forced into by Misako's father starts to change Kaname's opinions on the beauty of a woman. Ideally Kaname's affair with Louise and the sudden interest in O-hisa and the puppet theater does show the battle between traditional and modern playthings. On one hand O-hisa does poise as the controlled and well restrained woman of any

Open Document