Analysis of Dulce et Decorum est by Wilfred Owen and Charge of the Light Brigade by Alfred Lord Tennyson
opinion Essay
3175 words
Analysis of Dulce et Decorum est by Wilfred Owen and Charge of the Light Brigade by Alfred Lord Tennyson
In this essay I intend to discuss the two passionately opinionated war
poems, 'Dulce et Decorum est' by Wilfred Owen based on WW1 and 'Charge
of the Light Brigade' by Alfred Lord Tennyson which portrays the
Crimean war against Russia. Both poems are heart wrenching, emotional
and thought provoking, and expressively highlight the issues of war,
glory, death and heroism, all in explicit detail and compelling
imagery. I shall compare how one author can see war as glorious and
exciting whereas the other empathises on suffering, injury and loss
and tells us the reality in gruesome and uninhibited detail.
I shall study how different authors present and explore the brutal
realism of war, death and glory within the context of a poem. I shall
investigate if first hand experience of war differs the authors view
and how they portray the suffering and grievance. I will find the
effects that mood, tone, the raised and ignored issues have on their
targeted audience and the vivid images created in our minds. Also, how
powerful vocabulary and successful language features help to make
these issues so powerful, I shall investigate further.
Firstly, I intend to analyse the poem 'Dulce et Decorum est' by
Wilfred Owen, this poem is his personal account of when he was
fighting in World War 1. The title, 'Dulce et Decorum est' is very
symbolic and has a poignant meaning as it is Latin for; 'It is
courageous and honorable to die for your country'. Therefore, the
reader would instantly think that this poem is going to be promoting
war as glorious and...
... middle of paper ...
...the
audience will believe that warfare is unnecessary if circumstances
like the one Owen described are happening. Tennyson's message is not
as clear, once reading his poem the audience will see the positive
side to war and the advantages of fighting for our rights. Both poems
have used thought provoking and fantastic imagery to portray their
differing and highly opinionated views on warfare. Powerful literacy
techniques and successful uses of metaphors and similies cleverly
enhance the story and increase the pace, which influences the
excitement. Therefore I can say that the experiences that a man has in
connection to warfare will defiantly affect their view and how they
present the issue in the style of a poem, also that poets will hide
parts of the truth to emphasise their view and capture their
audiences' minds.
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes dulce et decorum est by wilfred owen and charge of the light brigade by alfred lord tennyson.
- Opines that wilfred owen is not the case as you read on.
- Analyzes how the poem is in chronological order and tells a story.
- Opines that it is not noble or heroic to die for one's war.
- Opines that it is trying to capture the minds of people who might be going to war.
- Analyzes how the poem seems to flow and rhyme due to its rhythm.
- Analyzes how the message is not made very obvious, as the poem is just a story.
- Explains that noble six hundred, he is proud of these men and wishes to show this.
- Opines that when a poet uses words like these it increases the chance of death.
- Explains that men had to encounter when they were in war.
- Opines that the only part of the poem that is 'but not the six hundred', is the one that's summary:
- Explains that he has only read about the war in the papers and has received the news.
- Opines that it is noble to die for one's country and that killing a man is justifiable.
- Opines that owen's song could not be sung as a light hearted song in music halls as this is not the image the poet wanted to create.
Related
- analytical
- argumentative
- The Portrayal of War in Charge of the Light Brigade and Dulce et Decorum Est
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes the portrayal of war in charge of the light brigade and dulce et decorum est.
- Analyzes how the film tells the story of soldiers caught in a gas attack.
- Narrates how they were clumsy in putting their helmets on in such a rush.
- Describes how nasty it is to watch someone die in a gas attack.
- Explains that cannon to the left of them volleyed and cites the right and left.
- Compares the charge of the light brigade to the light brigade.
- Opines that war is bad and should be avoided at all costs.
- Explains that rhymes the last word of the first and third lines with the third and the second lines.
