Essay about The Dred Scott Case Vs. Sanford Case

Essay about The Dred Scott Case Vs. Sanford Case

Length: 1029 words (2.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

From my perspective, I think the arguments in the Dred Scott case are similar in a way to the earlier ones over the scope of national power, but I also think it weakens the federal government in a way. By ruling in favor of Sandford, it caused a void on the Missouri Compromise to come into affect. This was put in place by the federal government and now after a Missouri state case ruling, it has to be voided away. This shows that states powers are kind of stronger than the federal government because they made them change the rules they put in place in the first place. The federal government did not allow slavery in that specific area, but it occurred anyway. This is where I get my similarity in the arguments because in the end of both of the arguments the states end up looking like they gained the most.
In my opinion, I agree with the majority of individuals who believe the decision made in the Dred Scott v. Sanford case was one of the worst decisions made by the Supreme Court in history. After reading and learning all about the case completely, I came to the conclusion that the Scott family should have been granted their freedom in the first place and should have never had the ruling overturned by the Missouri Court system. The Supreme Court decision against Dred Scott consisted of a few flaws that took away from Scott’s chance at ever becoming a citizen of the United States. Based on the time period, in my opinion I believe the Court’s substantive decision to go against Dred Scott was made to protect the country, but was highly influenced by the “slightly” flawed legal reasoning of Chief Justice Roger Taney.
During the 20th century, slavery was one of the most major issues that took place in the Unite States. Many in...


... middle of paper ...


...o white man who hated even the idea of African Americans, was going to allow a federal court case to be ruled in their favor at all.
By having a mainly pro-slavery Supreme Court, the decisions can be easily persuaded to be in favor of slavery. This makes the Supreme Court look bias in the eyes of people nowadays, but back in the 1950s that was the way a lot of people thought. In my opinion, I think any African American slave whom sued for their freedom or citizenship at the time would have lost the case no matter what. Dre Scott was the first one to start the civil movement and allowed for more African Americans to start pursuing their freedom as well. In the end, I believe Scott should have been freed, due to all the facts of the case, he was entitled to be free and was not given that right because the white minded Supreme Court would not allow it to happen.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about The Dred Scott Case Vs. Sanford Case

- From my perspective, I think the arguments in the Dred Scott case are similar in a way to the earlier ones over the scope of national power, but I also think it weakens the federal government in a way. By ruling in favor of Sandford, it caused a void on the Missouri Compromise to come into affect. This was put in place by the federal government and now after a Missouri state case ruling, it has to be voided away. This shows that states powers are kind of stronger than the federal government because they made them change the rules they put in place in the first place....   [tags: American Civil War, Slavery in the United States]

Better Essays
1029 words (2.9 pages)

Dred Scott v. Sanford Essay

- Dred Scott, an African American man who was born into slavery, wanted what all slaves would have wanted, their freedom. They were mistreated, neglected, and treated not as humans, but as property. In 1852, Dred Scott sued his current owner, Sanford, about him, no longer being a slave, but a free man (Oyez 1). In Article four of the Constitution, it states that any slave, who set foot in a free land, makes them a free man. This controversy led to the ruling of the state courts and in the end, came to the final word of the Supreme Court....   [tags: American History, Slavery, Freedom]

Free Essays
917 words (2.6 pages)

Dred Scott V. Sanford Research Paper

- Dred Scott v. Sanford Research Paper Citizenship is often a word taken for guaranteed by natural born citizens in the United States today. The word citizen is a word over looked and skimmed as one may browse through the constitution. In today’s society it may seem long ago that citizenship wasn’t granted to everyone, but the word segregation may strike a nerve. Dred Scott v. Sanford, 1856 landmark Supreme Court case is a prime example of the struggle slaves had in their disputes to be free. There goes another word- free....   [tags: American Civil War, Slavery in the United States]

Better Essays
1073 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on The Impact of the Dred Scott Case on the United States

