Comparison of Animal Rights Texts

774 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Animal rights vs human rights essays

Comparison of Animal Rights Texts

I am going to compare two pieces of text called: 'It's a crying shame'

and 'Sorry, but I think dying people are more important than dumb

animals,' by an Animal Rights Group and Polly Toynbee respectively.

The first article is intended to appeal to a younger audience who

think that killing animals is wrong because they are cute etc. The

second extract is aimed at adults who are interested in the welfare of

human beings. The Animal Aid leaflet is persuasive as it is trying to

pledge donations to stop animal experiments. The newspaper article is

informative and persuasive by saying that killing an animal to save

humans is good because would you rather die than an insignificant

canine or rat.

The Animal Rights leaflet is very eye catching. It has a colour image

of a dog, which appears to be crying. The size of the text is varied

form size 22 to 9 points and is in the font Arial which is an easier

to read font than Times New Roman. There are three columns in which

text is displayed. They use the colour purple a lot and a sort of

reddish pink colour. Colour images are used well as they portray how

graphic an image is and makes people feel sorry for the animals. The

colour purple is soft and loving and is also eye catching. It will

also attract women who feel strongly for animal rights. The text is in

small chunks making the text easier to read and eye catching, also if

the text is in chunks it seems like less to read.

The newspaper article is very plain and boring, defiantly aimed at the

mature audience. It contains an image of the author, Poly Toynbee, in

black and white and the text is Times New...

... middle of paper ...

....

Poly Toynbee's article uses mainly very blunt and to the point

language. She also uses real life facts and statistics: 'only 5 per

cent of medical research uses animals.' And 'Maybe because only 7 per

cent of the population is vegetarian, so an out-and-out vegetarian war

wouldn't catch the public imagination.' This proves points very well

and gets it to the reader plainly and simply. As before she is trying

to get the reader to approve of her opinions and to simply really care

about human welfare.

Overall, I agree with Poly Toynbee's argument. Personally, I would

much rather survive than a canine or rat. Human life is one of the

most important factors in this millennia's time frame and as the world

is ultimately going to be destroyed we should inhabit it as long as

humanly possible, no matter what the cost…

Show More
Related

  • The Case for Animal Rights

    850 Words  | 2 Pages

    "The Case For Animal Rights" written by Tom Regan, promotes the equal treatment of humans and non-humans. I agree with Regan's view, as he suggests that humans and animals alike, share the experience of life, and thus share equal, inherent value.

    Read More

  • Bruce Weigl's May

    842 Words  | 2 Pages

    In the poem “May” written by Bruce Weigl, the speaker has a sick, suffering dog named May. The speaker is taking May to the veterinarian to be put to sleep. The speaker is sad, but does not want May to suffer anymore. He/she lies into the May’s ear with comforting words as the veterinarian puts her to sleep, ending the pain and suffering.

    Read More

  • Budweiser Someone Waits Ad Analysis

    552 Words  | 2 Pages

    It appeals to the audience emotions because it shows that the dog is more than just a pet to the guy. As the guy leaves with his friends the guy says “see you later buddy” to show the audience that the guy plans on coming back. The music is also very important because as the dog waits the music starts to slow down until the dog finally loses hope and the music stops. Then when the guy walks through the door the happy music starts up. When the black screen and white letters show up it grabs the attention because it interrupts the video and it usually means something important. When the guy arrives he immediately hugs and plays with the dog. It shows that he cares and was also worried about the dog. He then explains to the dog why he didn’t come home that night. He repeats “im back” to show that he is glad that he decided to not drink and

    Read More

  • Persuasive Essay: Drunk Driving

    1018 Words  | 3 Pages

    Article #1 is a very effective piece of propaganda in that it captures the reader?s attention successfully by placing a picture of a dog in the focal point of the article. The dog plays a vital role in this piece of propaganda in that it represents a loved one, family and anything cherished. It shows what could be left behind, if a driver chose to ignore safe driving. The breed of dog is also very important. Choosing a sorrowful dogs face, further enhanced the emotions of the reader, as the article wouldn?t have the same effect if a dangerous dog was shown instead

    Read More

  • Argumentative Essay On Emoji Women

    260 Words  | 1 Pages

    The article Should that frown be upside down? Emojis make the meaning clear By Tracey Lien, Los Angeles Times, you read about the incorporation of the emoji to the dictionary. The article says, “The emoji it singled out — an image of a laughing yellow face crying tears of joy — did not fit most people’s definitions of the word.” This is pointing out that the addition of an image to the dictionary,

    Read More

  • Animals Rights and Religion Analysis

    1223 Words  | 3 Pages

    In his essay “Religion and Animal Rights," the writer Tom Regan maintains the place that animals are "subjects-of-a-life”, like humans. If we value all beings regardless of the degree of human rationality that are able to act, we must also attribute to animals or as it is called non-human animals as well. All practices involving abuse of animals should be abolished. The animals have an intrinsic value as humans, and stresses that Christian theology has brought unbridled land on the brink of an ecological catastrophe.

