A Stand Against National Id Cards Essay

839 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Disadvantages of new national id

A Stand Against National ID Cards The issue of national security is a highly discussed topic; however, the implementation of a national ID card would cost Americans their privacy safety and increase discrimination within the United States. The improving of the U.S.s national security is without a doubt something that is extremely important and vital to life in America. But, national ID cards for every citizen is not an ideal solution. National ID cards are not worth the sacrifice of privacy, safety, and the rise in discrimination that will be occur from its creation. National IDs are not the solution to national security. All they will serve to do is slow down real progress in national security. Should a national id be created the privacy …show more content…

Anyone who appears to be foreign would fall under that category. These people will be preyed upon by police employers and banks with constant identity checks. These agencies will be a constant source of harassment and fear simply because of how a person looks. A similar event occurred decades ago “after congress passed the Employer Sanctions provision of the Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1985” (85). This act created a massive torrent of discrimination against foreign looking United States citizens. This injustice focuses mainly on Asian and Hispanic workers. In 1990 a study conducted by the General Accounting Office “found almost 20 percent of employers engaged in such practices” (85). The same negative effects would happen if national IDs were implemented, only it would happen on a much grander scale affecting thousands of more people. A person of a nonnative appearance could be harassed, searched, or, arrested for something as simple as not having their ID card with them. The National ID card would be a powerful tool that could easily be abused law enforcement and private corporations alike. Similar to how some college students will abuse drugs if left unabated and unregulated. Some police officers will use their new power to harass individuals, and will continue to do so if the power of the police is left

Show More
Related

  • Amadou Diallo In Malcolm Gladwell's 'Blink'

    694 Words  | 2 Pages

    You can’t judge a person accurately based on their visual aspect alone. In the book Blink by Malcolm Gladwell, a man named Amadou Diallo is killed by the police due to bad judgment on his appearance. Diallo is approached by the police at midnight; Diallo is sitting on a porch, looking up a down the street. The police found this subspecies and one police officer think Diallo looks like a push in burglar that has been around. The police approach Diallo and this scares Diallo, he is an immigrant with not very good English; Diallo runs from the police to his home as he tries to enter the building, he reaches in his pocket and an officer yells “gun” and they unload their guns on Diallo. The police subsequently found he was reaching for his wallet. The police were in the wrong for chasing Diallo, they had no

    Read More

  • Analysis of The Threat of National ID

    621 Words  | 2 Pages

    In William Safire’s “The Threat of National ID”, he argues against a National ID card. Safire published an article in the New York Times to establish different context. Safire gives details about the use of National ID card at different places in different situations. He emphasizes that many Americans are willing to give up personal privacy in return for greater safety, but none of us have privacy regarding where we go and what we do all the time. Safire disputes that mandatory National ID become necessary for people to prevent fear of terror attack.

    Read More

  • 'Limited Legality' By John Torpey Summary

    324 Words  | 1 Pages

    In John Torpey’s article “Coming and Going: On the State Monopolization of legitimate Means of Movement” he points out that through the use of documents such as international passports, internal passports, and identifications card such as driver licenses, the state control movements. By constructing rules and regulations the states are able to monitor and regulate who come can come in and who can’t. However, Sadiq in his article addresses illegal immigrants in a way that Torpey, failed to mention in his article. Sadiq in in his article, “Documentary Citizenship” brings forth an argument that focuses on illegal immigrants and their visibility within a nation-state. Being illegal one does not have any legal documents which means, they are invisible to the state. Though, illegal immigrants can buy identification documents in the black market that can give them social, political, or economical rights that will give them visibility within the state. I agree with Sadiq, that in order to fit in and to have rights in society you need some sort of

    Read More

  • Alan Dershowitz 'And' Why Fear National ID Cards?

    1075 Words  | 3 Pages

    Next on, the author presents the idea that national ID cards would not prevent all threats of terrorism, but they will for sure stop them from coming out in the open. Furthermore, the author says that National ID cards would reduce racial and ethnic segregation. Because someone’s information can be accessed online anytime it can be seen that that person is not a criminal. Summing up his thoughts, Dershowitz suggests that a national ID card would be effective in preventing terrorism and that he believes to follow a system that takes a bit of freedom for

    Read More

  • Why Is Domestic Surveillance Important

    1064 Words  | 3 Pages

    The NSA and U.S. government sifting through our private information is but a small inconvenience that we must sacrifice in order to protect our own freedom and safety. Domestic Surveillance roots back to the 1910’s, where the assassination of President McKinley, created a Bureau of Investigation that would trace the efforts of the Communists attempting an uprising in America. This would be the foundings behind Domestic Surveillance in America, and would continue on after World War II where the government created the NSA and CIA, with the main purposes

    Read More

  • Latino Stereotypes

    1208 Words  | 3 Pages

    Imagine being at risk of being pulled over at any given time, the only reason? The color of your skin. “2010, the state of Arizona passed a law authorizing local police to check the immigration status of anyone they reasonably suspect of being in the United States illegally.” (11 Facts...). The ability to pull people over for the sole reason of looking illegal. This seems aimed at Latinos because they are the ones that are easily recognizable, and often stereotyped as not being legal residents of the United States. For example, if two people were lined up and one had a light complexion and light features, and one had tan skin and darker skin, when asked who looked like an immigrant, a large majority would choose the individual with the tan

    Read More

  • Should Illegal Immigrants Get License Essay

    507 Words  | 2 Pages

    Illegal immigrant’s driving rights is a large topic in the U.S., especially since President Barack Obama passed a law that gave illegal immigrants the rights to a special privilege I.D. and license. The topic has become more frequent in conversation due to the presidential election looming around the corner. The idea of giving non-U.S. citizens licenses eludes a large number of the population. The question still remains whether or not illegal immigrants should have driver’s licenses. Illegal immigrants should continue to have the right to obtain driver’s licenses because they made sacrifices, already work in dismal conditions and U.S. citizens waste the privilege.

