Avoiding Physical Punishment In Child Rearing
opinion Essay
1310 words
Avoiding Physical Punishment In Child Rearing
Is "sparing the rod" spoiling or saving the child? Is violence, resentment, anger or fear worth the risk taken when striking him or her. Whether your for or against using physical punishment in child development, as a parent, you will someday have to face this issue. Many parents are taught this method in their childhood, and are not aware of any other way. Often originating from religion, physical or corporal punishment is seen as an important ingredient in child rearing. This tool is used to accomplish total authority by the parent and to receive total submission from the child. Physical punishment may be convenient and achieve temporary conformance, but produces negative results, and should be avoided.
HISTORICALLY
Punishment dates back to early human history. To maintain the laws that were created for social living, penalties were developed for the individuals who could not abide by them. Authoritarianism changed the reasons behind punishment; instead of protecting society from the criminal, it became a way for the "Chiefs to control the Indians." It placed the leaders above everyone else, preventing the people's opinions from counting; an antidemocratic society. As illustrated by Dreikurs and Grey, "Those in command were superior and therefore right; those whom they ruled were inferior and therefore wrong if they disagreed with the rulers" (66).
Physical punishment has been approved in history as "the role of authority," as a declaration of power. Penelope Leach states, "Physical punishment was once an accepted part of any relationship that gave one individual legitimate authority over others - master over slave, servant or wife; officer over lower ranks; law en...
... middle of paper ...
...
of Children: Clarifying the Issues". The Journal for the Scientific Study of
Religion v35, n1 (1996): 1-16.
Greven, Philip. Spare the Child. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1991.
Grey, Loren. Discipline Without Fear: Child Training During the Early School
Years. New York: Hawthorn Books Inc., 1974.
Leach, Penelope. Children First: What Society must do - and is not doing - for
Children Today. New York: Vintage Books, 1994.
Reibstein, Larry. "The Debate over Discipline". Newsweek Spring-Summer
1997: 64.
"Sparing the Rod to Save the Child". Editorial. New Statesman and Society.
24 June 1994: 5.
Spock, Benjamin and Micheal B. Rothenberg. Dr. Spock's Baby and Child Care.
New York: Dutton, 1992.
Straus, Murray. Beating the Devil Out of Them: Corporal Punishment in American
Families and Its Effects on Children. Boston: Lexington Books, 1994.
In this essay, the author
- Opines that physical or corporal punishment is an important ingredient in child rearing. it is used to accomplish total authority by the parent and to receive total submission from the child.
- Analyzes leach, penelope, children first: what society must do and is not doing for children.
- Explains that punishment dates back to early human history. authoritarianism placed the leaders above everyone else, preventing the people's opinions from counting.
- Opines that to be more effective in child rearing, we must first realize the undesired results that can come from using physical punishment.
- Explains the "law of reinforcement," "time-out", "immobilization" and "logical or natural consequences."
Related
- explanatory
- analytical
- opinion
- comparative
- Corporal Punishment in American Homesexplanatory essayIn Upper Darby, Pennsylvania, a twenty-six year old mother has been in jail for more than a month for giving her eight-year-old son a black eye. The incident happened on December 4th of 2009, and according to the young boy, Mrs. Jennifer Huber was planning on spanking him and his siblings because someone broke the toilet seat.
In this essay, the author
- Explains that a twenty-six-year-old woman in upper darby, pennsylvania, has been jailed for giving her son black eyes. the incident happened on december 4th of 2009, and according to the young boy, mrs.
- Analyzes how a spanking for the huber boys was not going to teach them to never break anything else, but rather address what they broke in the moment.
- Explains that mrs. huber, like other parents, deals with the hard decision of disciplining their child. the use of physical punishment in american homes led to aggression, long-term health issues, and eroded family relationships.
- Explains that corporal punishment can affect a child's long-term behavior. discipline is used to mold and teach kids how to behave, which will eventually prepare them for society.
- Explains that many parents spank their misbehaving child and expose their child to random acts of violence.
- Explains that a research conducted in tanzania, africa interviewed over 400 kids between grades 2 and 7 about physical punishment. nine percent of children had higher-than-normal levels of hyperactivity.
- Explains that studies have linked physical punishment to aggression and criminal behavior, and that corporal punishment contributed to delinquent behaviors such as theft and murder.
- Explains that children who are punished through hitting learn from their parents that important things can be communicated through corporal punishment, which leads them to think it is okay to be violent.
- Opines that if parents show kindness, children will have a reason to behave well on their own. parents need to display positive actions so the child knows to follow in those footsteps.
- Explains that corporal punishment can lead to a violent child who may struggle with mental health issues later on in life.
