Tradition and the Decline of Professional Standards in Darlington Hall

1067 Words3 Pages

Similarly, Farraday’s control over Darlington Hall also changes Stevens’ idea of English identity by demonstrating the lack of service staff. From the start of the novel, Stevens lets the reader know that he has been unable to hire a perfect staff because no one fits his standards. He admits, “I have a reluctance to change too much of the old ways. But there is no virtue at all in clinging as some do to tradition merely for its own sake … the retaining off unnecessary numbers simply for tradition’s sake — resulting in employees having too much time on their hands — has been an important factor in the sharp decline of professional standards” (Ishiguro 6). Stevens admits that he has a habit of holding on to traditions simply because they are …show more content…

This leaves Stevens to function as one of the few servants left in Darlington Hall that still embody the traditional English identity. As scholar Ryan Trimm mentions, “The irony that, in moving from serving the English aristocrat and amateur diplomat Lord Darlington to being in the employ of the retired American Mr. Farraday, Stevens has in fact changed positions without leaving Darlington Hall” (Trimm 197). Stevens is now forced to perform all of the duties of the different service personnel in hopes that he can keep the dignity of the English butler alive. While Stevens is still the butler of Darlington Hall, he is also now the last remaining symbol of Englishness in a now American space. Stevens is no longer surrounded by the gentlemen of England or the staff members that he had control over. The lack of service personnel within Darlington Hall plays a major role in Stevens’ identity because it isolates him within a space that once represented his …show more content…

During Stevens’ flashbacks to Lord Darlington, he prides himself on how his work of polishing the silver has contributed to the history within Darlington Hall, such as when he impresses Lord Halifax during a meeting at Darlington Hall. However, once Mr. Farraday takes over the house, Stevens loses his ability to properly do his traditional butler duties. He mentions one instance where “[Mr Farraday] had, upon seating himself, simply picked up the fork, examined it for a brief second, touching the prongs with a fingertip, then turned his attention to the morning headlines” 139). While Stevens has experience maintaining a great household, his inability to polish the silver to Farraday’s standards symbolizes how he is unable to keep up with the changes in the modern English society. In this case, the fork also symbolizes Stevens himself. While Farraday does not want to embarrass Stevens, he is compelled to switch the fork because it does not meet his expectations as a dignified butler. Similarly, Stevens also tries to fix this situation by emphasizing the need for more staff members. He explains, “Errors such as these which have occurred over the last few months have been, naturally enough, injurious to one’s self-respect, but then there is no reason to believe them to be signs of anything more sinister than a staff shortage” (Ishiguro 139). While Stevens is able to admit

Open Document