    Read More

  • Persuasive Essay On The Patriot Act

    1457 Words  | 3 Pages

    After the horrific incident on September 9, 2001, the Patriot Act was passed to help “reduce” terrorist attacks, but they have only restricted us from our rights and feeling free. Regardless of whether we have anything to hide, we deserve to feel comfortable in our own homes. They can even hack into our TVs and cameras! This is unacceptable! We have been dealing with the violation of our privacy due the Patriot Act, but this act led to the abuse of governments’ power, violation of our natural rights, and the government has been going through our texts, internet history, social media, which is breaching into the laws of the constitution.

    Read More

  • Domestic Surveillance Persuasive Essay

    1105 Words  | 3 Pages

    Many people live in fear that they are constantly being watched. Michael Jackson sang it best in the 80 's by saying, "I always feel like, somebody 's watching me," in his hit song with Rockwell. That 's exactly what the NSA and other government organizations are doing today with domestic surveillance. Everywhere Americans go and every corner they turn there is a camera, and every website or email they send is being monitored closely. So what can society do about this? Educate others on the situation and stand up for what is right. Some people believe they must give up some freedoms for protection, but at what cost? What is happening in America is not what the founding fathers fought for. Domestic surveillance should not be allowed because

    Read More

  • Essay On The Patriot Act

    2034 Words  | 5 Pages

    What Are Your Rights Worth? George Edward Peele III King &Low Heywood Thomas School. National security has been greatly enhanced by the passage of the Patriot Act. The USA PATRIOT Act is an act of Congress that was signed by President Bush in 2001. The title of the act is a ten-letter acronym that stands for Uniting and Strengthening America by Providing Appropriate Tools Required to Intercept and Obstruct Terrorism.

    Read More

  • Police Brutality Persuasive Essay

    1182 Words  | 3 Pages

    Police officers would be wearier of how they interact with citizens as well as avoid us of foul language. A 2013 New York Times article written by executive director of Law Enforcement against prohibition, Neill Franklin explains how officers will be more accountable for their actions and put at the same standards as regular citizens (Franklin). Citizen behavior would also greatly improve because a trust in police would most likely follow and more likely to seek police assistance when needed. Implementing body cams would make citizens feel like police officers are just as responsible for their actions as they

    Read More

  • Racism In Latin America

    932 Words  | 2 Pages

    Like in many other countries, Haitian immigrants in the Dominican Republic are treated as second-class citizens. Haitian migrants often take on the toughest jobs in indispensable sectors, yet are quickly blamed and looked down upon when the economy goes sour (Burdick and Dixon, 2012). Furthermore, Haitians in the Dominican Republic, are often exploited by their employers to work for lower wages, denied labor benefits, harassed by authorities, physically and sexually abused, and ultimately deported (Burdick and Dixon, 2012). This anti-Haitian sentiment is further supported by Dominican Republic institutions. The Dominican Republic uses identification cards that describe citizens as Indio (light, dark), Moreno, and the racially charged term Negro, which is almost exclusive to Haitians (Burdick and Dixon, 2012). This system has not only institutionalized anti-Haitian sentiment and racism, but it has also failed to protect Dominicans as Afro-Dominicans are often mistaken for Haitians and then

    Read More

  • Pros And Cons Of Racial Profiling

    1148 Words  | 3 Pages

    This type of circumstances have harm ethnic minorities. The main races that are target are Hispanics and Latinos, Arab and Muslims, African American, but they each have a category for why they been stop, follow and harass. First Hispanics and Latinos are been profile because some of them might be illegal. African American for been violent, troublemakers and been theft. Arab and Muslims are category as been terrorist. They have become second-class citizens for all that mistreatment or neglecting society, law enforcement has done to them. An example of second -class citizen is when in April 2010, Arizona authorized SB 1070, a law that would require law-enforcement officers to prove the citizenship of individuals they stop if they have reasonable suspicion that they may be in the United States illegally. (NY Times: Blocking Parts

    Read More

  • The Police Have Become the Criminals

    632 Words  | 2 Pages

    Across America, police have been involved in scandals and drugs. They are abusing the power that they have been given. The communities have begun not to trust the police because of their conduct toward the citizens. People have been beaten and harassed by the guys in blue. People in the communities have seen the police push individuals around and take things from individuals for no reason. People receive the wrong message. The public no longer can see a difference between the police and criminals.

    Read More

  • National Identification Essay

    734 Words  | 2 Pages

    Although there are many people such as Alan M. Dershowitz who believes that having national identification cards could help make the United States safer. However, there a people such as William Safire who believe the national identification cards are a threat to a citizen’s security, immigrants, and terrorism. Alan M. Desrshowitz in an article he wrote called, “Why Fear National ID” explains his views on why the

    Read More

More about A Stand Against National Id Cards Essay

Open Document