2158 wordsRead More - Dulce Et Decorum Est And Wilfred Owen Analysisanalytical essayBoth Wilfred Owen’s “Dulce et Decorum Est” as well as “next to of course god america i” written by E.E. Cummings preform critic on war propaganda used during the first world war. Besides this the influence war propaganda has on the soldiers as individuals as well as on war in more general terms, is being portrayed in a sophisticated and progressive manner. By depicting war with the use of strong literary features such as imagery or sarcasm both texts demonstrate the harshness of war as well as attempt to convey that war propaganda is, as Owen states “an old lie”, and that it certainly is not honourable to die for one’s country. Therefore, the aim of both writers can be said to be to frontally attack any form of war promotion or support offensively
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes how wilfred owen's "dulce et decorum est" and e.e. cummings' "next to of course god america i" preform critics on war propaganda used during the first world war.
- Analyzes how "dulce et decorum est" and "next to of course god america i" both focus on war propaganda providing deceptive and counterfeit images of war, but both in totally diverging manners.
- Analyzes how the idea that war in reality is totally diverging from the images depicted in patriotic propaganda is again emphasized in owens "dulce et decorum est".
- Analyzes how owen compares the idealistically perfect and tough soldiers depicted in war propaganda with the completely opposing reality.
- Analyzes how the speaker's tone changes towards the end of the poem, establishing a deeper connection to the reader and emphasising imagery.
- Analyzes how e.e. cummings' "next to god america i" uses patriotic ideas to create a deeper understanding for the reader.
- Analyzes how cummings integrated an example of the ideas war propaganda conveys in a humorous but yet serious form. the speaker mocks these by using words of sarcasm and irony.
- Analyzes how the speaker exaggerates by contradicting the apparent heroic greatness of war depicted in war propaganda with completely opposing descriptors of the reality.
- Analyzes how the use of the word "rapidly" suggests that the speaker has to recover from his speech which might have exhausted him due to the lacking punctuation and steady pace.
- Explains that although both poems have their own totally individual method of conveying their message, they both agree that patriotic war propaganda is used to manipulate or brainwash individuals in order to adjust a nations ideas or attitude towards certain factors or conditions.
1364 wordsRead More - Compare and Contrast Tennyson's The Charge of the Light Brigade and Owen's Dulce Et Decorum Estargumentative essayIn this essay you will notice the differences and similarities between ‘The Charge of the Light Brigade’ and ‘Dulce Et Decorum Est’. ‘The Charge of the Light Brigade’ was written in nineteenth century by Alfred Lord Tennyson. In contrast, ‘Dulce Et Decorum Est’ was written in the twentieth century by Wilfred Owen. The main similarity we have observed is that they both capture war time experiences. However, the poets’ present these events using their own style, and the effect is two completely different observations of war.
In this essay, the author
- Compares ‘the charge of the light brigade’ and ‘dulce et decorum est’. both capture war time experiences, but the poets present them using their own style, and the effect is two completely different observations of war.
- Analyzes how tennyson's poem glorifies the war, celebrating the sacrifice they had made for their country. the commitment of war in ‘the charge of the light brigade’ is only shown because he has not used descriptive language.
- Analyzes how tennyson portrays the generals in a positive light, but he wants to blame someone else for the deaths.
- Compares owen's use of metaphors and similes in his poem 'into the jaws of death', which conveys that he was helpless as the soldiers suffered.
- Concludes that ‘the charge of the light brigade’ and ‘dulce et decorum est’ are contrastable, but in some points they are compatible.
1860 wordsRead More - Dulce Et Decorum Est, And Wilfred Owen's Impact Of War On Poetryanalytical essayWorld War I impacted poetry profoundly. Poets who served in the war were using poetry to share their horrific stories about the hardships they faced. These poets became known as “war poets.” They wrote about the traumatic, life changing experiences that haunted them once the war was over. Intense poems started emerging that portrayed the mental and physical struggles soldiers faced. Two examples of the impact that World War I had on poetry is seen in the poems “Dulce et Decorum Est” by Wilfred Owen and “Repression of War Experience” by Siegfried Sassoon.
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes how world war i impacted poetry profoundly. poets who served in the war were using poetry to share their horrific stories about the hardships they faced.
- Explains that the time period after the war led to a new world of literature. people viewed war as courageous and patriotic. the realities of world war i led traditional poets away from their beliefs and values.
- Describes wilfred owen as a war poet who enlisted in the british army in 1915 after being wounded in combat. he met siegfried sassoon, who inspired owen to bring combat experiences to life through poetry.
