Comparing Dehumanization In 'The Machine Stops And Modern Times'

808 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Effect of technology on people's lives

Afsana Habib
603-HSD-VA
Section 00002

Essay

Man has constructed numerous inventions, each more resourceful than the previous one. The two works, “The Machine Stops” (1909) by E.M. Forster and Charlie Chaplin’s film Modern Times (1936) share the common ground of the expansion of technology however putting mankind in danger. Machinery should only help humans progress rather than creating a disaster or a gap among them. Men lose in the long run seeing that machines evolve, revealing that men are less resilient than machinery. As demonstrated in the two works, the use of machinery can create a dependence upon it, further lead to humanity’s dehumanization and take you to the brink of insanity. …show more content…

Chaplin criticizes the effects of technology and shows it through a comical level. For instance, the opening scene shows a flock of sheep, being herded into their pen followed by a scene of workers rushed out of a subway. This portrays them to be as such; innocent men caught in the traps of an industrialized society. However, Chaplin is that one black sheep that attempts to escapes from the sheep and machine like behaviour.The power of advancement is also portrayed in this film. One of the scenes show the boss agreeing to a demonstration of the automated lunch feeder, in hopes of cutting costs of lunch breaks. The machine fails and forcefully feeds Chaplin bolts that were accidentally left on the tray. This suggests that he is literally forced to consume progress. The device demolishes him by compelling him to consume its own parts. Further on, Chaplin gets caught in the machine, running smoothly between the gears. He is once again devoured by the machine, unable to defend himself from the Industrial age. Chaplin can be characterized as a product of industrialization as opposed to the man he

Show More
Related

  • Analysis Of Dehumanized By Mark Slouka

    827 Words  | 2 Pages

    “Dehumanized” by Mark Slouka explores the issue of our nation’s education and how science and math are being used to primarily teach students about business and capitalism. Although I believe that students should have a good understanding of economics for the sake of their future. I, like Mark Slouka, believe that the humanities should be taught and accepted in our schools to help students further their education.

    Read More

  • Dehumanization In Fahrenheit 451

    1260 Words  | 3 Pages

    When a community attempts to promote social order by ridding society of controversial ideas and making every citizen equal to every other, the community becomes dystopian. Although dystopian societies intend to improve life, the manipulation of thoughts and actions, even when it is done out of the interest of citizens, often leads to the dehumanization of people. In Ray Bradbury’s Fahrenheit 451, Montag, the main character, lives in a dystopian society that has been so overly simplified and homogenized, in order to promote social order, that the citizens exist as thoughtless beings. The lack of individual thinking, deficit of depth and knowledge, and the loss of true living is what has transformed Montag’s city into a dystopia and made the

    Read More

  • Dehumanization In Night Essay

    705 Words  | 2 Pages

    When the author of Night, Elie Wiesel, arrives at Auschwitz, the Jewish people around him, the Germans, and himself have yet to lose their humanity. Throughout the holocaust, which is an infamous genocide that imprisoned many Jewish people at concentration camps, it is clear that the horrors that took place here have internally affected all who were involved by slowly dehumanizing them. To be dehumanized means to lose the qualities of a human, and that is exactly what happened to both the Germans and the Jewish prisoners. Wiesel has lived on from this atrocious event to establish the dehumanization of all those involved through his use of animal imagery in his memoir Night to advance the theme that violence dehumanizes both the perpetrator

    Read More

  • Nickel and Dimed: On (Not) Getting By In America, by Barbara Ehrenreich

    652 Words  | 2 Pages

    Ehrenreich draws quickly upon Marx when formulating the rules for her experiment, “…I had to take the highest-paying job that was offered me and do my best to hold it; no Marxist rants or sneaking off to read novels in the ladies’ room” (Ehrenreich, 2001), and while her only reference to revolution is the 1989 “Velvet Revolution by Frank Zappa” (Ehrenreich, 2001 p.37-38), she effectively attempts to stage a revolution of her own when Holly, one of her co-worker’s at a cleaning service, injures her ankle on the job (2001p.110-111). Though her attempt to get Holly to rebel against her manager and seek medical attention ultimately fails, her values could not have been made more clear. She clearly stands with the humanity of the worker and will call for the overthrow any authority that denies th...

    Read More

  • Dehumanization In The Book Night

    743 Words  | 2 Pages

    In the story Night by Elie Wiesel, dehumanization occurs through the loss of religious belief. While in the concentration camps, Elie's friends and family suffer each and every day. He prays to God every night but he soon questions why God has not helped even one time through the suffering.

    Read More

  • Quotes On Dehumanization In 1984

    1448 Words  | 3 Pages

    Throughout our history, the government has used spying to control humans, therefore dehumanizing them in order to get and keep power. In 1984 by George Orwell, The Party controls the past, the present, and the future through the records in the Ministry of Love. The Ministry of Love burns all accounts of the past, therefore the citizens of Oceania don’t know anything different about the present than what the Party tells them. The Party keeps the people in Oceania clueless about everything in their society. If the Party says something is the way it is, then that is what it is. The Party is ultimate truth. The government just wants their citizens to love Big Brother, so they can have power over them. The Party does this by making sex only about

    Read More

  • Analysis Of August 2026 There Will Come Soft Rains

    1495 Words  | 3 Pages

    Use of technology is expanding from day to day, more things in life are depending on machinery. Machines are meant to bring us a comfortable life, and technology is meant to enhance our living standard, yet. Half a century ago, Ray Bradbury issued an enlightenment in the short story “August 2026: There Will Come Soft Rain”. In E. M. Forster’s “The Machine Stops”, a similar enlightenment is made. Both edify people that things will go wrong when technology is dominant over humanity; our dependence on technology lead people lost humanity, lead people lost control of human creation, and eventually lead humanity to devastate. The didactic works at the level of form in Bradbury, while in Forester is works at the level of content.

