Cahn's Argument Analysis

484 Words1 Page

My disclaimer in answering this question must start with the elimination of the word “if.” There is no doubt in mind that God exists. My answer would have to begin with God exists and murder is immoral. Cahn (2014) argues that “what is right is independent of what God commands” (p.52). The word of God is absolute and is the beginning and end. The Commandments are not a belief as Cahn (2014) suggests, but it is the direct word of God. It is not merely a social norm but God’s law. He is the creator so it is irrelevant in the argument that Cahn (2014) makes when he asks if murder is wrong because God says it is wrong or is wrong because it is wrong. I am not a person who has blind faith without any thought to reason, however true believers in

Open Document