- Explains that wilfred owen was an unknown poet when he died, but is now recognized as one of the most well-known, admired poets of world war i.
- Analyzes how wilfred owen's poem "dulce et decorum est" depicts helpless soldiers on the battlefield and gory details of death.
- Compares siegfried sassoon and wilfred owen, who served in world war i, and wrote many of his war poems while in the hospital.
- Analyzes how sassoon uses a soldier as the example of repression as someone who has experienced war and the impacts it has on life after.
- Analyzes the impact that the war had on poetry of that time by focusing on one poem by wilfred owen and one by siegfried sassoon.
- Explains that wilfred owen's dulce et decorum est as an anti-war manifesto was published in the journal of history, culture & art research.
1089 wordsRead More - Analysis Of Dulce Et Decorum Est By Wilfred Owenanalytical essayWilfred Owen wrote about the distilled pity of war from his first-hand experience. Owen concisely features the carnage and destruction of war in both the poems, ‘Dulce et Decorum Est’ and ‘Strange Meeting’ Owen uses these poems document the psychological and physical debilitation of war. In ‘Dulce et Decorum est’, Owen uses a various amount of literary techniques to visually depict the cruel and grotesque death from the mustard gas whereas ‘Strange Meeting’, portrays the speaker in conversation with a dead soldier that he is presumably responsible for killing, symbolically which emphasises the effect of the wartime trauma. Wilfred Owen’s poetry effectively highlights the carnage and destruction of war to educate the audience on the disillusionment of war.
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes how wilfred owen wrote about the distilled pity of war from his first-hand experience. owen uses literary techniques to visually depict the cruel and grotesque death from the mustard gas.
- Analyzes owen's use of simile and alliteration in "dede" to convey the disillusionment in war.
- Analyzes how owen uses hyperbole, allusion to dante's inferno and word connotation to emphasize the physical enfeeblement of the soldiers in war.
- Analyzes how owen highlights carnage and destruction in "dede" and "sm" to emphasize the physical impairment of the soldiers due to war.
- Analyzes how owen uses metaphors to emphasise psychological carnage and destruction of war. the emotive word "flung" implies soldiers are treated as disposable.
- Analyzes how owen heightens on carnage and destruction to teach the audience about the psychological effects of war.
- Analyzes how owen uses metaphor, connotation and emotive words to express the disillusionment in war in "dede" and "sm".
- Analyzes how owen uses tone and repetition of the title to exemplify the lie in war "the old lie: dulce et decorum est pro patria mori".
- Analyzes how owen highlights the slaughter and devastation in "sm" to uncover the truth in war. he uses metaphor and allusion to "intimations of immortality in early childhood".
- Analyzes how owen uses metaphor and tone to convey that there is disillusionment. he highlights the carnage and destruction of war to emphasize the sacrifice that soldiers were willing to make for their country.
- Analyzes how owen's poetry depicts the carnage and destruction of war to educate the audience on the disillusionment in war.
1465 wordsRead More - Analysis of Dulce et Decorum Est by Wilfred Owenanalytical essayAnalysis of Dulce et Decorum Est by Wilfred Owen In the poem, Dulce et Decorum Est written by Wilfred Owen, the speaker appears to be a soldier in the army, warning young people eager for war, “children ardent for some desperate glory,” that war is not what it seems. The soldier explains to the reader through first hand experience that fighting for one’s country is not as glorious a task as it may appear to be. One shouldn’t believe the lie that is told about how it is sweet and proper to die for one’s country. The poem takes place during a war, while the men are marching and death surrounds them. Throughout the length of the poem, the speaker has a morose tone, as anyone witnessing so much death and destruction around them would.
In this essay, the author
- Opines that if one were to see what he has seen, they would see it.
- Analyzes how the poem expresses to the reader, the pain of war and what it is like to live in war.
- Opines that helmets or what seems to be gas masks, one doesn't get it in time.
- Describes the sense of sound, as one is able to imagine what it must sound and feel.
- Analyzes the scene and the phrase "as under a green sea."
- Analyzes how the poem gives it a type of rhythm, similar to the beat of the song.