- The Impact of the Dred Scott Case on the United States The Dred Scott Case had a huge impact on the United States as it is today. The Thirteenth and Fourteenth Amendments have called it the worst Supreme Court decision ever rendered and was later overturned. The Dred Scott Decision was a key case regarding the issue of slavery; the case started as a slave seeking his rightful freedom and mushroomed into a whole lot more. 65 The reason why Dred Scott decided to pursue his freedom is unknown, but there are a couple theories....   [tags: Dred Scott Case Supreme Court Slavery Essays]

Better Essays
1457 words (4.2 pages)

Essay about Dred Scott Vs. Sandford

- In 1857, the United States Supreme Court made a stunning decision to uphold slavery in the territories, denied the legality of black citizenship, and declared the Missouri Compromise of 1820 unconstitutional. The Supreme Court case, DRED SCOTT VS. SANDFORD reached the Supreme Court in 1857 after the Missouri Supreme Court against Scott in 1852. Scott’s next step was to take his case out of the state judicial system and into the federal judicial system. After going through the U.S Circuit Court for the District of Missouri it was finally heard by the Supreme Court....   [tags: Slavery in the United States]

Better Essays
1059 words (3 pages)

Essay on Dred Scott V. Sandford Case

- In the mid to late 1800’s, America was a hard place to live in if you were a person of color. Slavery was still legal in the south during the 1800’s and was practised in the majority of the states. While slavery was legal in the South, it was outlawed in the North. With this being the case, a separation between slave states and non slave states, there needed to be a border to separate the two. This means that once this line was crossed, ideally, a slave would no longer be a slave. If he was not freed, there would be some sort of Consequence However, this was not the case when it came to the Dred Scott v....   [tags: Slavery in the United States, American Civil War]

Better Essays
1025 words (2.9 pages)

Dredd Scott Decision Essay

- INTRODUCTION United States Supreme Court case Scott v. Sanford (1857), commonly known as the Dred Scott Case, is probably the most famous case of the nineteenth century (with the exception possibly of Marbury v. Madison). It is one of only four cases in U. S. history that has ever been overturned by a Constitutional amendment (overturned by the 13th and 14th Amendments). It is also, along with Marbury, one of only two cases prior to the Civil War that declared a federal law unconstitutional. This case may have also been one of the most, if not the most, controversial case in American history, due simply to the fact that it dealt an explosive opinion on an issue already prepared to erupt -...   [tags: Supreme Court Scott v. Sanford]

Better Essays
2561 words (7.3 pages)

Dred Scott case Essay

- On June 19th 1862 the US Congress prohibits slavery in the United States territories nullifying the Dred Scott Case. This was the most important day in US history for African Americans. This is because it helped blacks gain the rights they deserve. It also gave them rights they never thought they could achieve. This Court case of Scott vs. Sanford was a catalyst to riots, other court cases such as Brown vs. Board of Education, Rachel vs. Walker and many acts and amendments resulted from one mans wish to be free....   [tags: American History, African Americans ]

Better Essays
1923 words (5.5 pages)

Essay on An Analysis of the Dred Scott Decision and The People Vs. Hall

- The People vs. Hall and Dread Scott Decision both were very interesting cases. Their similarities zoomed to expose the preamble of the Constitution and make the authors of it think over what they meant by "all men are created equal." This question is still present today, are all men created equal. Or does it mean by men, the white Americans with European decent. The People vs. Hall was a case of murder in 1854. A white man, George W. Hall, was blamed for a murder. A Chinese man was the witness of this murder....   [tags: American History, Legal Issues, Social Issues]

Free Essays
326 words (0.9 pages)

Essay on Dred Scott

- In this position paper I will explain the trials that Dred Scott had to go through in his life in his attempts for justice to be served. Dred Scott was born in 1799, and was an illiterate slave. His parents were slaves and so he was born the property of the Peter Blow family. In 1804 The United States took possesion of Missouri and after many debates on whether or not it would be a slavery state, a resolution known as the Missouri Compromise came along. This made a balance in the number of free and slave states, the problem was that Missouri was located right in the middle of what was the freedom and slavery....   [tags: essays research papers]

Better Essays
790 words (2.3 pages)