Comparative Essay

1021 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Holocaust explanatory essay

Vladek and Guido use their skills and intelligence to endure a genocide that killed over 6 million Jews and 11 million people in total. Although sadly Guido did not make it through the Holocaust, his wife Dora and Son Giosué survived, thanks to the help of Guido. Vladek survived by using his many talents in the prison camps whereas Guido survived by his cunning intelligence and positive attitude. In the Books Maus I and II by Art Spiegelman, the author uses his fathers story of survival to create a book that unleashes vivid imagery of Vladeks time in Auschwitz, in addition to how it has affected him since. In the movie Life Is Beautiful Directed by Roberto Benigni, Guido was an average Jewish man living in Italy. When his family got taken to a Natzi death camp he managed to keep his son Giosué hidden, while doing so he jeopardized his own life. Both of these works display two brave men withstanding the worst race extermination in history.
Vladek was a polish Jew who later fell in love with a woman named Anja, just as Guido fell in love with Dora. Vladek, living in poland, starts to hear news of the Nazi’s uprising. As Poland was beginning to fall under the control of the Nazi’s, Vladek and his family tried to escape Poland but are tricked and sent to Auschwitz. “It was many, many such stories – synagogues burned, Jews beaten with no reason, whole towns pushing out all Jews – each story worse than the other.” (Maus I pg 35) Just as Vladek had lost his textile factory due to the Nazi’s, Guido’s book shop had been labeled a Jewish store. Both Guido and Vladek suffered through the train ride to the concentration camps. Vladek was incredibly smart and hung out on a beam at the top of the train car. He had access to fresher air and the...

... middle of paper ...

...eautiful they both show two brave men going through the Holocaust and their journey to freedom. These two stories of bravery, hopefulness and love have transformed the way the way in which a Holocaust story can be told. Both stories had their own way of portraying the horror of the Holocaust. Art used animals to convey characters in the comic, while director Roberto Benigni used comedy and lightheartedness to show a beautiful story of horror. Both of these stories had similarities and of course differences yet one similarity stood out; love is endless. Giosué will forever be grateful to have had a dad who sacrificed himself for the life and future of his son, just as Art will be knowing how strong Vladek was and that although they weren’t too close his dad loved him. Both stories contained a unique father-son relationship that is incredibly powerful to the viewer.

Show More
Related

  • Grendel Compare And Contrast Essay

    1268 Words  | 3 Pages

    The differences and similarities between the traditional version of the Epic Beowulf and the modern version, Beowulf and Grendel, makes passages for characters such as Grendel to be changed due to the time frame in between the film and the epic.There are several characters that stood out from the film, as they are portrayed in the epic as something completely different than in the movie. Grendel is one of the few that stood out the most.

    Read More

  • Night, by Elie Wiesel’s, and Roberto Begnini’s film Life is Beautiful Show Sufferig of the Holocaust

    721 Words  | 2 Pages

    The Holocaust was one of the darkest times in history. Both Night, by Elie Wiesel’s, and Roberto Begnini’s film Life is Beautiful, are set in the time period of the Holocaust. The Holocaust is portrayed very differently in the two pieces. Night has a much more serious tone. It tells how it really was. Life is Beautiful has a happier tone. It uses humor to explain what is happening. Night and Life is Beautiful are similar in the strong emphasis on the father-son bonds formed in each. Also, even though they were written in the same time period, the way that they portray the Holocaust is very different. Lastly, in each the boys are affected by what happened to Jews during the Holocaust. These pieces present themselves as powerfully magnificent and moving, but when it comes to the question of which is more effective in telling the story of the Holocaust, the answer is simple. Night.

    Read More

  • Metaphor Compare Contrast Essay

    712 Words  | 2 Pages

    Two people could be living two very different lifestyles, yet they could be very similar in the way they act and react in the same situation. Charlotte from “The Metaphor” by Budge Wilson and the Mother character from “Borders” by Thomas King live very different lives but the way they deal with the problems they are faced with is very similar. Both protagonists have to deal with trying to be forced to be something they are not by society and their families, but Charlotte from “The Metaphor” has been challenged by her strenuous home, she must face her organized mother and orderly home; the Mother from “Borders” must stand up for what she believes in and fight for what she wants.