477 wordsRead More - Dulce Et Decorum Est By Wilfred Owen: Poem Analysisanalytical essayThere are aspects of war that one cannot understand if they never witness it. The lack of connection with soldiers on the battlefield only fuel citizens who want to fight. Wilfred Owen’s poems paint a picture of being on the field to people who do not have this experience. He describes the emotions, thoughts, and struggles of living in the combat zone.
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes how wilfred owen's poems paint a picture of being on the field to people who don't have this experience.
- Analyzes how wilfred portrays a group of weak soldiers trekking along the horrendous conditions of their trench. owen describes how nothing about war is glorious.
- Analyzes how wilfred owen develops the idea that war is a nightmare and these men on the field live it.
- Analyzes how wilfred owen uses personification to describe war as built on a church of death.
- Analyzes how the second stanza of anthem for a doomed youth states how love ones can honor the lives of soldiers after their death.
- Analyzes how owen's poems define an untraditional view in which dying for your country is not worthy. wilfred states only the civilians at home can stop the massacre but are blind to the penalties of war.
612 wordsRead More - The Comparison of Prewar and Postwar Ideas of War and their Reflection in Literatureanalytical essayOwen, Wilfred. “Dulce et Decorum Est’’. The Norton Anthology of English Literature, 8th ed., vol. II. Ed. M. H. Abrams. New York: W. W. Norton & Company, 2006. 1974. Print.
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes how the idea of enlisting in the british army appealed to ideals of masculinity, heroism, pride, and loyalty. but after facing the war, they felt betrayed and abandoned by their country.
- Analyzes how rupert brooke's poem "the soldier" is idealistic and permeated with the traditional idea of war.
- Analyzes how wilfred owen's poem, "dulce et decorum est," is a part of the latin proverb that goes "delicious" and expresses his attitude toward war.
- Analyzes how owens' method of dramatic description seeks to make physical and psychological suffering of the war more vivid. he continues by describing horror as maybe not even imaginable in the worst dreams.
- Explains that the great war started in 1914 and lasted until 1918. it led to changes in society, in the way people looked at war.
- Explains brooke, rupert, and m. h. abrams' the norton anthology of english literature.
- Explains owen, wilfred, and m. h. abrams' the norton anthology of english literature.
- Analyzes how the world war one, also known as the great war, escalated in 1914 by the assassination of austrian archduke franz ferdinand in sarajevo and lasted till 1918.
836 wordsRead More - Of Wilfred Owen's 'Dulce Et Decorum Est'analytical essayThe poem Dulce Et Decorum Est, by Wilfred Owen begins when the soldiers are returning from World War 1.
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes how wilfred owen's poem dulce et decorum est begins when the soldiers are returning from world war 1. they were tired and exhausted, and a gas attack happened.
- Analyzes the language feature wilfred owen uses, "as under a green sea, i saw him drowning." the soldier was stuck in the poisonous gas and couldn't escape it.
- Analyzes how the poem explains the experience that the soldiers and wilfred owen had experienced during this explicit death.
380 wordsRead More - Dulce Et Docorum Est by Wilfred Owenanalytical essayDulce Et Docorum Est by Wilfred Owen The World War One poet, Wilfred Owen, wrote two poems named ‘Dulce Et Decorum Est’ and ‘Disabled’. The main themes running throughout both poems are that of the pain and worthlessness of war, and the crime towards the young soldiers it was. The beginning and ending of these two poems link these ideas through the use of imagery contrast and language features. The poem ‘disabled’ begins by describing a physically and mentally destroyed soldier, clearly a result of war, welcoming darkness to come and end his misery by taking him away. The image of a “wheeled chair” implies that he is disabled and probably dependent on others.
In this essay, the author
- Explains that wilfred owen wrote two poems, 'dulce et decorum est' and ‘disabled’. the main themes running throughout both poems are that of the pain and worthlessness of war, and the crime towards young soldiers.
- Analyzes how wilfred owen's poem 'disabled' describes a physically and mentally destroyed soldier who welcomes darkness to end his misery by taking him away.
- Analyzes how owen's poem focuses on a man who couldn't fit his gas mask in time when they were attacked.
- Concludes that wilfred owen writes two poems to shock his readers and enlighten them about how awful war really was. both the beginning and end of each poem retain the same messages throughout.
- Analyzes how wilfred owen's poem, "dulce et decorum est," depicts the tiredness and pain caused by war.
843 wordsRead More