Louis Riel as a Hero or Villian

566 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: louis riel as a hero essays

Louis Riel as a Hero or Villian The story of Louis Riel began on October 28th 1844. He was born in a log cabin beside Seine Lake. The same priest who married his parents one year earlier baptized Louis on his day of birth. Many people view Louis Riel as the biggest pioneer of Metis in Canadian history. They base their decision on the fortresses he took and his position in Metis organizations. Others call him a joke and despise him. They base this on him being taken to trial for treason and eventually convicted and sentenced to death. As well as him betraying his country and fleeing when the land's owners were switched ruining a chance for a rebellion and having the nerve to return and restart a rebellion only before being arrested tried and hung. Everybody has his or her own view as what to make of Louis Riel. What's yours…? Hero or Villain? If you think Louis Riel was a Hero. You need to assess his accomplishments and what they did for the Metis history. In this life time Riel was named the Secretary for the National Committee of the Red River Metis and people came to him for advice instead of the president. Riel was well aware of about McDougall's approach to the boundary at Pembina. On November 2nd, Riel and 120-armed Metis marched through the open gate at Fort Garry and took power of the ambulant storage of food and the fortress itself. Riel also claimed other fortresses for the Metis and eventually the president of the National Committee of the Red River Metis resigned and gave the position of president to Louis Riel. These are some of the many reasons that society today sees Louis Riel as a hero in Canadian history and they admire him. Although as you read you will see the reasons that society thinks of this man as an embarrassment in our history. If you think of Louis Riel was a Villain. You must look at all the crooked things he did while he was alive. He tried to lead Native Americans and Metis in the Red River settlements in Manitoba to rebel. Although the land was transferred from the Hudson Bay company to the Canadian Government, and the rebellion collapsed. Riel ran away and returned to Canada in 1844. He led rebels attempting to secure land titles in Saskatchewan at the engagement at Batoche in 1885.

Show More
Related

  • Louis Riel: Father of Confederation or a Treasonous Rebel?

    1114 Words  | 3 Pages

    Riel was highly looked upon by the Aboriginal peoples, notably the Métis, on account for fighting for their civil liberties in which were being stripped from them systematically by the government. While stationed in the Red River settlement, he was welcomed by the invasion of discrimination brought by Ontario Anglophone settlers; racial tensions escalated. He strived to protect the Métis habitat, customs and values in the Northwest as they were steadily l...

    Read More

  • Louis Riel Changed Manitoba Forever

    1141 Words  | 3 Pages

    One way that Louis Riel changed Manitoba forever was the creation of the Métis Bill of Rights. The Métis Bill of Rights was a revised list of rights that Louis Riel’s provisional government proposed to the Government of Canada. One aspect of this Bill of Rights was “The right to elect their own Legislative Assembly, with the power to pass all local laws,” (Clark and McKay 220). It is clear that this request was granted and still stands today. Without Louis Riel’s effort on this issue who knows when Manitoba would have gotten its own elected Legislative Assembly. Some argue that everything Louis Riel accomplished with the Métis Bill of Rights would have eventually been enacted by Parliament. However, this is untrue for numerous reasons. One of which is how the Métis Bill of Rights consisted of many rights intended specifically for minorities such as Métis or French-Canadians. The federal government at the time did not have minorities on its mind which made it hard for legislation relating to minorities to be passed. Another way that the Métis Bill of Rights still affects us today is how it ensured “The right to have Winnipeg connected by rail to the nearest railw...

    Read More

  • Bonaparte Betrayed the Revolution

    1622 Words  | 4 Pages

    ...ected its extravagances and exported its ideals to Europe. He certainly did not betray it. As Francois Furet wrote, “He was chosen by the revolution, from which he received his strange power not only to embody a new nation … but also to fulfil its destiny.”

    Read More

  • Louis Riel

    2030 Words  | 5 Pages

    There lived and died a man who we recognize today as the founder of the Province of Manitoba and defender of the rights of the Métis and of French Canadians.

