Harman Grewal The short story “The Kid Nobody Could Handle," by Kurt Vonnegut Jr. depicts the significance of acceptance. Jim is portrayed as an insecure and forlorn individual who hides the vulnerability he feels under a 'tough boy' facade. His sense of hope is battered and beaten by the negligence and abandonment he experiences. In this story, judgement creates a deceiving illusion of an individuals proposed identity. First of all, the theory of Forms by Plato describes that behind every idea and object there is a hidden reality. Perception is often deceived by physical senses, and the dependency on these senses creates a selectively blind society. The concepts and objects we perceive are only a reflection of the Form they represent. …show more content…
It shows them imprisoned to emphasize the fallacy of their judgement. Correspondingly, Jim builds his own ‘cave’ of isolation burying his true self from others. Isolation hides the true identity of an individual showcasing only their ‘reflection.’ It is used as a defense mechanism to evade emotional distress and turmoil. The disconnection between emotions and the purposed purpose creates a path of social instability. Social isolation creates a greater susceptibility to loneliness and low self-esteem. Initially, Jim is portrayed as a product of betrayal and neglect which establishes his impassive disposition. His emotionless and cold attitude clashes with Helmholtz’s optimistic outlook who, “was appalled to see that the boy’s eyes were as expressionless as oysters.” However, Jim’s apathetic temperament is used as a shield to hide his insecurities. His hesitancy is shown when he doubtfully asks, “[w]hat good is it?” Also, Jim’s sense of determination is evident in the story. He continuously shields himself from others trying to preserve his isolated state of mind. For example, when …show more content…
Judgment is a natural instinct and a necessary psychological adaptation. However, judgement can cloud one’s perception of other individuals. For example, people are unable to identify with Jim because of their impressionable mentalities. Judgement influences the way we perceive others. Likewise, Quinn automatically assumes that Jim is unintelligent because of his troublesome appearance. Jim is immensely affected by the judgemental outlooks of the society he lives in. His impassive ‘robot-like’ temperament is strengthened because nobody expects otherwise. The self-deceitful presumptions make Jim isolate himself from others. He showcases how judgemental values can lead to a suppressed identity. Furthermore, judgement is prominent in society today reflecting inner thoughts and perspectives. Society has disparate perceptions of what is considered suitable and appropriate. It’s impossible to judge humans as simply good or bad, because the world isn’t black and white it’s a million shades of colours. For example, Jim seems like a cold person, but his emotions are shown when Helmholtz break the trumpet. Jim exemplifies the volatile impact judgment has on youth. Judgement is a corrupt disease, and acceptance is the only remedy. For instance, Helmholtz’s acceptance gives Jim a sense of belonging, and helps break his ‘cave’ of
The “Theory of forms” is taught in Plato’s “allegory of the cave”, a thought experiment which makes his point from a real world scenario. He wants us to imagine humans in the conditions of enslavement to the extent that we cannot move and what we can only see are images of everyday objects: pencils, books, tables, letters, etc. What the people, in this condition, are actually seeing are shadows, because behind them there are imperfect representations of the actual objects made out of wood which are moving across their vision as shadows because behind the objects there is a fire which is the only light in this dark cave. Once we at least have semi-clear vision of what this thought experiment entail then we can see what Plato is trying to say in his theory of forms. The shado...
This article contains claims that Jim’s character should not be offensive because of his positive portrayal. The author uses personal experiences and examples from the book to back this claim. His position as an English Professor is important to note.
Jim’s character is defined not just by his own introspective nature but the setting he is in and the individuals that he meets influence his life. The journey that he undertakes from innocence to experience is influenced by all these factors. We first see Jim as an innocent and quiet young man who spends much of his time watching the migratory and native birds on the coast of QLD. David Malouf foregrounds these themes of innocence and experience by portraying Jim the protagonist as an unknown threat as the reader slowly has to develop a back story about the main character as the novel progresses forward. Clearly, without the searing experiences of war, Jim would definitely not have grown up the way he did. It’s not just the violence and brutalities of war that transformed his own innocence to experience but some of the mental and physical barriers he’s faced throughout his journey. “He weaved about, but very light. He might have been executing a graceful dance, all on his own there, till another figure, hurling itself from the shadows, brought him down. There were thumps. A woman’s raucous laughter. ‘Abos,’ the girl said again with cool disgust, as the rituals being enacted, however violent, and in whatever degenerate form, were ordinary and not to be taken note of”. (PG
Throughout the novel there is a recurring theme, acceptance. In order for the reader to connect
Plato’s view on existence can be understood by discussing his theory of Forms. The theory of Forms or Ideas is about the existence of ideas in higher form of reality, the existence of a reality inhabited by forms of all things and concepts. Plato used example of objects such as table and rock and concepts like Beauty and Justice to illustrate the notion of Forms. Plato further describes Forms as a being possessed by concepts. For example, Virtue has different characters; but they all have a common nature which makes them virtuous.