- Explains that depression occurs in many children when anger is repressed. the inflicted pain caused by corporal punishment is too much for a child to handle.
- Explains that physical punishment can be a frightening and traumatic experience for many children. parents spank their children when they see them doing something bad.
- Explains that children are hit without proper explanation of why they deserve the punishment; they develop poor self-esteem and this can make it difficult for them to adjust socially in school.
- Explains that spanked children may feel disconnected from society and have a hard time adjusting. many children will try therapy to fix or at least deal with the problems that may have occurred many years ago.
- Explains that there are alternative forms of discipline for which a parent may use and see positive results. a majority of children disagree with the use of corporal punishment.
- Explains that healthy parent-child relationships consist of affection, communication, and quality time. children's relationships with their parents may be damaged by corporal punishment.
- Opines that a relationship grows more and more as parents spend time with their child, especially in the younger years, where most of the discipline takes place.
- Opines that spanking a child will result in the child losing trust and respect for their parent.
- Opines that when the home becomes an unhealthy environment to live in, the child will eventually go off and live with friends, complete strangers or end up in the streets. most kids will run away because the relationship they hold with their parent is just unbearable.
- Opines that children who will become adults have trust issues and will most likely not want to get to close to another person.
- Explains that corporal punishment has a huge impact on children's lives, from their emotions to their psychological well-being, and relationships.
- Cites gates, sara. "spanking children & mental health: punishment linked to disorders later in life." huffington post.
- Explains ng, desmond, "don't slap that kid." healthxchange. n.p., n.d.
- Cites waters, rob, "healthday." corporal punishment and trauma. n.p., n.d.
1385 wordsRead More - Spanking Is Effective Punishmentanalytical essayWhen someone goes through punishment, whether it is a fine, penalty, or confinement for adults or the removal or denial of something that is desirable and pleasant for a child, the disciplinary actions taken can have a huge impact on the individual’s mental psychological state. Whether the punishment is carried out by the law system or in a social setting within family, people have argued and protested over the many forms of punishments that are being utilized today for both adults and children. With so many issues that surround child abuse and the penal system’s disciplinary actions on prisoners, the need for change is critical to ensure that the psychological state of the individuals that are being punished are affected in a positive way rather
In this essay, the author
- Opines that disciplinary actions can have a huge impact on the individual's mental psychological state.
- Explains that physical punishment on children shows a higher level of aggression against their parents, siblings, peers, and later spouses.
- Argues that the older generation was looking for a quicker and effective way to manage bad behavior thus resulting in physical punishment.
- Explains that using more effective methods such as time-outs and negotiations, teaches children to become more reasonable on how they behave and utilize methods in making better decisions as they grow older.
- Analyzes how solitary confinement in the penal system can have a negative psychological effect on adults who are not in prison.
- Explains that society's view on corporal punishment remains controversial because of the questions that surround the limits of where that fine line is drawn that justifies physical discipline or physical abuse.
- Analyzes the relationship between the public support for the death penalty and the nationwide declines in executions and new death sentences.
- Explains that school corporal punishment can have a positive impact on future crimes and punishments. people believe in the virtues of punishment because of cognitive dissonance.
- Explains that spanking is an alternative to hitting and that assaults can land people in jail. studies show that children who were hit identify with the aggressor and are more likely to become hitters themselves.
- Analyzes how the affluenza teen, ethan anthony couch, was never disciplined by his parents and was unable to link his actions with consequences because of their teaching that wealth buys privileges.
1918 wordsRead More - The Importance Of Corporal Punishmentanalytical essayThroughout time parents have used corporal punishment to discipline their children. Some people believe that corporal punishment is the best and fastest way to discipline them. Do parents that use corporal punishment to discipline, educating their children or instilling fear in them? Spanking or hitting a child might make them stop doing an undesired action or behavior, but they are not stopping because they know what they were doing was wrong; they are stopping because they are afraid of getting hit again. The use of corporal punishment only helps the parents make the child stop an action the parents see undesirable, but it does not help the child 's mental health. Victims of corporal punishment end up having psychological problems throughout
In this essay, the author
- Explains that parents have used corporal punishment to discipline their children, but it does not help the child's mental health.
- Explains why parents spank their children to show that it is fine for the person in charge to use violence to get what they want and that violence is part of a relationship.
- Explains that people that have anxiety or depression might have developed mental illnesses because of their parent's method of discipline. emotional security theories suggest that children who experience violent parenting may feel that the relationship they have with their parents is how relationships with other people will be.
- Explains that prospective and history cohort studies show that physical punishment during childhood increases the peril of alcohol quandaries when the child is older.
- Explains that being spanked as a child may cause the person to have problems in social environments, such as asking questions in school or socializing with other people.