    Read More

  • Ray Bradbury Use Of Technology

    1767 Words  | 4 Pages

    Ray Bradbury is a well-known author for his outstanding fictional works. In every story he has written throughout his career, readers will quickly begin to notice a repeating pattern of him creating an excellent story revolving around technology. However, unlike how we perceive technology as one of the greatest inventions ever created and how much they have improved our everyday lives, Bradbury predicts serious danger if we let technology become too dominant. “Marionettes Inc.” and “The Veldt” are two short stories written by Bradbury that use multiple literature elements to warn society the dangerous future if technology claims power. In “Marionettes Inc.” two men, Braling and Smith explain to each other the hardships they must deal with their

    Read More

  • 1984 Dehumanization Analysis

    949 Words  | 2 Pages

    In 1984, George Orwell presents an overly controlled society that is run by Big Brother. The protagonist, Winston, attempts to “stay human” in the face of a dehumanizing, totalitarian regime. Big Brother possesses so much control over these people that even the most natural thoughts such as love and sex are considered taboo and are punishable. Big Brother has taken this society and turned each individual against one another. Parents distrust their own offspring, husband and wife turn on one another, and some people turn on their own selves entirely. The people of Oceania become brainwashed by Big Brother. Punishment for any uprising rebellions is punishable harshly.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Ray Bradbury's 'The Veldt And August 2026'

    1171 Words  | 3 Pages

    Today’s world is full of robots that vacuum the floor and cars that talk to their drivers. People can ask their phones to send a text or play a song and a cheerful voice will oblige. Machines are taking over more and more tasks that are traditionally left to people, such as cleaning, navigating, and even scheduling meetings. In a world where technology is becoming increasingly human, questions arise about whether machines will eventually replace humankind altogether. In Ray Bradbury’s short stories, “The Veldt” and “August 2026,” he presents themes that technology will not only further replace the jobs of humans, but it will also outlast humankind as a whole. Although this is a plausible future, computers just cannot do certain human jobs.

    Read More

  • Tomainia In The Film 'The Great Dictator'

    910 Words  | 2 Pages

    Chaplin talks about how the good qualities

    Read More

  • Tramp And The Great Depression

    456 Words  | 1 Pages

    Chaplin utilizes his performance as the Tramp character to illustrate the hardships that the upper class brought to the working class. In his dancing scene, Chaplin presents a series of gestures that relay to the audience the various perspectives of those living under the Great Depression. Through his gestures, he creates caricatures of those affected by the Great Depression: specifically those who are benefitting and those who are suffering. Chaplin’s Tramp character depicts the stereotypical boss of a company by making a motion that suggests a large belly, a mustache and amusement. In his selection of characteristics unique to this stereotype, Chaplin’s character imparts the idea that the bosses are fat, as they have generated enough income

    Read More

  • The Great Dictator by Charles Chaplin

    1556 Words  | 4 Pages

    As evident from “The Great Dictator” in its entirety, Charlie Chaplin was a fantastic writer and speaker. He had successfully convinced his audience that change is possible through his choice of words and charisma. This speech is nothing short of motivational and has many characteristics within it that would help people understand his point of view and also come into agreement with him, those being ethos, organization, and pathos in particular. Although this was given several decades ago, it remains relatable today in terms of how things like money and power have blinded people and caused so much misery and destruction for the benefit of a few.

    Read More

  • Death Of A Salesman American Dream Essay

    762 Words  | 2 Pages

    Throughout his life, Willy Loman remains stuck in the proletariat class, while endlessly striving to earn and have more. Willy works tirelessly toward retirement, but nevertheless falls short in the finance department. When Willy’s boss, Howard, tells Willy he won’t give him an office job with the company, Willy causes a scene, shouting, in attempts to stay employed. Willy truly believes he helped make the business what it is today and therefore deserves to stay with the company, rather than be let go for unproductivity. Willy is absolutely devastated by Howard’s refusal, which leaves him unable to provide for his family.

    Read More

  • Modernism And Modernism

    929 Words  | 2 Pages

    Towards the end of the nineteenth century, around 1860 after man had considerably conquered the machine, a new reality became prevalent in the lives of the newly industrialised world. “Modernism includes more than just art and literature. By now it includes almost the whole of what is truly alive in our culture”(Greenberg 1982:5) This quote can be applied to the earlier days of modernism When jobs had changed from agricultural based employment to corporate and menial based labour. Housing situations had too changed, from rural to urban, as people began to follow the money trail the industrial revolution had left behind. All this change had brought a new way of life for the western world, as things became automated and products were readily available to the con...

    Read More

More about Comparing Dehumanization In 'The Machine Stops And Modern Times'

Open Document