History has continuously shown one thing, that the most successful people resist the desperation for acceptance, just to be considered, “normal”. The need for acceptance becomes a barrier to reaching personal freedom, happiness, and truth. Rather, it creates a barren wasteland, where your true identity cannot bloom, but withers, leaving a deceitful and false personality that remains on the surface. This only creates guilt, distress, and stress-- from hiding one’s real self in pursuit of approval. Yet, the people who learn to accept themselves and overlook others’ opinions end up finding peace and success. Rising above the misery of letting others pick out blemishes and pin on “perfections”, they find the bravery
Acceptance: 1) The action of consenting to receive or undertake something offered. 2) The action or process of being received as adequate or suitable, typically to be admitted into a group. However, many think of acceptance much differently. The popular opinion of acceptance, however, is when one emotionally acknowledges the importance or significance of someone or something. In his story short story “The Jacket,” Gary Soto writes about the period of a boy’s life when he receives an ugly, “day-old guacamole” green jacket that is made fun of and altogether convinces the narrator that the jacket is the one to blame for his lonely years. In it, Soto reveals the theme to be “acceptance is gradual” by using allusion, personification, and main events
Hinton focuses on how hardships while growing up shapes self-identifying as an adult. Johnny Cade, a teen who is considered a “lost puppy” mentions to Dally if his parents have been worried about him after he been hospitalized in critical condition ‘” My parents,” Johnny repeated doggedly, “did they ask about me.” “No,” snapped Dally, “they didn’t”’ (Hinton 327). Johnny is mostly isolated by his relationship with his parents. The parents neglect shapes Johnny’s identity for the urge of his parent’s acceptance. Subsequently, the urge of his parent’s acceptance limits his childhood responsibility and puts restrictions on Johnny and his parent's relationship. Childhood behavior is supposed to be formed around innocence, the need of protection, nurturing and supposed to be viewed as ideally happy and carefree. Meanwhile, Johnny's construction of childhood entails notions of isolations, loss of childhood, and the dependence of approval. Tyson explains a useful way of understanding behavior in "Psychoanalytic Criticism." He mentions, "Fear of abandonment – the unshakable belief that our friends and loved ones are going to desert us (physical abandonment) or don't really care about us (emotional abandonment.)" Specifically, Tyson is mentioning isolation impressions causes psychological strains on a person. Similarly, Johnny relates to Tyson's theory because Johnny's fear of abandonment accelerated his childhood because of
First and foremost, you have acceptance with everyone around you. In other words an agreement with others. For example there’s a boy who stays in the corner of the room all day because he can’t be to active or he dies. One day his brother kept pushing and pushing him till one day he could run, jump, and swim just so he could be accepted. Then one day he passed away in a severe thunderstorm trying to get home safely by running.
I intend to show the validity of Plato's arguments about his theory of Forms. Aristotle, along with others, cross-examines Plato's proposals. Yet, I happen to see the potential of his point of view and would like to take a deeper look into his theory. The purpose of this paper is to critically analyze the theory of Plato's Forms from his perspective and that of several others, including Aristotle.
With these rejected definitions in mind, Plato’s theory of knowledge, one that is grounded in idealism , calls for the separation of form and matter as well the existence of two worlds: the world of appearances and the world of intelligibly. The Platonic theory of knowledge states that knowledge is achieved through the ascension of, what Plato calls, the Plateaus of Kno...
The Theory of Forms or also known as The Theory of Ideas, is a challenging concept but represents the purest form of knowledge according to Socrates and Plato. The Forms represent Plato’s argument that non-physical forms/ideas are the most accurate reality we have. One can notice this difference because throughout Plato’s work, The Theory of Forms are often capitalized. Plato, who speaks of The Forms through different characters in each story, but mostly Socrates, believes that the Forms are the only objects of study that can provide knowledge and are the solutions to the universal problems that occur. Plato was heavily influenced on sceptism, which came from his teacher, Socrates. According to Plato, the world is contantly changing and believes
According to Plato, his Theory of Forms states perfection only lives in the realm of thought. There only exists one of every ideal and the rest is just a copy. This one creation is called a form, the most flawless representation of an idea. In the physical world everything is a copy of these forms and all copies are imperfect. Plato believed in two worlds; the intelligible world and the illusionistic world. The intelligible world is where everything is unchanging and eternal. We can only grasp the intelligible world with our mind. It is the world of ideas and not senses. A place where there are perfect forms of the things we know on Earth. According to Plato everything in the world we live in is an illusion. All objects are only shadows of their true forms. His theory further states every group of objects that have the same defying properties must have an ideal form. For example, in the class of wine glasses there must be one in particular that is the ideal wine glass. All others would fall under this ideal form.
One of the greatest philosophers to contribute the philosophy is Plato, who was a student of Socrates. Plato introduced the Theory of Forms, which states that what is real is not the objects we see, but rather the idea of Forms (Moore and Bruder, n.d., 35). Plato’s theory states that the objects we see in life, such as a chair, are not real and are only an object noticeable because it participates in the idea of a Form. The idea of Forms is what defines and makes an object such as a chair real. Further, in the book Philosophy The Power of Ideas by Brooke Noel Moore and Kenneth Bruder, the authors use an example of two beautiful objects to help explain Plato’s Theory of Forms. In the example, a beautiful statue and a beautiful house are used and it is expressed that they both have something in common, beauty. Moore and Bruder state that beauty is a type of form a...
Matter highlights and carries through substantial changes. A substance is caused (destroyed) by having matter take on (lose) form. A form is a conceptual property or quality. For example, if we take any property of an object and disconnect it from that object and look at it by itself, you are contemplating a form. In other words, the form is appearance things, something that is alive. "Forms" and "Ideas" are equivalent words. The form of the soul is the intellect, and the soul is a matter of the intellect. Plato believed that the delectable world has “forms” which provided meaning and identity to the individual