    Read More

  • Sacrifice In Roberto Benigni's Life Is Beautiful

    764 Words  | 2 Pages

    Roberto Benigni, the director of Life is Beautiful (1997), explores the sacrifice of people during war . Through the use of Foreshadowing, Mood, and Characterization, film audiences are challenged to Imagine the struggles of the those in the holocaust.

    Read More

  • Comparison Essay

    1007 Words  | 3 Pages

    Prince Henry of Portugal, more commonly known as Henry the Navigator, and Zheng He, a successful Chinese admiral, were both extremely accomplished men throughout the 14th and 15th centuries. During this era, many accomplished explorers ventured out into the ocean and discovered new lands, two of the most important men being Henry the Navigator and Zheng He. Although both men came from different backgrounds, their contrasting societies and structures affected the way in which they regarded economic and political expansion and also their contact with other cultures. Societies like the Chinese and Portuguese had many cultural differences such as their different religions. The Chinese practiced neo-Confucianism whereas the Portuguese were Christians which was one of the many purposes of their exploration, to spread Christianity. There were also many cultural similarities between the two societies such as their long lasting histories and their explorer’s curiosity to seek out to new lands, which resulted the two societies in having different views on economic and political expansion and contact with other cultures. Both Confucian and Christian ideologies favored those who worked over the wealthy. Thus, to a larger extent, the structures and values of a society have an extensive impact on the way people view economic and political expansion and contact with other cultures.

    Read More

  • Maus and the Holocaust

    839 Words  | 2 Pages

    The Holocaust took a great toll on many lives in one way or another, one in particular being Vladek

    Read More

  • Vladek Spiegelman Character Analysis

    513 Words  | 2 Pages

    Vladek lived a normal life before the war, got married to Anja a daughter of a millionaire. He also got Richieu his first son. They all lived a happy life for awhile until the Swastika was raised as an emblem of the German Nazi party. That’s when the fairytale ended. Vladek went to the army and got captured by the Nazi. Back to luckiness, he could easily died at the P.O.W camp, disease, hunger or even get beat up by the Nazi. On page 48, the bullets came in his direction, the bullet ricochet on his helmet, he could have died if the soldier aim better or if he didn’t have the helmet, he could have easily been dead. Being resourceful also helped him in the war. On page 53, he bathed in the river in the winter, unlike his soldier mates, he didn’t get infection on his frostbites.

    Read More

  • Comparativism Essay

    713 Words  | 2 Pages

    Relativism can be hard to understand. It’s in our nature as human beings to base thing off of the knowledge we already know. Relativism is the idea that, when faced with another culture, we must try to comprehend it instead of judging it based on our own culture’s values and morals. Human rights advocates opposing the tradition of female genital modification (FGM) is an example of relativism (page 30). Female genital modification can include the removal of the clitoris or a process in which the female anatomy is modified in such a way that constricts the vaginal opening. Both procedures reduce female sexual pleasure and, it is believed to prevent the likelihood of adultery. Although a tradition in societies in Africa and the Middle East, human

    Read More

  • Chris Mccandless Compare And Contrast Essay

    756 Words  | 2 Pages

    Christopher McCandless and Adam Shepard both did some similar targets in their lives, at the end it lead them to unexpected situations. Christopher McCandless was a young man who didn't believe in society and he chose to get away from that and left everything he had, including his family. He developed important relationships with key people that helped him on his journey into the wild. Similarly Adam Shepard was a young man who left with only $25 and a sleeping bag to go prove his point that the american dream does exist and to see if he can achieve it in a couple of months. Overall comparing McCandless and Shepard, Christopher McCandless had a greater impact in people, motivated many, and was selfish in plenty of good ways.

    Read More

  • Roberto Benigni's Use Of Comedy In 'Life Is Beautiful'

    1171 Words  | 3 Pages

    Life is beautiful is a film about a man named Guido Orefice, his wife Dora, his son Giosuè, and Guido’s uncle Eliseo. His family is sent to a concentration camp. Guido uses his humor to hide the horror of the camp by playing a game with his son. Critics of the film say that the film is not showing the full picture of the holocaust. Proponents of the film said that the film is portraying the Holocaust, this way to have a broader audience. Roberto Benigni’s use of comedy is effective in portraying the Holocaust, while other work of writers about the Holocaust are grim, Benigni is about comedy.