- Analyzes how corporal punishment affects a child's ability to learn, thus, affecting his or her progress in school. it is hypothesized that spanking before age two, may cause the child to have behavioral problems four years later.
- Explains that children misbehave whenever their parents are not present. the parents never teach the child wrong from right but to fear ity figure in the room.
- Analyzes how people who were spanked frequently as children are desensitized to violence and see it as the only way to solve their problems.
- Explains that corporal punishment is one of the oldest ways to raise children, but it is ineffective in the sense that it only works to make the child stop the undesired behavior at the moment.
1285 wordsRead More - Persuasive Essay On Disciporal Punishmentexplanatory essayIt is effective in a way that children would know how to manage their own behavior to a certain situation, and they may know what is right and wrong. If ever the punishment has gone beyond discipline and turned out to violence, the child’s capability of doing the things that he/she does could be discriminated nor humiliated. The frequent use of punishment may disengage into acting younger. According to Lodhi & Siddiqui (2014), corporal punishment leave scars in the memories of children which are unforgettable and unhealed. The child’s development of anti-social behavior may possibly occur. Lowering of self-esteem can be a factor leading to a child’s perception that he/she is a bad person. Punishment involves a negative experience for the child that occurs after they have done a certain action, which the adult condemns. (Lodhi, M.S., & Siddiqui, J.A.,
In this essay, the author
- Explains that corporal punishment is a traditional practice of imposing pain, which is commonly used by parents towards children to remove an unpleasant behavior.
- Explains that disciplined punishment is effective in a way that children know how to manage their own behavior, and they may know what is right and wrong. the frequent use of punishment may disengage into acting younger.
- Explains that exposing children to physical, psychological, and emotional torture is not helpful, in accordance with their development.
- Explains coleman's definition of reasonable corporal punishment based on normative understandings and scientific evidence of capacity and functional impairment.
996 wordsRead More - The Use of Corporal Punishmentanalytical essayProverbs 13:24 in the New King James version of the bible states that “He who spares his rod hates his son: but he that loves him disciplines him promptly.” The Nelson study bible goes into more detail and states that a parent’s loving discipline is modeled after God’s loving correction. The list of pros and cons relating to corporal punishment can be very different for each individual and is defined as physical punishment, such as spanking, inflicted on a child by an adult in authority. Lets look at the pros, cons and the effectiveness of corporal punishment in the United States and the rest of the world.
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes the pros and cons of corporal punishment in the united states and the rest of the world.
- Explains that spanking can be effective on a short-term basis in getting children to change any negative behaviors that prompted the spaking. cons include increased aggressiveness, antisocial behavior, and delinquency.
- Explains the pros and cons of spanking according to james talbot.
- Opines that spanking is an ineffective and meaningless discipline tool that causes fear and withdrawal.
- Explains that countries outlawing physical punishment of children. discipline and the law.
1106 wordsRead More - Corporal Punishment and Parentsopinion essayThe most important argument in favour of corporal punishment, which is the excuse of most of the parents when they are asked to stop the physical punishment, is that it teaches discipline to the children. The conventional parents give the name of discipline to the use of physical force to enforce their orders on their offspring’s. But actually discipline is of two types as defined in a journal named “The State of Research on the Effects of Physical Punishment” that “power-assertive” and “inductive” discipline. Power-assertive disciplinary methods involve following a child’s inappropriate behaviour with a negative consequence (smacking, threats, and withdrawal of privileges) without explanation or justification. Inductive methods involve setting limits, setting up logical consequences, reasoning and explanation.” (Smith, “The State of Research on the Effects of Physical Punishment”) These definitions of two types of discipline illustrates that there are other ways of teaching discipline instead of using corporal punishment. But most of the parents are unaware of it and have a mindset that the only way to make the children disciplined and make them a mannered person is to punish them physically on doing any mistake. But that is not the case, Power-assertive discipline have a lot of negative effects which are discussed. In fact such use of power do not make the children disciplined in true sense but make them wild and as violence leads to violence so they do the same to compel others to obey them. They think that it is the only way to force others to obey you and think it to be legal to hit, slap or beat someone who does not follows their instruction. So there is no excuse of using force to implement what you want and even by causing...
In this essay, the author
- Explains that the most important argument in favour of corporal punishment is that it teaches discipline to the children.
- Argues that gershoff meta-analysis appears to be in favour of corporal punishment because it results in immediate compliance and expeditious acquiescence.
- Opines that corporal punishment of juveniles is against moral principles and argues that it is not the sole right of parents to use it to teach them discipline and other norms of society.
- Opines that there are many alternatives of corporal punishment to implement rules and regulations upon children and to teach them the norms of society.