    Read More

  • Mark Doty's Poem 'Golden Retrievals'

    754 Words  | 2 Pages

    The speaker scans his surroundings, “muck, pond, ditch, residue”(5), spondee, stressed words, are used to show the typical image of a distracted dog. This is further emphasized in the enjambments and caesuras at the hyphens and colons, to express the unpredictable actions of the speaker. At the beginning the speaker includes rhetorical questions, to highlight the merry, short attention span, “Fetch? Balls and sticks capture my attention seconds at a time. Catch? I don’t think so” (1-2). The rhyme scheme is abba ccdd efef gh and often are slant rhymes which shows the dog is not as educated as a human. The vowel ‘o’ in “or else you’re off in some fog concerning/ --tomorrow”(9-10) is an assonance and “bow-wow…”(14), is onomatopoeia illustrates the dog howling and barking at his human.

    Read More

  • Ban a Pit bull, Save a Life: Why the Ontario Ban against Pit bull Terriers Should Remain in Place

    1265 Words  | 3 Pages

    Vancouver Sun. (2007, February 6). Kids' cries woke mom of boy, 3, killed by dogs' bites. Retrieved April 20, 2011, from Canada.com:

    Read More

  • animal rights

    669 Words  | 2 Pages

    In his Meditations, Rene Descartes argues that animals are purely physical entities, having no mental or spiritual substance. Thus, Descartes concludes, animals can’t reason, think, feel pain or suffer. Animals, are mere machines with no consciousness. Use the Internet to explore the issue of animal rights. Investigate the legacy left by Rene Descartes concerning the moral status of animals.

    Read More

  • animal rights

    1959 Words  | 4 Pages

    animals. If they keep the animals, then the animal will be treated as a pet or

    Read More

  • animal rights

    825 Words  | 2 Pages

    For decades, mankind has used animals to progress efficiently in scientific research. Animal testing is important for medical science and other beneficial experiments. Many citizens criticize scientists for testing on animals for unnecessary means other than medical research. Many of today’s current vaccines and disease treatments would have been delayed without the use of animals. People across the globe have been saved through organ transplants by persistent research on animals. Many material products and medical accomplishments people take for granted wouldn’t have been possible without animal testing.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of The Fourth State Of Matter

    861 Words  | 2 Pages

    This can be seen in the first paragraph, “ We used to call her the face of love”. Using the word, we in this sentence means that Beard and her husband were still together at that point in time. Furthermore, the name of the dog, “ The face of love”, representing the young lover's excitement for one another. A love like a new puppy, always exciting, and no matter the situation it never seems that heavy a burden. Then with age problems begin to arise, small inconveniences seem like a bigger problem than they are, causing a wedge to grow between husband and wife. Beard when seeing her collie in the middle of the night thinking, the face of love, reminds her of how times used to be when her husband was still at home. The comparison between dog and husband is seen again when Beard talks with Chris, her colleague, who asks her “Why are you letting this go one?” (Beard. J. A., June 24, 1996, Para. 35). This can be interpreted as Chris asking about the phone calls Beard’s husband leaves, or about the collie. Beard responds by saying she isn’t letting it go on (Beard. J. A., June 24, 1996, Para. 36). When she isn’t doing anything, she's waiting for the problem to solve itself; for times to go back to what they were. Beard is scared to let go of her collie, her last real tie to what her marriage

    Read More

  • The Importance of Setting in Jack London's To Build A Fire

    1451 Words  | 3 Pages

    feelings in the man and the dog, of a constant battle with this world of

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Tom Regan's Animal Rights Human Wrongs

    1052 Words  | 3 Pages

    In Tom Regan’s article “Animal Rights, Human Wrongs,” he explores three different philosophical “accounts” and talks about their view and stances on animal rights and the treatment of animals. The first account that Regan looks at is the Kantian account, which is that humans have obligations to treat animals right only because if humans treated animals poorly it would lead to humans treating one another poorly. Regan says this account to be amiss because it makes us assume that animal interests do not matter and that we are not concerned with the poor treatment of the animal, yet instead we are concerned with the effect the action will have on humans in the future. The second account that Regan analyzes is the cruelty account, which revolves

    Read More

  • A Dark Brown Dog by Stephen Crane

    768 Words  | 2 Pages

    Ones take of this story can be many of sorts. The dog essential may have saved this young child, his father may have chosen to throw him out the window. If the dog wasn’t there to take his place, who is to say what could had happened? It also shows how the dogs undeniable, love, devotion and eagerness to please his master. Eventually these traits, sadly left him resting lifeless in his young master’s arms. The relationships between these characters, is one of who’s pulling the strings. The abuse has been passed down from father to son. This story leaves an emptiness, with the unsettling turn of events.

    Read More

More about Comparison of Animal Rights Texts

Open Document