Johnson Response To Hope Rhetorical Analysis

550 Words2 Pages

In his response to a woman who wants him to get her son into university, Johnson carefully and effectively responds to this woman by defining what hope is, using logic, and using a judgmental tone. Through these strategies, Johnson is able to be convincing and legitimate. Also, by using these devices, he is able to keep in line . In the beginning of his response, he knows what this mother has in her ; hope. He then goes on to define hope. He defines hope like “pleasures immoderately enjoyed” and how it is made up by “pain”. He is saying how people enjoy hope so much, but the only thing that hope really does is cause pain. Therefore, by this woman requesting this deed, she is setting herself up for disappointment. With this strategy, he is able to let the woman down gently and he is able to explain why her hope was a dangerous feeling for her. While using this strategy, he is able to give a negative connotation to hope, and that it is not him letting her down, it is hope that is letting her down. He is able to take the attention away from himself and put attention to hope, the real enemy here. Another strategy Johnson uses is the use of logic. When addressing the woman’s son, he describes him as a “great man” , but “to whom I never spoke” and “had never seen” . This is an example of logic because he is saying that he …show more content…

In the beginning of his response, he uses a gentle and explanatory tone and then goes on to use logic. However, towards the end of the response, he gets judgemental. By saying that the woman “should have considered what she was asking”, he is putting the blame on the woman. He is making the woman realize what her request was and to make her reflect her own actions, rather than him denying her request. Instead of sugarcoating her like before, he turns into a more critical professional and tells it like it is, that her request is

Open Document