    Read More

  • The Red River Rebellion

    1614 Words  | 4 Pages

    The Red River Colony was changing, but it wasn’t the only one, all of Canada were changing, because in the late 1860s Canada entered a new era and the changes and events that occurred in the Red River was only the beginning of many more conflicts and circumstances to come that would help shape and define this age Canada has entered. Although the Red River Rebellion had ostensibly achieved most of its major objectives, the Metis would soon find themselves at a disadvantage. They would rise yet again for another rebellion called The North-West Rebellion of 1885 to assert their nationality once more.

    Read More

  • The Significance of the North West Rebellion

    861 Words  | 2 Pages

    The political consequences of the Rebellion for the First Nations were burdening starting with the conviction of Poundmaker and Big Bear, continuing the with public hangings of eight First Nations people, and ending with legal shackles meant to keep the people without the ability to fight for themselves or have a voice. By many accounts Poundmaker was the leader of the political attempts to help his people, the Cree, and ensure the government upholds their end of the treaty, stating and proving time and again during the Rebellion that he did not want or support violence. He even claimed that any violence was against their cause. #source*. Poundmaker refused Riel’s offer to fight, but became involved because his tribe was ambushed in the night by the Police and had to defend themselves. In an interview with General Middleton Poundmaker reputed that he was not a part of the planned Rebellion and any fighting they did was in defence of the women and children, points and evidence which are repeatedly rejected by General Middleton. (pg 385/386 mulvany). The entire trial became a witch hunt, where anyone found to associate with the Rebellion is convicted of treas...

    Read More

  • Napoleon Bonaparte Hero or Tyrant?

    679 Words  | 2 Pages

    With such driving momentum, yet unstable, the French in the late 1700’s needed something or someone who was willing to lead their country, unite them, and bring order to their society. In 1799 Napoleon Bonaparte emerged to become that very man. Controversy wells up now a days as people begin to argue whether this man was a hero or tyrant, however I believe him to be a hero for doing exactly what the French needed at the time. He created a legendary domestic system that modified French society and is still used today, his warfare experience and keen sense of tactics revolutionized military then and for years to come and led France to become a dominant nation in the world, and lastly through his many contributions he created a sense of nationalism and identity nothing like the French had ever had before, all of these accomplishments not only bettering France but the world.

    Read More

  • Toussaint L Ouverture Dbq

    771 Words  | 2 Pages

    He was smart leader and used new way of fighting to benefit the revolters overall in the process their fight tactic used was guerilla fighting which was way less formal way of fighting but gave the best result when his skill and aid was advised. Later on in his life after the initial slave emancipation was hearing the unsettling noise of the french they had said the wanted to return/ reinstate slavery(Doc B) but Monsieur Louverture was ready to fight for the right that they fought for before and they are willing and ready to do it again(Doc

    Read More

  • Who Is Armand Van Helden A True Hero?

    445 Words  | 1 Pages

    The art of house music had been mastered by fee and enjoyed by many. Through the last decade, we've experienced the funk, the hypnotic joys and the intrinsic make-up of house and electronic music. Slowly but surely, the majority of the masses ended up hooked and addicted to the jumpy tunes, the out of this world music experience and the tracks started pouring in, leaving amazement on each path. The thriving of house music had been deemed successful, and the growth of artists trying out this genre ballooned, had been strengthened and further solidified their unconscious love for house music. We've witnessed different neophytes ebbed and flowed, some had been disposed after one masterful track, while some stuck on fame due to their incomparable talent and passion to het house music abloom. One of the pillars of house music, and stayed there since, is the tenured Armand Van Helden.

    Read More

  • Maximilien Robespierre, Leader of the French Revolution

    1448 Words  | 3 Pages

    contributed to the execution of King Louis XVI so that French citizens might find a better existence under honest rule. To keep citizens focused on the revolution, he established a

    Read More

  • Absolutism: The Reign Of King Louis XIV

    977 Words  | 2 Pages

    He once lived in poverty, he suffered misfortune, fear humiliation, cold, and hunger at one point also (He had some rough times during his life even though he was king. In 1648 the nobles and Paris Parliament rose against the crown. This marked the beginning of a long French civil war called The Fronde. He would never forgive the nobles, commoners or the Parliament because they had already turned against him once. That event in his life shaped his character and how he would lead the country of France throughout his long rule as king. He wanted to have total control over France because he was worried that the rest of the country would try to raise up against the crown again. This led to him ruling as an absolutist so he could ensure that was not an option. Louis went against tradition and took complete control of the government. He used divine right and absolutism to lead France to a prosperous time during France's rich

