Angry Harvest Movie Comparison

1649 Words4 Pages

Polish directors Andrzej Wajda and Agnieszka Holland both make use of silence in their two films, Katyn (2006) and Angry Harvest (1985) to highlight emotion, as well as conflict. They as well share in their depictions of authority, best expressed in Katyn with Nazi and Soviet rule, and in Angry Harvest with Leon exerting sexual control over Rosa. The setting of World War II allows the directors to incorporate such themes as well as portray the physical and psychological aspect of people of the era. Katyn (2006), directed by Andrzej Wajda, is a historical epic that centers on the Katyn Massacre, a mass execution of Polish army officers by Soviet troops in April 1940 in Western Russia. This story is told through the experiences of one of the …show more content…

Holland uses the war more as a backdrop than an event for which the entire plot pivots off of. A well to do farmer, Leon Wolny, comes across a Jewish woman—Rosa—on his farm, hungry and delirious from illness, having spent several days evading Nazis after jumping off of a train that was transporting her and her family to a concentration camp, he takes her in. At first the film appears to be a story of how the farmer shows compassion to this woman, but it devolves into a complex character study where Leon battles his moral conscience and questions himself and his attraction to her and other women. The two eventually grow close, though it is unclear how much of the relationship is based off of mutual love and respect. At the end of the film, when faced with the possibility of the Nazis finding Rosa, Leon tells her she needs to flee to and hide at a neighboring farm, out of fear of leaving her small cellar underneath his house, she commits suicide by slitting her …show more content…

Holland makes use of this tense scene with a very minimal mis-en-scene, the viewer does not see the interior of the train in any detail, for it is incredibly dark. Neither does the viewer see any of the faces of those that are talking, just darkness. Instead of using dramatic music and intricate camera work to establish the tone of the film, Holland uses the sound of the train on the tracks, the darkness of the train car, and the whispers of Rosa, pleading with her daughter to let go of her doll and jump out of the moving train. Presumably her husband pulls her away, and just as the train is passing through a tunnel, pushes her out of the car and into the forest with a scream. The scene then cuts to Leon visiting his old employer in town and the movie properly

Open Document