Meniscus Tears Essay

653 Words2 Pages

As submitted by Yan et al., (2011), meniscus tears, a condition prevalent among the old and young patients in equal measures are common predisposing factors for knee pain. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is done on the knee section and has incidentally found meniscal tears to be a typical case in regards to the general population. The prevalence of the condition was also determined to increase with the advancement of age. The purpose of the study is to conduct a prediction of the probability of the condition (meniscus tears) using a comparison of patient’s test history and MRI with physical examination (McMurray’s test). The authors of the article under review argue that it is critical to make meniscus tears diagnosis that is accurate to enable the administration of the most …show more content…

McMurray's test, locking and Giving Way were the independent factors for diagnosis that predicted a correct 80 percent in the meniscal tear diagnosis during arthroscopy. In regards to MRI, the combined values of the three tests (locking, Giving way and McMurray) were as follows: 88,90,90 for accuracy, 96, 97,97 for sensitivity, 74,76,74 for specificity, 87,88,88 for PPV and 90, 94,94 for NPV. The study determined that MRI shows a higher accuracy in comparison to giving way, locking and McMurray tests in regards to NPV and sensitivity. A combination of the other three tests seems appropriate for the diagnosis of the meniscal lesion. As informed by these results, there is a need for a standardized manner of MRI to be employed in the detection of meniscal tears in arthroscopy. However, the study seems to have a limitation regarding the study group. The target population was arthroscopy patients, which meant a possibility of higher prevalence in meniscal tear cases.

Open Document