    Read More

  • The Aftermath of the Holocaust in Art Spiegelman’s Maus Volumes I and II

    1130 Words  | 3 Pages

    By means of comic illustration and parody, Art Spiegelman wrote a graphic novel about the lives of his parents, Vladek and Anja, before and during the Holocaust. Spiegelman’s Maus Volumes I and II delves into the emotional struggle he faced as a result of his father’s failure to recover from the trauma he suffered during the Holocaust. In the novel, Vladek’s inability to cope with the horrors he faced while imprisoned, along with his wife’s tragic death, causes him to become emotionally detached from his son, Art. Consequently, Vladek hinders Art’s emotional growth. However, Art overcomes the emotional trauma his father instilled in him through his writing.

    Read More

  • Essay On Vladek Spiegelman

    546 Words  | 2 Pages

    Vladek Spiegelman has clearly not fully recovered from the horrors of the Holocaust. One of the ways in which Vladek Spiegelman does not survive is the way he becomes so obsessed and conservative when it comes to food or money matters. He never wastes anything, no matter how small. After Mala Spiegelman, his wife, leaves him, Vladek Spiegelman goes to the supermarket, to return foods she left behind.Vladek Spiegelman wants to return opened and partially eaten food. After much frustration from both the store manager and himself, Vladek returns successful, remarking, “I exchanged and got six dollars worth of new groceries for only one dollar!” (250). He tries to return old food even though it is not allowed, but uses his past as an excuse. The store manager, wanting to avoid the topic of what society owes Holocaust survivors, accommodates his needs, wanting to appease him. Being a prisoner at a concentration camp alters Vladek Spiegelman's personality, making him obsessive, stingy, and unable to trust others. This alters his life and relationships with his loved

    Read More

  • Comparison and Contrast Essay

    755 Words  | 2 Pages

    Some people think that if they could only change one aspect of their lives, it would be perfect. They do not realize that anything that is changed could come with unintended consequences. “The Monkey’s Paw” by W.W. Jacobs and “The Third Wish” by Joan Aiken both illustrate this theme. They demonstrate this by granting the main character three wishes, but with each wish that is granted, brings undesirable consequences. The main idea of this essay is to compare and contrast “The Monkey’s Paw” and “The Third Wish.” Although the “The Monkey’s Paw” and “The Third Wish” are both fantasies and have similar themes, they have different main characters, wishes, and resolutions.

    Read More

  • The impact of survivor’s guilt in Art Spiegelman’s Maus

    699 Words  | 2 Pages

    The comic implies that surviving the holocaust affects Vladek’s life and wrecks his relationship with his son and his wife. In some parts of the story, Vladek rides a stationary bike while narrating his story (I, 81, panel 7-9). Given the fact that it is a stationary bike, it stays immobile: no matter how hard Vladek pedals, he cannot move forward. The immobility of the bike symbolizes how survivor’s guilt will never let him escape his past. Vladek can never really move past the holocaust: he cannot even fall asleep without shouting from the nightmares (II, 74, panel 4-5). Moreover, throughout the story, the two narrators depict Vladek before, during and after the war. Before the war, Vladek is characterized as a pragmatic and resourceful man. He is resourceful as he is able to continue his black business and make money even under the strengthened control of the Nazi right before the war (I, 77 panel 1-7). However, after surviving the holocaust, Vladek feels an obligation to prove to himself and to others that his survival was not simply by mere luck, but because h...

    Read More

  • COmparison and Contrast Essay

    793 Words  | 2 Pages

    Both the films, The Blind Side and Rudy, address many common issues. Two in particular that stand out are education and sports. Both Michael Oher and Daniel Ruettiger (Rudy) pursue their education in order to follow their dreams. In these cases, both dreamed of becoming college football players. The long journeys they take to reach their goals bring out each characters motivation and dedication to get to the top.

    Read More

More about Comparative Essay

Open Document