    Read More

  • Louis XIV

    1242 Words  | 3 Pages

    Louis the XIV had a commanding presence and used it wisely. In a time of great separation Louis began to try unifying France. While he did have a few faults, his positive change helped France more than any other king could have at that time. Those who feel his few faults are enough to call him a bad king are dwelling on such minor issues and should look at his overall influence on the country. Under his rule, France ranked highest among art, literature, war and statesmanship. Louis XIV had plenty of skill, which is why he was able to bring such great qualities all at once to France.

    Read More

  • An Essay On Louis Riel

    1624 Words  | 4 Pages

    Louis Riel played a big role in Canada and was fighting for the rights of Metis. He was captured and executed by Canadian authorities in November 16, 1885 in Regina. Louis Riel did not receive a fair trial due that he was fighting for the rights of the Metis and people. It was inappropriate to accuse Riel as a traitor. He tried to defend the traditional right of Metis and equal people and dedicated his life to help others like Metis, Native Indians and Western settlers. He gained a lot of respect and was a good leader. Riel was a person who stepped up and was not afraid to tell the government what they needed. He tried to succeed through peaceful methods and bring change into the Canadian government. However, he did not want to take over Canada or start a revolution against Quebec. The Canadian government did not see this and went against him and charged him as a traitor. At this point, English speaking men were against Riel’s beliefs. When Louis Riel tried to get Metis rights and make them equal but the English people did not want to this change and thought that this was obligating treason. Treason expresses someone that is overthrowing the government in power. Many thoughts came up upon the government whether to hang Louis Riel or not. Quebec was concerned that if Riel would be hanged, they would upset the Conservative Party and if they kept him alive, Ontario would be enraged. Many members of the Canadian government believed that Riel was an insane and not responsible but he did not refuse to give up. His plan was equal everyone out and to devise of Canada with many races, such as Catholic and Protestant. Many people respected him and were confident in him. Louis Riel was not a traitor in Canada and did not receive a fair tria...

    Read More

  • Is Napoleon A Tyrant Or A Hero?

    204 Words  | 1 Pages

    I would argue that Napoleon is a tyrant and not a hero because of the way the ruled France. Napoleon is responsible for the deaths of countless amounts of people through wars and battles that he put France through. Wars and battles such as the Battle of Waterloo, the Battle of Austerlitz and the Battle of Borodino had a big impact on France's population and the economy. Speaking about battles, even though people can argue that he was a fantastic military leader, he wasn't very great when he fled and abandoned his fellow troops in Egypt and Russia. Not only is Napoleon responsible for the deaths of hundreds of troops and for fleeing a war because things got too bad, he is also to blame for pushing France into a deeper bankruptcy. He agreed to

    Read More

  • Dominique Francon: The Personification Of The Human Hero

    1233 Words  | 3 Pages

    Dominique Francon is the human personification of inner turmoil and complexity. She is a character who seeks to destroy the one person she has allowed herself to love. She is introduced as a character that lets people walk over her and control her destiny. Her father, Guy Francon, describes her as not even possessing the ability to “behave like a human being” (122). Dominique lives her life freely, not caring about reputations or money. Her life appears to be transparent at times, almost like she is not really living at all. She goes through the motions of working for a paper she despises, writing about a subject she views as despicable. She even states that she holds this job to “have something to do, something more disgusting than many other things I could do. And more amusing” (118). However, her persona changes entirely when she meets Howard Roark. Roark is a man who represents everything Dominique values in life- heroism, nobility, creativity, and individualism- which is why she seeks to destroy him. She wishes to preserve him, along with her values. In a world where she herself can barely survive, Dominique seeks to destroy the one thing she loves, in order to give him salvation.

    Read More

More about Louis Riel as a Hero or Villian

Open Document