- Opines that corporal punishment is the best way of teaching discipline by the parents, but its exercise inevitably produces mental disorders, increase in aggression and anti-social behaviour of children and worse effect on the parent-child relationship.
- Explains that physical punishment and the development of aggressive and violent behaviour: a review by elizabeth kandel.
- States smith, anne b., "the state of research on the effects of physical punishment." ministry of social development, 27 mar. 2006.
1099 wordsRead More - Why Is Child Discipline Wrongopinion essayPhysical punishment to children helps the child engage better with others and to modify or control their behavior (Child Discipline). The child will learn to think before they do something because of the consequences they would have to face after they do something bad. Another example that shows that physical punishment can do the job is the child would be more carefully of what they do. The reason for discipline is so the children can encourage moral, and also so the child could develop a sense of responsibility (Child Discipline). With the child growing up with a sense of responsibility they could understand to be independent and depend on their self instead of someone else. Disciplining a child could help them grow into responsible
In this essay, the author
- Explains that some children are too young to understand an explanation of why their behavior is wrong, but children should be discipline because physical punishment can do the job and the children need to learn some way.
- Opines that children should be disciplined because physical punishment helps them engage better with others and modify or control their behavior. the reason for discipline is to encourage moral and develop a sense of responsibility.
- Opines that children should be disciplined because they need to learn some way.
- Explains that although some children are too young to understand why their behavior is wrong, children should be disciplined for two main reasons: physical punishment can do the job, but the children need to learn some way.
576 wordsRead More - Should Parents Be Allowed To Spank Childrencomparative essay"All people have the right to protection of their physical integrity, and children are people too”(Hunt). Children are physically punished to correct their negative behaviors; however, there has been a dispute about whether or not it is acceptable for parents to spank their children as a form of punishment since children have the same rights to be respected like adults. Most adults would argue that it is acceptable for parents to physically punish their children with spanking because there are benefits to discipling children using this method, but even though the opposing argument is valid, spanking children as punishment has long term effects that can negatively change the child’s behavior. Documentation presents reasons why it is not okay for parents to spank their children as the only form of punishment.
In this essay, the author
- Explains that children are physically punished to correct their negative behaviors, but there has been a dispute about whether or not it is acceptable for parents to spank their children.
- Explains that most adults think it is acceptable to spank their children because they believe a simple "time out" isn't effective enough.
- Explains that spanking has negative effects on children, such as depression, anxiety, and "increased" aggression, but there are studies that can't prove this.
- Explains that parents can introduce to their children that there are consequences for their poor actions by using discipline. most adults who use spanking as physical punishment believe that it will make them respect and obey their authorities.
- Concludes that spanking may be an effective way to discipline children, but the information presented gives reason as to why physical punishment should not solely be a way of disciplining young children.
743 wordsRead More - Disciplining a Childopinion essayIn today’s society many people believe spanking children and physically punishing them is a good way to discipline. I believe there are many more effective ways to discipline a child.
In this essay, the author
- Explains that people believe spanking children is a good way to discipline, but there are many more effective ways.
- Opines that it is not acceptable for a fully grown adult to use painful physical force against small vulnerable children. children turned out okay in spite of spanking, not because of it.
- Explains that most smokers never develop cancer, most drunk drivers don’t get into wrecks, and most children who grow up in homes with lead paint do not suffer brain damage.
- Opines that spanking children is the only effective way to discipline a child.
- Advises parents to discipline their children in a non-violent way, explaining things to them, and giving them time to think about their actions. the fact that our society has decided to offer protection to other victims does not alter the truth.
563 wordsRead More - Pros And Cons Of Corporal Punishmentanalytical essayIn conclusion, the use of corporal punishment on children should be banned as it continues to grow out of favor among Americans. The use of corporal punishment is also associated with detrimental negative outcomes such as, an increased risk of aggression, antisocial behaviors, mental health problems, and puts children at greater risk of experiencing physical abuse. Also with efforts in place to educate the public and provide effective alternative strategies for disciplining children, passing a ban in the United States on all forms of corporal to help protect children is in the foreseeable future.
In this essay, the author
- Argues that the united states should ban all forms of corporal punishment used on children to help reduce violence against them.
- Explains that gershoff's study on corporal punishment by parents found it was associated with a decrease in moral internalization, quality of relationships, and mental health in both child and adulthood.
- Explains that the use of corporal punishment on children was highly favorable among americans, but public approval has gradually declined. the american academy of pediatrics (aap) released the issues policy statement on parental discipline of children.
- Opines that public education and informational campaigns are needed to change the opinion, attitudes, and behaviors of americans regarding corporal punishment use on children.
856 wordsRead More